Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 962,267 views
Nissan Skyline GTS-T vs. Subaru Impreza WRX vs. Toyota Celica GT-Four vs. Holden Commodore SS vs. Toyota Supra vs. BMW 540i - WRX by default. ;) Then 540i by default.

Results:
1. Subaru Impreza WRX
2. BMW 540i
3. Toyota Celica GT-Four
4. Nissan Skyline GTS-T
5. Toyota Supra
6. Holden Commodore SS
 
Commodore for me because it's N/A, then the BMW, and I don't care what order the rest of the cars come in as long as the Subaru is last.
 
and I don't care what order the rest of the cars come in as long as the Subaru is last.
crying-celebrity-gifs-lauren-conrad.gif
 
Of those choice of cars, I would pick the Toyota Celica GT-Four ST185. My 2nd choice is the skyline.
--------------------------

Lexus LFA Nurburgring
Lexus-LFA-Nurburgring-1.jpg


or

Ferrari 599 GTO
2011-ferrari-599-gto-2.jpg
 
1994 Nissan Skyline R33 GTS-T vs. 1998 Subaru Impreza GF8 WRX Hatch vs. 1990 Toyota Celica ST185R GT-Four vs. 2000 Holden Commodore VT II SS vs. 1986 Toyota Supra MA70 vs. 1994 BMW 540i E34

First of all, the BMW's out as I fear the electrical and electronics issues...or because of whatever parts which will break down sooner or later. I have heard bad things about the reliability of BMWs from that era. I don't know about the Holden, but I have a bad feeling about it and I don't like the look of its front grille, so that's also out. Not really a fan of wagon Imprezas, and the paint in combination with the darkened taillights and the black rims doesn't look so good to me. The Skyline GTS-T's rims don't fit the looks - bling just doesn't go nicely with brawny and robustious in a restrained, subdued manner, and I may be wrong, but the reliability of a 90s Nissan isn't so good compared to that of a Honda or Toyota from the same era.

It leaves me with the Supra and the Celica-GT-Four. I'm a huge lover of the Celica GT-Four, partly due to Sega Rally in my childhood. (although it was the ST205 generation in the game) The Supra looks nice and clean but it doesn't produce the same effect on me. Both are from the same manufacturers, but one is from the 90s, the other one is from the 80s...I think the 90s one is safer. The Celica has been driven for more miles, and the four-wheel drive system may cause more problems...I don't know. I'll still take the Celica GT-Four anyway.


Lexus LFA with the Nürburgring Package vs. Ferrari 599 GTO

The 599 GTO. If the 599 is the standard GTB Fiorano or even the one with the HGTE package, I'll take the LFA though, even without the Nürburgring Package. I'm not pleased with the way the 599 GTB Fiorano's smiling. The newer grille on the GTO makes it look much better. To me, the 599 GTB Fiorano speaks luxury at first sight, but the 599 GTO speaks aggression, sportiness, and driving fun.
 
Lexus LFA Nurburgring Edition vs. Ferrari 599 GTO - GTO, same reason as @AudiMan2011.

2013 Mazda Mazda2
2014-mazda-2-photo-539705-s-1280x782.jpg


vs.

2013 Kia Rio Hatchback
2013-kia-rio_100389753_l.jpg


vs.

2014 Ford Fiesta Hatchback
2014-Ford-Fiesta.jpg


vs.

2013 Chevrolet Spark
2013-Chevrolet-Spark-front-rear-three-quarters.jpg


vs.

2013 Hyundai Accent Hatchback
2013-hyundai-accent-front-view-pictures.jpg
 
Last edited:
Cheap performance: I'm gonna have to go with the Celica GT Four. Because Toyota fanboy and it's a lot more special than a MK3 Supra.

LFA vs Ferrari: LFA please, the 599 is probably one of my least favorite Ferraris and I LOVE the LFA anyway.

Hatchbacks: Mazda 2 I guess because it's the least sucky.
 
LFA vs Ferrari: Ferrari. I do not like the LFA whatsoever.

Hatchbacks: Like none of them. I cannot stand that body style on anything, it looks so stupid. If I was forced, I'd take the Fiesta and sell it to buy something else, immediately. :yuck:



2013 Mustang GT/CS 5.0

SV1_4294.jpg



vs


1968 Mustang GT/CS 7.0L

Potter-GTCS-390-1024x767.jpg
 
For my WYR I'd take the 540i because of the ones there that isn't the Holden it's the cleanest-looking and it's an E34.

LFA vs. Ferrari: LFA for the same reason as @AudiMan2011 .

Hatchbacks: Between the Rio and Fiesta for me. The Accent looks bland and isn't as well-equipped, the Mazda 2 is exactly the same as the Fiesta except the Fiesta's chassis is a little tighter and again the 2 isn't as well equipped, and I absolutely hate the Barina Spark with a passion. The Rio has warranty and a more punchy engine on its side while the Fiesta has Euro-chic (even though it's made in Thailand for the AUDM) and is more fun to drive. Since it would most likely become a daily driver I'd take the Rio.

2013 Mustang GT/CS vs. 1968 Mustang GT/CS: Probably the late-model Mustang because I'd be less scared of scratching it.
 
I'll take the Mazda2 and the 1968 Mustang.



US-market base model compact sedans:



2014 Toyota Corolla L

2014-toyota-corolla-l_100437790_l.jpg


2014 Honda Civic Sedan LX
c150ebfac273913fb51ea771160587c2x.jpg


2014 Nissan Versa Sedan S
2014_Nissan_Versa_Sedan_S_910755.jpg


2014 Mazda 3 4-Door i SV
2014-mazda-mazda3-503-p1.jpg


2014 Mitsubishi Lancer ES Sedan
wicked-white-d.jpg


2014 Subaru Impreza Sedan 2.0i
35b429bb2ccf998410d3cf6ced567b4dx.jpg


2014 Hyundai Elantra Sedan SE

new-2014-hyundai-elantra-4drsdnautose-10149-11504633-1-640.jpg


2014 Kia Forte Sedan LX
new-2014-kia-forte-4drsdnautolx-5691-10455823-2-640.jpg


2014 Chevrolet Cruze LS
2014-Chevrolet-Cruze-Sedan-LS-Manual-4dr-Sedan-Photo-1.png


2014 Ford Focus S Sedan
2014_Ford_Focus_S_Sedan_903074.png


2014 Dodge Dart SE
2014_Dodge_Dart_SE_1196631.jpg


2014 Volkswagen Jetta S
2014_Volkswagen_Jetta_S_986359.jpg
 
That's just a lancer. Lol. But if we can't choose the Focus hatchback, I guess I'd take the new Corolla. I drove that thing and it's actually not too bad. It's got paddle shifters and a manual mode, it's trying to be cool again!
 
Same car.

Wat.jpg


Similar exterior contours and similar interior layout, and that's about it, more or less. Other than that, the Evo's a highly different car underneath.

But...something tells me you know that already. Too quick to decide on defending yourself instead of admitting the careless mistake? That happens with me for several times - not happy about people knowing that I wrongly stated something, I proceeded by being adamant that I was partially right, hoping to make myself look less ignorant to them, yet eventually ending up with me feeling that I look more ignorant than before the reiteration. Or were you just kidding about it being the same car? Or...were you just trying to say that you choose it because it looks a lot like the Lancer Evolution X and you really like the way that Evo looks?

Umm...I'm not sure why I'm posting this though. Just feeling like it. It's not that I'm trying to be provocative or anything.
 
Last edited:
Ford Fiesta because it's the best car there, Ford Mustang 5.0 overall better than the old one, Volkswagen because Volkswagen.
 
Back