I floss every day, brush twice a day, and get cleanings and checkups every 6 months. So, yes, I'm at least relatively serious about gingivitis.
I can absolutely see a reason to vote for Supreme that is devoid of any attempt at humor. I do not live in a battleground state. Delaware's paltry 3 electoral votes are going to Harris even if I stay home, eat pizza, and watch
Thunderbirds reruns all night.
Voting for Harris in my case sends 1 of 3 messages:
- I like Harris, the Democrats, and their proposed policies
- It does not matter who the Democrats run, as long as that person is less intolerable than who the Republicans run
- I hate Trump and the Republicans
Remember, my state is going for Harris no matter what I do, and for a state this unimportant, it doesn't matter anyway.
So, really, when I vote Democrat, the only messages that the DNC is likely to receive are 1 and 2. Message 3 is irrelevant - it's completely outweighed by Message 2. And, as I said above, given historical precedent,
the message the DNC is most likely to hear is Message 1. Reading Message 3 between the lines is far too nuanced for them, and it does not reinforce their self-image. The DNC is
far more likely to interpret a popular victory - particularly, farther down the ticket - as a mandate
for their candidates and their policies, rather than a defensive move
against the Republicans. It's just the way they are.
If I vote for Supreme, it sends
Message 4: I hate Trump and the Republicans, but I don't particularly like the Democrats either. Which, quite frankly, is my actual opinion. It's a perfectly reasonable vote, given the reality of my state's political position.
Now, it happens that I want to send a message to the Republicans, and that message requires the popular vote to go as much against Trump as possible. So I will accept the Democrats mistaken impression that I support them as collateral damage from my intent to make the popular vote as clear as possible against the Republicans.
But nothing about any of this, in my case, makes my potential vote for Vermin Supreme "unreasonable". As you say, context matters.