Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 963,995 views
Superbird.

57 Harley Sportster:

Sportster-1.jpg


Or

2015 Harley Superlow 1200T.
14-hd-superlow-1200t-bs.jpg


I'll take the old one.

-----

2014 Ferrari 458 speciale.
nuova-458-speciale_4.jpg


Or

1963 Corvette Z06.
122612_13.jpg


I'm taking the vette.

-----

Mclaren P1 (roughly 1.1 million dollars)
321021.jpg


67 Cobra (Roughly 1.1 million dollars, depending on miles)
'67_AC_Cobra_(Crusin'_At_The_Boardwalk_'10).jpg


Car pictured is likely a replica, but we're going by the real thing. Cobra for me.
 
Bikes: Old

New Ferrari vs Old Corvette: 458 looks ugly and C2 is one of the best looking cars. Corvette

P1 vs Cobra: Cobra
 
Mercedes/Dodge Sprinter
Plymouth Superbird

@Dagger311 what? '57 Sportster has no relation with the Superflow 1200, other than having two wheels. The P1 and 458 Speciale are completely different cars compared to the 'Vette and Cobra. Should have done old vs. new by the same manufacturers.

That said,

'57 Sportster
'63 'Vette
'67 Cobra
 
Mercedes/Dodge Sprinter
Plymouth Superbird

@Dagger311 what? '57 Sportster has no relation with the Superflow 1200, other than having two wheels. The P1 and 458 Speciale are completely different cars compared to the 'Vette and Cobra. Should have done old vs. new by the same manufacturers.

That said,

'57 Sportster
'63 'Vette
'67 Cobra
I chose the most expensive new Harley versus one of my favorite bikes of all time, and the others I tried to match up based on price. If it was old vs new from the same model/manufacturer, that's highly overdone.
 
New to this so I'll just post a response to the most recent pics:

- The 57 Harley (it looks great; the newer one seems to have lost some 'rawness')
- 458 (liked the original from when I first saw it, so an easy pick; the Vette does look good though)
- P1 (the Cobra is probably more of a joy to drive but I'd prefer to take the P1 for a spin around a track)
 
Minis :D:

1964 Austin Mini Cooper S 1071
Austin Mini Cooper S 1071 .jpg


1969 Mini 1275GT
06.jpg


1969 Morris Mini Cooper S 1275
02.jpg


1991 Rover Mini Cooper
07.jpg


1997 Rover Mini Cooper
Rover Mini Cooper.jpg
 
Time for something a little different...
1. Fiat Ducato/Peugeot Boxter/Citroen Jumper/Ram ProMaster/Something Whatever
citroen_jumper_wallpaper_4x800x600.jpg

2. Ford Transit
Ford_Transit_2007.JPG

3. Mercedes Sprinter
Mercedes_sprinter_2_v_sst.jpg

4. Gazelle
1720.jpg

5. Renault Master
Renault_master.JPG

1. Ford Transit
2. Mercedes Sprinter
3. Fiat
4. Citroen
5. Peugeot
6. Renault
7. Gazelle
As this thread is a little slow, while playing a vídeo game, to honor 2 of my favourite american icons.

So, would you rather...? (judge the car, not colors. Please leave feedback on your favourite color, if you wish). :)

Dodge Charger Daytona

Dodge-Charger_Daytona_1969_1024x768_wallpaper_02.jpg

or...

Plymouth Superbird

plymouth-superbird-02.jpg

For me, the Superbird (my choice) has something more...

Superbird

Superbird.

57 Harley Sportster:

Sportster-1.jpg


Or

2015 Harley Superlow 1200T.
14-hd-superlow-1200t-bs.jpg


I'll take the old one.

2015.

Dagger311
-----

2014 Ferrari 458 speciale.
nuova-458-speciale_4.jpg


Or

1963 Corvette Z06.
122612_13.jpg


I'm taking the vette.

458 Speciale

Dagger311
-----

Mclaren P1 (roughly 1.1 million dollars)
321021.jpg


67 Cobra (Roughly 1.1 million dollars, depending on miles)
'67_AC_Cobra_(Crusin'_At_The_Boardwalk_'10).jpg


Car pictured is likely a replica, but we're going by the real thing. Cobra for me.

P1.

Minis :D:

1964 Austin Mini Cooper S 1071
View attachment 233237

1969 Mini 1275GT
View attachment 233240

1969 Morris Mini Cooper S 1275
View attachment 233239

1991 Rover Mini Cooper
View attachment 233243

1997 Rover Mini Cooper
View attachment 233242

1. 1964 Austin Mini Cooper S 1071
2. 1969 Morris Mini Cooper S 1275
3. 1969 Mini 1275GT
4. 1991 Rover Mini Cooper
5. 1997 Rover Mini Cooper
 
2014 E63 AMG:

2014-mercedes-benz-e63-s-amg-front-three-quarter-in-motion.jpg


Or:

BMW M5 Competition Pack:
2014-bmw-m5-side-in-motion.jpg


I'm gonna go with the BMW. I like Mercedes as a company better, but that grille is really offsetting.
 
Edit: Small RR cars:
1. Fiat 500
2. Autobianchi Bianchina
3. ZAZ 965

Volkswagen Golf GTIs:

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk1)
View attachment 227609

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk2)
View attachment 227610

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk3)
View attachment 227611

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk4)
View attachment 227612

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk5)
View attachment 227613

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk6)
View attachment 227615

Volkswagen Golf GTI (Mk7)
View attachment 227616
I have to take the II. God that thing is awesome. :drool:

Results:
1. Golf II
2. Golf III
3. Golf IV
4. Golf I
5. Golf VI
6. Golf V
7. Golf VII
2006 Mustang GT

300hp/320tq

09-justin-brockmeyer-mustang.jpg



vs

1998 SVT Cobra

305hp/300tq

Ford-Cobra-SVT-Mustang-Cobra--for-sale-custom-30583-408990.jpg
1998 SVT, it looks nicer to me. I hate when the rim color is different from the wheel color.
Modern hot hatches:

Abarth 500 Esseesse:
View attachment 228133

Ford Fiesta ST
View attachment 228145

Opel Corsa OPC
View attachment 228146

Peugeot 208 GTi
View attachment 228147

Renault Clio RS
View attachment 228148
500 Esseesse by 100 miles. :P

Results:
1. Fiat 500 Abarth Esseesse
2. Ford Fiesta ST
3. Renault Clio RS
4. Opel Corsa OPC
5. Peugeot 208 GTi
Dodge Challenger SRT8 392

2011-Dodge-Challenger-SRT8-392-wallpaper.jpg


or

1st gen Dodge Viper RT/10

dodge-viper-rt10-03.jpg
Viper. Driving it would make me feel...happier.
2015 Mercedes C63 AMG sedan

if5a5fxij9a87ackbjrt.png


or

2012 Mercedes C63 AMG sedan

2012-Mercedes-Benz-C63-AMG-8.JPG
That's hard, but I like the 2015 better. The design is more sleek.
2015 Mercedes C63 AMG estate

gc3gdnyjcuhxbz9vukoi.png


or

2012 Mercedes C63 AMG estate

2012-Mercedes-C63-AMG-01.jpg

2015 for the same reasons as the above.
Audi TT

First gen

Audi_tt.jpg



2nd gen

2007-Audi-TT.jpg


3rd gen

ghw48jvhxzbj9wq9umok.jpg
2nd gen. It looks nice and simple.

Results:
1. 2nd gen.
2. 1st gen
3. 3rd gen

Peugeot 20x hot versions:

Peugeot 205 GTI
View attachment 229397

Peugeot 206 RC
View attachment 229402

Peugeot 207 RC
View attachment 229399

Peugeot 208 GTi
View attachment 229400
205, but the 206 was really close. I've loved that 206 for a while.

Results:
1. Peugeot 205 GTI
2. Peugeot 206 RC
3. Peugeot 207 RC
4. Peugeot 208 GTI

This one is for MINI fans.
Mini Spiritual Concept
198l7ssz5qg77jpg.jpg

BMW Mini
02-06_Mini_Cooper.jpg

Daihatsu Trevis
2006_Daihatsu_Trevis_011_9153.jpg

To be honest, i think i'd go for the BMW Mini, though the Trevis is more faithful to the original Mini.
BMW MINI. The others are ugly.

Results:
1. MINI Cooper
2. Daihatsu Trevis
3. MINI Spiritual Concept

Muscle car wagons:

Nova:
chevrolet-nova-ss-wagon-03.jpg


Gran Torino:
1973_Ford_Gran_Torino.jpg


Or Chevelle:
graggsswagon.jpg


I'm not a huge fan of Wagons, but I've seen some sweet Chevelle wagon hot rods, so that.
Nova, it looks the nicest to me.

Results:
1. Chevrolet Nova
2. Ford Gran Torino
3. Chevrolet Chevelle
US Market Sport Compacts of the mid-2000s.

2005 Mazdaspeed 3
2007_mazda_mazdaspeed3_grand_touring-pic-771751813856138201.jpeg


2005 Dodge Neon SRT-4 ACR
DSC_0033.JPG


2005 Chevrolet Cobalt SS Supercharged
Chevrolet_Cobalt_SS_SC2.jpg


or

2005 Acura RSX Type-S
Acura-RSX_Type-S_2005_photo_08.jpg
Your comparos are way too hard. I'll take the Mazdaspeed because of its space.

Results:
1. Mazda Mazdaspeed3
2. Everything else

Time for something a little different...
1. Fiat Ducato/Peugeot Boxter/Citroen Jumper/Ram ProMaster/Something Whatever
citroen_jumper_wallpaper_4x800x600.jpg

2. Ford Transit
Ford_Transit_2007.JPG

3. Mercedes Sprinter
Mercedes_sprinter_2_v_sst.jpg

4. Gazelle
1720.jpg

5. Renault Master
Renault_master.JPG
Transit, like everyone else.

Results:
1. Ford Transit
2. Renault Master (it looks cute!)
3. Mercedes-Benz Sprinter
4. GAZelle
5. The thing with too many names
As this thread is a little slow, while playing a vídeo game, to honor 2 of my favourite american icons.

So, would you rather...? (judge the car, not colors. Please leave feedback on your favourite color, if you wish). :)

Dodge Charger Daytona

Dodge-Charger_Daytona_1969_1024x768_wallpaper_02.jpg

or...

Plymouth Superbird

plymouth-superbird-02.jpg

For me, the Superbird (my choice) has something more...
The Superbird. I like the black headlight tops.
2014 Ferrari 458 speciale.
nuova-458-speciale_4.jpg


Or

1963 Corvette Z06.
122612_13.jpg
Corvette. The 458 is an overrated piece of...well, it's not a piece of crap, but it's overrated.

Mclaren P1 (roughly 1.1 million dollars)
321021.jpg


67 Cobra (Roughly 1.1 million dollars, depending on miles)
'67_AC_Cobra_(Crusin'_At_The_Boardwalk_'10).jpg


Car pictured is likely a replica, but we're going by the real thing. Cobra for me.
Cobra, by the length of the Autobahn.
Minis :D:

1964 Austin Mini Cooper S 1071
View attachment 233237

1969 Mini 1275GT
View attachment 233240

1969 Morris Mini Cooper S 1275
View attachment 233239

1991 Rover Mini Cooper
View attachment 233243

1997 Rover Mini Cooper
View attachment 233242
The Morris Mini.

Results:
1. Morris Mini Cooper S 1275
2. Mini 1275GT
3. Austin Mini Cooper S 1071
4. Both of them, they're basically the same

Plymouth. I never really liked that version of the Mustang.
2014 E63 AMG:

2014-mercedes-benz-e63-s-amg-front-three-quarter-in-motion.jpg


Or:

BMW M5 Competition Pack:
2014-bmw-m5-side-in-motion.jpg


I'm gonna go with the BMW. I like Mercedes as a company better, but that grille is really offsetting.
The Merc. I really like their new redesigns.

__

1997 Porsche 911 GT1 Straßenversion
750951.jpg


or

1998 Nissan R390 GT1 Road Car
Nissan-R390-Gt.jpg


or

1995 NISMO Skyline GT-R LM Road Going Version
RP-032_1K0E_0.jpg


or

1998 Mercedes-Benz CLK GTR Road Car
mercedes-benz_clk_gtr_amg_road_version_19.jpg
 

Latest Posts

Back