The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**
- Thread starter MSD Drifter
- 2,388 comments
- 173,473 views
- 28
- Oregon
- herbninja
^^ Looks good Horde:tup: The only thing I'd possibly change is the angle, the fireball looks a bit too bright and blurry. 8/10
STI17 by penguinlunacy, on Flickr
STI17 by penguinlunacy, on Flickr
- 176
- Omaha, NE
- backpain1
^^ Looks good Horde:tup: The only thing I'd possibly change is the angle, the fireball looks a bit too bright and blurry. 8/10
STI17 by penguinlunacy, on Flickr
Looks very good for a standard car, the backround is perfect, only the quilaty of the car lets this down
8/10
- 747
- London
- hlus_ua
- Ukrainian Hype
Great looking Photos ! Loving the composition ! i can't think of any improvements. 9/10 for me
NOW PLEASE* I would actually want to hear some real feedback on these shots ! what should i improve ? what should i work on. I would appreciate that. I don't want to hear "very nice, good looking etc." i need actual feedback Thanks
Realitycollection2 by UkrainianHype, on Flickr
First Try in photoshop toning
by UkrainianHype, on Flickr
- 1,511
- Michigan
- tahoe01
You did well on the washed out look. The lens flare looks nice on the first one, but the light source (sun) is not anywhere near the frame, so I wouldn't think the flare would be there, or you could add a bright overlay on the right side to emphasize that the sun is there.
The tones on the second one are nice. Not much to criticize about that.
8/10
Study this and tell me what to improve.
The tones on the second one are nice. Not much to criticize about that.
8/10
Study this and tell me what to improve.
Last edited:
- 2,234
- Parañaque, PH
- FD3S_Mat
- None
I like it! My only comment is that I think the front end blends in a bit too much with the sky. Nonetheless, 9.5/10! 
Diogo
(Banned)
- 4,638
- No, thanks
- 5,999
- Over there
- ask me
@ Eric1512
Very Nice shot.. really good use shot.. 10/10 from me...👍
Now one from me that I'm really unsure about.. give it to me straight
Very Nice shot.. really good use shot.. 10/10 from me...👍
Now one from me that I'm really unsure about.. give it to me straight
- 2,452
- Singapore
- lowzikai
^Fantastic pic ziggy:tup:
Very nice. Lighting is extremely good in this photo. White works really well with the car.
Aperture is just about right, focal point is an accurate hit, but the camera could be lifted a tiny bit to give a better composition.
Not under-exposed, nor over-exposed, and toning's really apt.
A tiny bit more of noise, would make it look a little bit better.
Great photo. 9.5/10 👍 👍
Click for lightbox!
- 6,694
- Dallas, TX
- 4,420
- nealcropper
Crooooooow
Not from me!
9/10. The background looks amazing!
Feedback? I'm a proper noob!
- 2,017
- Manchester
- MatthewPC1996
Not from me!
9/10. The background looks amazing!
Feedback? I'm a proper noob!
I would give that picture about a 5/10. To start with positives, you have captured the action well with the car braking for the first corner, and that their are no rough edges. However, the picture is a bit too blurry and I would of focused in on the car not the background.
Nürburgring Nordschleife_29 by MPC27, on Flickr
- 747
- London
- hlus_ua
- Ukrainian Hype
Well I like the contrast, and toning. However you can clearly see the highlights on a car , but you made a picture quite dark. Therefore i would add kind of a sun-flare coming form the top left corner ( just slightly brighter than the rest of the picture) As i said I really like the composition and speed effect, so I'll give it 8.5-9/10 just because i'd like to see some warm highlights. ;D
Here is next Rape It! Comment on every smallest bit you like or you don't like )
reality3 by UkrainianHype, on Flickr
Here is next
Rape It! Comment on every smallest bit you like or you don't like ) reality3 by UkrainianHype, on Flickr
- 1,541
- Mexico
- Yauma10
I feel the car is too centered and over exposed, also the tone it has (IMHO) doesn't fit well in Nurb, but in general it's a nice pic. 8/10
- 12,389
- Betelgeuse
- Beeblebrox_237
I think that I would give those an 8/10. The toning is nice and the desired effect is achieved very well, yet I find it a bit boring. If the car was bright red or red-orange I think it would suit the toning better, this colour might be better with some in-your-face editing. The sense of action is not bad, but I think the biggest weakness is the angle, it's just too ordinary.Overall, they're very good, but a bit forgettable IMHO.
How's this:
- 4,771
- New York
- GO6DoRiFUt0
- gtun3d
The angle/framing is very good, as well as the toning, but when viewed fullsize, there's a lot of artifacts, (Try duplicating the layer, adding noise, then reducing it to reduce artifacts, then using a soft eraser or transparency gradient fade/erase the parts that don't need the reducing) But my biggest gripe is the glow from the road line, it's distracting as all hell, but that may be my OCD 
. 7.5/10
. 7.5/10
- 12,389
- Betelgeuse
- Beeblebrox_237
The angle/framing is very good, as well as the toning, but when viewed fullsize, there's a lot of artifacts, (Try duplicating the layer, adding noise, then reducing it to reduce artifacts, then using a soft eraser or transparency gradient fade/erase the parts that don't need the reducing) But my biggest gripe is the glow from the road line, it's distracting as all hell, but that may be my OCD
Wait, what's an artifact?
![[Nor]MclarenF1](/forum/data/avatars/m/169/169289.jpg?1413287138){kind=avatar}
- 2,281
- Moss
- hoydeskrekk
It usualy manifests itself av color distortions - often purple or pinkish hues. You can see some artifacts on the sky in your photo.
Now then... Back to the task at hand.
I like the general concept and what's going on in the picture. However, there is room for improvement. First of all I think the car is a little too far to the left, it' almost touching the edge of the picture. Another thing is that it lacks a little edge, I would've loved to get those smoking wheels right up in my face, preferably with some fish eye-effect. Overall I would say it's not a bad photo but it is a little bland - and I know you can do sooo much better.
I give it a 6/10 (yes, I'm a cruel bastard).
So... Who wants to go next?
- 2,452
- Singapore
- lowzikai
[Nor]MclarenF1;7669461It usualy manifests itself av color distortions - often purple or pinkish hues. You can see some artifacts on the sky in your photo.
Now then... Back to the task at hand.
I like the general concept and what's going on in the picture. However, there is room for improvement. First of all I think the car is a little too far to the left, it' almost touching the edge of the picture. Another thing is that it lacks a little edge, I would've loved to get those smoking wheels right up in my face, preferably with some fish eye-effect. Overall I would say it's not a bad photo but it is a little bland - and I know you can do sooo much better.
I give it a 6/10 (yes, I'm a cruel bastard).
So... Who wants to go next?
Photo is neat. Not too much of problem. Colour of the car compliments the overall mood of the photo and the toning of it.
Not over of under exposed, you've hit the margin quite accurately.
Though, IMHO, I would prefer a tiny, tiny bit more of contrast. Framing, angle and composition is where it could be improved on.
The stock could be moved a little more to the right, amplifying the motion of the photo.
The, again IMHO, camera could also be slightly elevated and tilted to give more of the rear of the car for a slightly, albeit already good, picture a more realistic angle.
Focus of the photo could also be brought to the rear of the car instead of the side rear fender, as that's a pretty boring area to look at.
Take advantage of the magnificent arse of this car!
Overall, good photo, toning is apt, and the overall mood of the photo is felt, your editing is superb. 👍 But composition and framing could have a tiny bit of improvement to make the photo stand out from the rest-- not being too dull, y'know? This angle looks really ordinary and not really something that wows. 7.5/10
C&C welcome.
- 4,487
- YorkshireLand
- SVTlover
Just wanting a general opinion on the photo. Everything from angle, focal, effects etc.
- 4,771
- New York
- GO6DoRiFUt0
- gtun3d
C&C welcome.
Beautiful toning as always Jaden (Gonna have to swipe some techniques from ya )
The shot itself is great, a good sense of motion and drifting, plus the framing of the Toscana sun and curved roads give it a more "It's a Saturday night, I'm gonna go out and see how many tickets I can get in this thing" Open road hoonage feel.
Only problem, the vignetting has some major harsh lines on the bottom right corner as well as some line near the bottom that just cuts off suddenly.
8/10
) The shot itself is great, a good sense of motion and drifting, plus the framing of the Toscana sun and curved roads give it a more "It's a Saturday night, I'm gonna go out and see how many tickets I can get in this thing" Open road hoonage feel.
Only problem, the vignetting has some major harsh lines on the bottom right corner as well as some line near the bottom that just cuts off suddenly.
8/10
- 679
- U.K
- ZHENIJ
Just what you guys think overall
MGWQjPR7SVggJQLFwo_0_Hagrid_Cyborg_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
B2wzLw6f2dhqe0DzxA_0_Lucas_Skin_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
N9xUkzfv2tA78auqGc_0_Harry_Wall_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
MGWQjPR7SVggJQLFwo_0_Hagrid_Cyborg_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
B2wzLw6f2dhqe0DzxA_0_Lucas_Skin_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
N9xUkzfv2tA78auqGc_0_Harry_Wall_Film by Zhen2001, on Flickr
