Ultimate draft fail: Ryan Leaf.
Another couple winners:
Ben Roethlisberger
Larry Fitzgerald
Philip Rivers
A questionable one for me has to be the 2008 Dolphins draft. Brady Quinn reminds (reminded) me of Peyton Manning, so I thought it would've been epic to have him on our team. Tedd Ginn still isn't elite, but then again it took Larry Fitzgerald a little while to settle in too. At least we got John Beck. I still think he is a great QB, but he sucked during his starts because our O-line was still garbage. I think the QB spot should be solid between Pennington, Henne, and him, though.
And how about trade losers? I think we messed up by sending Wes Welker to New England. We did get Philip Merling in the draft (another winner with time, imo) out of it, though. Hopefully Devon Bes will grow to be even better than Welker. Welker was wide open on every single play that I saw him play. Pennington + Welker would've been a deadly duo this year. We all know how deadly he was with Tom Brady.