Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 963,897 views
"4WD hyper wagons"

Mercedes E63 AMG S 4Matic Wagon

OR

Mercedes CLS63 AMG S 4Matic Shooting Brake

OR

Audi RS6 Avant

I love these comparos! :lol:

I will easily take the CLS, that is one sexy car! I'm not a fan of wagons, but I would make an exception for these cars, they are all fantastic! I love Audis, but they just can't compete with a good Benz. The E Class' new look is something I'm not too sure about, the headlights are a bit too... blobby, but that's just me. I'm not saying I don't like the new styling, I'm just still making my mind up on it. The CLS is and has always been a superb-looking car though, so that's my choice, without a shadow of a doubt. Keep these comparos going!

E63 AMG Wagon for me! I'm probably one of the only people that likes the look of the new E-Class.

I know what you mean, I think it just takes some time to get used to the new styling.

Corvette Wagon

or

CTS-V Wagon

I think the CTS-V makes a better platform for a wagon, but I just can't pass up a Corvette! :lol: Either way, the car would be sold for a C 63 AMG saloon!

An actual, mid-engined Ferrari with unruly handling, or a "poor man's Ferrari" that is more drivable?


Ferrari 348 TB

or

Toyota MR2 Turbo (W20)

I'll easily take the actual Ferrari! I respect the MR2, but I could never own one, they're just too small and cutesy. Also, I'm sorry, but they just can't compare to a real Ferrari. I'm a sucker for old Ferrari styling anyway, so I was never going to pick the MR2.
 
If I included the specs on the Tango would it change your opinions? :sly:

Tango EV:

0-60: 3.2-4.0 seconds
1/4 mile: 12.2 seconds at 107mph
Top speed: 150mph
Power: 805hp
Torque: 3,000lb-ft


It also has 2,000 pounds of batteries mounted under the floor, so the center of gravity is extremely low, and therefore can keep up with many good sports cars on the track.

Burnout250.jpg
 
If I included the specs on the Tango would it change your opinions? :sly:

Tango EV:

0-60: 3.2-4.0 seconds
1/4 mile: 12.2 seconds at 107mph
Top speed: 150mph
Power: 805hp
Torque: 3,000lb-ft

That is quite impressive, but I still wouldn't drive it! I don't care how fast a car could be, if it looks that stupid; I'm NOT driving it!
That car is making me angry just by looking at it.
 
That is quite impressive, but I still wouldn't drive it! I don't care how fast a car could be, if it looks that stupid; I'm NOT driving it!
That car is making me angry just by looking at it.

^ Exactly why I didn't choose it. I assumed it was extremely fast in a straight line, but I just can't stand the thought of driving around in a car that looks like that.
 
^ Exactly why I didn't choose it. I assumed it was extremely fast in a straight line, but I just can't stand the thought of driving around in a car that looks like that.

Yup. Plus, I would look stupid in it. That things is kinda small and I'm a bit big, kinda the same reason why I won't own a Fiat 500 (even though I really like the 500).
 
I'll take the Colombian police car, but only because the Satellite is too boxy. Show me a Chevelle police car and I'll pick it in a heartbeat :lol:
 
The Ferrari 348 police car, it's probably worth more than that Plymouth Satelite and WTF; there's 3 plymouth models in 1970 and they all look the same. Why?!
 
Columbian police car. I like both very much, but I prefer the older car styling.
 
Paddy Wagons

Caprice Wagon

or

Focus ST Estate

I'll take the ST, gladly!

Volvo 240

or

Volvo 740 GL

And to think you call Mercedes "naff"... *grumble grumble*

I will take the 740, but only because the name has a larger number in it. I don't know much if anything about these cars and I won't pretend I do. I also don't like these cars, but I'll choose one for the sake of the comparo.
 
Volvo 740 I guess.

-----------------------
I'm going to do another WYR.

Sport Sedans:

2013 Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG Sedan
2012-Mercedes-Benz-C63-AMG-Sedan-left-front.jpg


2013 FPV Falcon GT
1A523A498DC0431992551249B3C8091F.jpg


or 2013 Jaguar XFR
Red-jaguar-xf-wallpaper.jpg
 
Ferrari 348 TB vs. Toyota MR2 Turbo - 348, it's a Ferrari....

Dodge Charger vs. Tango EV - I don't care how fast that "car" is, I'm not picking it. Let me have the Charger.

Ferrari 348 Colombian Police Car vs. Plymouth Satellite Seattle Police Car - Colombian for this cone, although the Satellite is nice.

Chevrolet Caprice Wagon vs. Ford Focus ST Estate - Focus, it's an ST and it's also not a Caprice.

Volvo 240 GL Estate vs. Volvo 740 GL Estate - 240, slightly less boxy.

Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG vs. FPV Falcon GT vs. Jaguar XFR - XFR. Just XFR.

Results:
1. Jaguar XFR
2. Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG
3. FPV Falcon GT
____
Battle of the body-styles!

Convertible
2012 BMW Z4 sDrive35is
2011-bmw-z4-sdrive35is-9_1600x0w.jpg


vs.

Coupe
2013 Hyundai Genesis 3.8 R-Spec
2013_Hyundai_Genesis_Coupe_3.8_R-Spec_--_06-15-2012_1.JPG


vs.

Hatchback
2014 Audi RS3
02-rs3.jpg


vs.

SUV
2013 Porsche Cayenne GTS
Porsche-Cayenne-2013-6.jpg


vs.

Sedan
2013 Dodge Charger R/T Blacktop
2013-dodge-charger-r-t-bl_800x0w.jpg


vs.

Wagon
2014 Audi RS4 Avant
AUDI-RS4-AVANT-audi-32970043-1280-850.jpg
 
Sport Sedans:

2013 Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG Sedan

2013 FPV Falcon GT

or 2013 Jaguar XFR

The XFR was a nice addition, but nothing can top a C63 in my book :lol: I'll take the C63, especially since it's the Saloon instead of the Coupe.

Battle of the body-styles!

Convertible
2012 BMW Z4 sDrive35is

vs.

Coupe
2013 Hyundai Genesis 3.8 R-Spec

vs.

Hatchback
2014 Audi RS3

vs.

SUV
2013 Porsche Cayenne GTS

vs.

Sedan
2013 Dodge Charger R/T Blacktop

vs.

Wagon
2014 Audi RS4 Avant

Another great comparo idea!

I'll take the Charger Saloon, but only because of my love for saloons. If I were to pick them based on the actual car, then the RS4 would be what I choose. I'm not a big fan of the new Charger, but since this was a "Battle of the body styles", the saloon is what I would take.
 
Back