Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 972,589 views
Toyota GT-86 vs Mazda MX-5 Miata; Gimme that MX-5!

Nissan GT-R vs Porsche 911 GT2 vs Chevrolet Corvette C6 vs Dodge Viper SRT-10 ACR; VIPER!!! Do I even have to say why?
 
BMW, by an incredibly slim margin.

GT86 for now, but I'd like to wait until I see the ND's specs.

Porsche, by a small margin over the ZR1, which wins over the GT-R, with the Viper in a very, very distant last.
 
Murican big 3:

60's full-size powerful sedans.

65 Impala.
65-impala.jpg


Or

65 Fairlane.
5791681633_ce4e5c83e8_z.jpg


Or

65 Dart.
65dart4.jpg



70's SUVs:
75 Suburban.

1973-Chevrolet-Subu_300758a.jpg


Or.

75 Bronco.
75-bronco-1.jpg


Or.

75 Dodge Ramcharger.
B29976.jpg


80's Pickup trucks:

85 Chevy.
41031498_2.jpg


85 Ford.
1985-Ford-F-150-the-80s-3649681-520-390.jpg


85 Dodge.
85dodgerambyrcarden_1.jpg


90's Hatchbacks:
95 Escort.
5438485371_4099691a56_z.jpg


Or.

95 Beretta (Mechanically, it's a Corsica, just in hatchback form).
CC-SM74-100-800.jpg


Or.

95 Dodge Stealth hatchback.
1996_dodge_stealth_coupe_rt-turbo_fq_oem_1_500.jpg


2000s sedans:

2005 Fusion:
2005_Ford_Fusion-1.jpg


Or.

2005 Impala.
2005Impala-O2.jpg


Or.

2005 Stratus.
2005-dodge-stratus.jpg


2010s: V8 Muscle.

2014 Mustang GT.
Ford-Mustang_GT_2011_1600x1200_wallpaper_01-e1370545861647.jpg


Or.

2014 Camaro SS.
Chevrolet-Camaro_SS_2014_800x600_wallpaper_01.jpg


Or.

2014 Challenger R/T.

740x470_Challenger_BilletSilver.png





60's:
Chevy.
Ford.
Dodge.

70's:
Chevy.
Ford.
Dodge.

80's:
Ford.
Chevy.
Dodge.

90's:
Ford.
Dodge.
Chevy.

00's:
Ford.
Dodge.
Chevy.

10's:
Dodge.
Ford.
Chevy.

Edit: Fiesta.
 
Time to catch up. :crazy:

604, easily.

The Peugeot again.

4TC. It's so ugly, beautiful, and interesting at the same time.

605. The XM is too blocky.

Peugeot wins here too.

The Tesla. It's one of my dream cars (but not one of my favorites, however.)

Results:
1. Tesla Model S
2. Jaguar XJ
3. Audi A8
4. Mercedes-Benz S-Class
5. BMW 7-Series

Charger. It's just...so amazing.

2014 DMC Design McLaren 12C Velocita Wind Edition
ic24ug.jpg


or

2013 Vorsteiner McLaren 12C
2013+Vorsteiner+McLaren+MP4-12C.jpg


or

2013 McLaren 12C MSO
gtspirit-12c-MSO.jpg

Vorsteiner.

Incredibly rare Muscle cars:

1970 Plymouth Hemi Superbird: 135 produced.
1970-Plymouth-Hemi-Superbird.jpg




Or:

1969 ZL1 427 Camaro: 69 Made.
1969-Chevrolet-Camaro-ZL-1.jpg




Or:

1967 Ford Fairlane 500 R-Code: 57 made.
1967-Ford-Fairlane-500-R-Code.jpg




Or:

1967 Plymouth RO23 GTX: 55 made.
1967-Plymouth-R023-GTX.jpg




1970-71 Plymouth Hemi Cuda Convertible: 21 made.
Plymouth-Hemi-Cuda-Convertible.jpg




I choose:

Camaro.
Cuda Vert.
Superbird.
GTX.
Fairlane.

Round two, with the top 5 rarest, coming up in a bit.

I choose the Second Mclaren.

I'll have the Fairlane.

I'm gonna do it. There are Corvettes in it, but they're almost muscle cars, so I'm gonna keep them in.

1967 Chevrolet Corvette L88: 20.
1967-Chevrolet-Corvette-L88.jpg




Or:

1970 Chevelle SS 454 LS6: 20.
1970-Chevrolet-Chevelle-SS-454-LS6.jpg




Or:

1971 Pontiac GTO Judge Convertible: 17.
1971-Pontiac-GTO-Judge-Convertible.jpg




Or:

1969 Chevrolet Corvette ZL1: 3.
1969-Chevrolet-Corvette-ZL-1.jpg




Or:

1967/1970 Dodge Coronet R/T 426 Hemi Convertible: 2.
Dodge-Coronet-RT-426-Hemi-Convertible.jpg




I choose:
The ZL1 vette.
The Chevelle, by a margin so close, words can't describe exactly how close it is.
GTO.
Coronet.
L88.

Chevelle. Never realized they were that rare.

New_510_005.jpg

Datsun 510

or

1306_Toyota-Corolla-Levin-AE86.jpg

Toyota AE86

The cars can be any body style of your choice and can be modified.

Datsun, by an uncountable amount of miles.


Nova.

Nova.

Stock4_Rear-Driver-Angle_large.jpg

or
Carrera 4S
media

Porsche.

Chevrolet Nova SS vs Dodge Coronet R/T; Nova SS

Nissan GT-R vs Porsche 911; I guess the GT-R.

--------------------

2014 Buick Verano Turbo
2014-buick-verano-turbo-right-side.jpg


or

2015 Ford Focus ST
focus-st-2015.jpg

Ford.


Daytona. Always liked the lines of the Charger more.

Saab vs Volvo

Round 1: 60s small family cars

Saab 96
View attachment 217717

Volvo 544
View attachment 217719

Round 2: Large 80s sedans

Saab 9000
View attachment 217724

Volvo 240
View attachment 217725

Round 3: 90 compact exclusive cars

Saab 900
View attachment 217728

Volvo S40
View attachment 217729

Round 4: early 00s wagons

Saab 9-5 Wagon
View attachment 217730

Volvo V70
View attachment 217731

Round 5: modern sedans

Saab 9-5
View attachment 217741

Volvo S80
View attachment 217742

I'm gonna pass on this.

EDIT:
^ Saab, Volvo, Saab, Volvo, Saab. The wagon one was hard but had to go Volvo
Combo round! :lol:
1997 Porsche 911 (993) Turbo with about 30K miles at $130k
993TT_8_7700_1024.jpg

+
1989 Ferrari Testarossa with around 20K miles for $80K
testarossa-5.jpg


OR
Brand spanking new (200 miles) 2014 Ferrari California for $220K
$_4.JPG

Porsche. Easy.

Saabs vs Volvos;
Round 1 - I would pick the Volvo
Other Rounds - I would pick the Saabs

Porsche 993 Turbo vs Ferrari 512 TR vs Ferrari California; Porsche 991 Turbo! I love that generation of the 911 so much, that model is what got me interested in Porsches in the first place.

-------------------------------------------------

BMW Z3 M Coupe
bmw-z3-m-coupe-03.jpg


or


Subaru Impreza WRX Coupe Sti (GC8)
Subbe-754895.jpg

Subaru, by a billion miles.

Toyota GT86

Toyota-GT-86-474x316-9a4c3cf068ae9cb1.jpg


Mazda MX5 Miata ND

Mazda-MX-5-ND-front-and-rear.jpg

Toyota.

chevy-corvette-z06-vs-dodge-viper-srt10-acr-nissan-gt-r-porsche-911-gt2-photo-211932-s-429x262.jpg

I choose the vette.

Vette, because V8. :P

2014 Ford Fiesta Hatchback
2014-Ford-Fiesta-03.jpg


2014 Dacia Sandero
Dacia_Sandero_TCe_90_eco%C2%B2_Laur%C3%A9ate_(II)_%E2%80%93_Frontansicht,_21._April_2013,_M%C3%BCnster.jpg


or

2014 Volkswagen UP
2014-volkswagen-e-up-front-three-quarters.jpg


I bet some of you guys know why I picked these 3 cars.

Uh. I'll have the Ford I guess.

Murican big 3:

60's full-size powerful sedans.

65 Impala.
65-impala.jpg


Or

65 Fairlane.
5791681633_ce4e5c83e8_z.jpg


Or

65 Dart.
65dart4.jpg



70's SUVs:
75 Suburban.

1973-Chevrolet-Subu_300758a.jpg


Or.

75 Bronco.
75-bronco-1.jpg


Or.

75 Dodge Ramcharger.
B29976.jpg


80's Pickup trucks:

85 Chevy.
41031498_2.jpg


85 Ford.
1985-Ford-F-150-the-80s-3649681-520-390.jpg


85 Dodge.
85dodgerambyrcarden_1.jpg


90's Hatchbacks:
95 Escort.
5438485371_4099691a56_z.jpg


Or.

95 Beretta (Mechanically, it's a Corsica, just in hatchback form).
CC-SM74-100-800.jpg


Or.

95 Dodge Stealth hatchback.
1996_dodge_stealth_coupe_rt-turbo_fq_oem_1_500.jpg


2000s sedans:

2005 Fusion:
2005_Ford_Fusion-1.jpg


Or.

2005 Impala.
2005Impala-O2.jpg


Or.

2005 Stratus.
2005-dodge-stratus.jpg


2010s: V8 Muscle.

2014 Mustang GT.
Ford-Mustang_GT_2011_1600x1200_wallpaper_01-e1370545861647.jpg


Or.

2014 Camaro SS.
Chevrolet-Camaro_SS_2014_800x600_wallpaper_01.jpg


Or.

2014 Challenger R/T.

740x470_Challenger_BilletSilver.png





60's:
Chevy.
Ford.
Dodge.

70's:
Chevy.
Ford.
Dodge.

80's:
Ford.
Chevy.
Dodge.

90's:
Ford.
Dodge.
Chevy.

00's:
Ford.
Dodge.
Chevy.

10's:
Dodge.
Ford.
Chevy.

Edit: Fiesta.

Impala (I find 65 Fairlanes incredibly ugly), easily the Ford for both SUVs and trucks, Stealth, Fusion, and Mustang, since I hate newer Camaros, and find the Challenger WAY too fat. (Not that the Mustang isn't either :lol:).
 
Dagger's post:

Round 1 - Ford Fairlane

Round 2 - Ford Bronco

Round 3 - Ford F-150

Round 4 - Dodge Stealth (especially if it's a Twin Turbo model), because Mitsubishi 3000GT!

Round 5 - Ford Fusion

Round 6 - Ford Mustang GT 5.0 (not surprising right), I don't see any reason for me to pick any of the others over the Mustang.
 
911 > Vette > GTR > Viper

Up > Fiesta > Dacia

Fairlane > Impala > Dart

Suburban > Ram > Bronco

80s truck : Chevy > Ford > Dodge

90s coupe : Beretta > Escort > Stealth

Oo sedan : Impala > Fusion > Stra-wTF

new Muscle : Camaro > Charger > Stang... it would seem that i keep on changing the order with each itiration of the same question lol...
 
GT86 vs MX-5:
1. Subaru BRZ
2. MX5
3. GT86

Supercars:
1. Porsche
2. GTR
3. Vette
4. Viper

Economy cars:
1. Up!
2. Fiesta
3. Sandero

American 60s Full-size:
1. Fairlane
2. Dart
3. Impala

American 70s SUVs:
1. Bronco
2. Ramcharger
3. Suburban

American 80s pickups:
1. Ford
2. Ram
3. Chevrolet

American 90s hatchbacks:
1. Stealth (It's Mitsubishi 3000GT)
2. Escort
3. Beretta (First time Chevy was close to not being last)

American 00s sedans:
1. Fusion
2. Stratus
3. Impala

American modern muscle:
1. Mustang
2. Challenger
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8. Camaro
 
chevy-corvette-z06-vs-dodge-viper-srt10-acr-nissan-gt-r-porsche-911-gt2-photo-211932-s-429x262.jpg

I choose the vette.

Viper ACR. Pretty easy.

2014 Ford Fiesta Hatchback
2014-Ford-Fiesta-03.jpg


2014 Dacia Sandero
Dacia_Sandero_TCe_90_eco%C2%B2_Laur%C3%A9ate_(II)_%E2%80%93_Frontansicht,_21._April_2013,_M%C3%BCnster.jpg


or

2014 Volkswagen UP
2014-volkswagen-e-up-front-three-quarters.jpg


I bet some of you guys know why I picked these 3 cars.

Ford Fiesta.

Murican big 3:

60's full-size powerful sedans.

65 Impala.
65-impala.jpg


Or

65 Fairlane.
5791681633_ce4e5c83e8_z.jpg


Or

65 Dart.
65dart4.jpg



70's SUVs:
75 Suburban.

1973-Chevrolet-Subu_300758a.jpg


Or.

75 Bronco.
75-bronco-1.jpg


Or.

75 Dodge Ramcharger.
B29976.jpg


80's Pickup trucks:

85 Chevy.
41031498_2.jpg


85 Ford.
1985-Ford-F-150-the-80s-3649681-520-390.jpg


85 Dodge.
85dodgerambyrcarden_1.jpg


90's Hatchbacks:
95 Escort.
5438485371_4099691a56_z.jpg


Or.

95 Beretta (Mechanically, it's a Corsica, just in hatchback form).
CC-SM74-100-800.jpg


Or.

95 Dodge Stealth hatchback.
1996_dodge_stealth_coupe_rt-turbo_fq_oem_1_500.jpg


2000s sedans:

2005 Fusion:
2005_Ford_Fusion-1.jpg


Or.

2005 Impala.
2005Impala-O2.jpg


Or.

2005 Stratus.
2005-dodge-stratus.jpg


2010s: V8 Muscle.

2014 Mustang GT.
Ford-Mustang_GT_2011_1600x1200_wallpaper_01-e1370545861647.jpg


Or.

2014 Camaro SS.
Chevrolet-Camaro_SS_2014_800x600_wallpaper_01.jpg


Or.

2014 Challenger R/T.

740x470_Challenger_BilletSilver.png

60's full-size powerful sedans: Impala. Not a fan of the Ford and I wouldn't have a 4 door if I had a Dart.
70's SUVs: Suburban. They're pretty s4wg.
80's Pickup trucks: Easily the Sla- I mean Ford.
90's Hatchbacks: Whichever one doesn't make me fall asleep.
2000s sedans: The Stratus is immediately out. It's a tough one between the Impala and the Fusion. I've been in both but more in the Impala. Hmm. I loved the Fusion but I also love the Impala. I don't know I guess give me the Impala.
2010s V8 Muscle: Camaro is immediately out. I like the Challenger but I like the Mustang just a wee bit more.



F12berlinetta-based Special Projects


Ferrari SP America
ferrari-sp-america-image-via-the-supercar-kids_100471086_l.jpg



or


Ferrari F12 TRS
Ferrari-F12-TRS.jpg

SP America
 
Catching up.
Sabbs vs volvos
96, 9000, s40, 9-5, s80, testarosa, Subaru, Miata, viper, ford, dart, suburban, dodge, stealth, fusion, SS, sa.
 
New_510_005.jpg

Datsun 510

or

1306_Toyota-Corolla-Levin-AE86.jpg

Toyota AE86

The cars can be any body style of your choice and can be modified.
I really want both...that's too hard! I guess I'll take the AE86.
Coronet. I love the Coronet.
Nova.

Stock4_Rear-Driver-Angle_large.jpg

or
Carrera 4S
media
I used to love the GT-R, now I really don't. I'll take the 911.
2014 Buick Verano Turbo
2014-buick-verano-turbo-right-side.jpg


or

2015 Ford Focus ST
focus-st-2015.jpg
Focus. That has to be one of the easiest comparos ever posted here.
Superbird, I like the black on the headlights.
Round 1: 60s small family cars

Saab 96
View attachment 217717

Volvo 544
View attachment 217719
The Volvo, although I really like the 96 too.
Round 2: Large 80s sedans

Saab 9000
View attachment 217724

Volvo 240
View attachment 217725
9000 easily.
Round 3: 90 compact exclusive cars

Saab 900
View attachment 217728

Volvo S40
View attachment 217729
The Saab again.
Round 4: early 00s wagons

Saab 9-5 Wagon
View attachment 217730

Volvo V70
View attachment 217731
And again.
Round 5: modern sedans

Saab 9-5
View attachment 217741

Volvo S80
View attachment 217742
The 9-5. There's barely any of those around.
EDIT:
^ Saab, Volvo, Saab, Volvo, Saab. The wagon one was hard but had to go Volvo
Combo round! :lol:
1997 Porsche 911 (993) Turbo with about 30K miles at $130k
993TT_8_7700_1024.jpg

+
1989 Ferrari Testarossa with around 20K miles for $80K
testarossa-5.jpg


OR
Brand spanking new (200 miles) 2014 Ferrari California for $220K
$_4.JPG
Testarossa and 911, that was easy.
BMW Z3 M Coupe
bmw-z3-m-coupe-03.jpg


or


Subaru Impreza WRX Coupe Sti (GC8)
Subbe-754895.jpg
Obviously the STi.
Toyota GT86

Toyota-GT-86-474x316-9a4c3cf068ae9cb1.jpg


Mazda MX5 Miata ND

Mazda-MX-5-ND-front-and-rear.jpg
GT86, the ND is ugly.
chevy-corvette-z06-vs-dodge-viper-srt10-acr-nissan-gt-r-porsche-911-gt2-photo-211932-s-429x262.jpg

I choose the vette.
The 911. That's a GT3, right?

Results:
1. Porsche 911 GT3
2. Dodge Viper ACR
3. Chevrolet Corvette
4. Nissan GT-R

2014 Ford Fiesta Hatchback
2014-Ford-Fiesta-03.jpg


2014 Dacia Sandero
Dacia_Sandero_TCe_90_eco%C2%B2_Laur%C3%A9ate_(II)_%E2%80%93_Frontansicht,_21._April_2013,_M%C3%BCnster.jpg


or

2014 Volkswagen UP
2014-volkswagen-e-up-front-three-quarters.jpg


I bet some of you guys know why I picked these 3 cars.
The Fiesta, although they're all really nice.

Results:
1. Ford Fiesta
2. Dacia Sandero
3. Volkswagen Up!
Murican big 3:

60's full-size powerful sedans.

65 Impala.
65-impala.jpg


Or

65 Fairlane.
5791681633_ce4e5c83e8_z.jpg


Or

65 Dart.
65dart4.jpg
Fairlane, because the Fairlane is awesome.

Results:
1. Ford Fairlane
2. Chevrolet Impala
3. Dodge Dart
70's SUVs:
75 Suburban.

1973-Chevrolet-Subu_300758a.jpg


Or.

75 Bronco.
75-bronco-1.jpg


Or.

75 Dodge Ramcharger.
B29976.jpg
Bronco, easily.

Results:
1. Ford Bronco
2. Dodge Ramcharger
3. Chevrolet Suburban
80's Pickup trucks:

85 Chevy.
41031498_2.jpg


85 Ford.
1985-Ford-F-150-the-80s-3649681-520-390.jpg


85 Dodge.
85dodgerambyrcarden_1.jpg
The Ford, although there's not many exterior differences between all of these.

Results:
1. Ford F-150
2. Dodge RAM
3. Chevrolet whatever it is
90's Hatchbacks:
95 Escort.
5438485371_4099691a56_z.jpg


Or.

95 Beretta (Mechanically, it's a Corsica, just in hatchback form).
CC-SM74-100-800.jpg


Or.

95 Dodge Stealth hatchback.
1996_dodge_stealth_coupe_rt-turbo_fq_oem_1_500.jpg
Beretta. I love its looks.

Results:
1. Chevrolet Beretta
2. Dodge Stealth
3. Ford Escort
2005 Fusion:
2005_Ford_Fusion-1.jpg


Or.

2005 Impala.
2005Impala-O2.jpg


Or.

2005 Stratus.
2005-dodge-stratus.jpg
I'll take the Stratus.

Results:
1. Dodge Stratus
2. Chevrolet Impala
3. Ford Fusion

2010s: V8 Muscle.

2014 Mustang GT.
Ford-Mustang_GT_2011_1600x1200_wallpaper_01-e1370545861647.jpg


Or.

2014 Camaro SS.
Chevrolet-Camaro_SS_2014_800x600_wallpaper_01.jpg


Or.

2014 Challenger R/T.

740x470_Challenger_BilletSilver.png
The Mustank.

Results:
1. Ford Mustang GT 5.0
2. Dodge Challenger R/T
3. Chevrolet Camaro SS
F12berlinetta-based Special Projects


Ferrari SP America
ferrari-sp-america-image-via-the-supercar-kids_100471086_l.jpg



or


Ferrari F12 TRS
Ferrari-F12-TRS.jpg
TRS. I don't like the SP America's rear that much.
 
ZR1 vs GT2 vs GTR vs ACR: The 911 GT2 by a very long ways. Because Porsche mainly. Plus the rest I'd really have no interest in owning.

Fiesta vs Sandero vs Up: I guess the Fiesta? I'd rather have none though.

Ford vs Chevy vs Dodge

1: The Impala by a huge margin, I absolutely love the old Impalas.

2: Eh, I guess the Ramcharger because they're kinda cool.

3: Well I'd rather have none, but I guess I like the look of the Dodge the most so sure, that.

4: Oh god, none please. But if I had to choose, I GUESS the Stealth.

5: More which I'd rather not own, but I guess the Impala for reasons.

6: Finally, one with something I wouldn't mind having. I'd go with the Camaro SS, it's not my favorite Camaro, but it's not a Mustang and the Challenger is to heavy.

F12s: Ehh.. I don't like the F12 but I guess the TRS.
 
Back