Time for me to weigh in here. I've been offline for the last 6 hours or so.
This did start innocently enough with my original "I'm leaving" post just after midnight EST April 1st. It ran innocently enough until about noon EST. People pitched in a little, and there was some speculation in the Conversation thread, but it was pretty clearly a joke.
Up until that time, NOBODY was really banned in anger. Some of us were pretending; VipFREAK agreed to be actually banned for a short period to make it seem truer. Der Alta's account was actually downgraded for a time for the same reason. I put my Duke/extreme_duke account into Invisible mode and kept an eye on things all morning. Jordan's post played along, and he also got me with a similar post in the Mods Forum. Things were going well enough and popular opinion was about evenly split on whether it was a joke or not, with a few more people siding with the (correct) 'JOKE' opinion.
I went to lunch to celebrate a friend of mine's new job. Jordan was busy as well. We all planned to let the idle speculation percolate for a while and make a big announcement when Jordan got back later in the afternoon.
Unfortunately, during that time, I believe that Jon gave sUn his account information so that sUn could access the SuperMod account. I came back from lunch and immediately had to go into Damage Control mode while we figured out what was going on. This unfortunately prevented me from A) knowing what to announce, and B) having time to announce it. By the end of the afternoon I had 4 or 5 browser tabs open on GTPlanet and 4 separate MSN conversations going while everybody tried to figure out what was happening.
They posted the screenshot of my account page showing that I was not really banned. This screenshot could ONLY have been obtained with an account with Super Mod status. I recycled that thread.
sUn apparently banned a number of people against whom he held grudges, in addition to several innocent bystanders. He also deleted various posts to further complicate the issue.
I also used my Duke account to give Captain Coffee temporary admin status to try and regain access to certain controls so I could repair permissions, as Jordan says. The Captain is indeed my second 'tester' account that I experiment on. As soon as I realized that the new account was causing concern, I demoted Captain Coffee back to obscurity and recycled the post with his information in it.
During this time AO and I realized that sUn was doing more damage than simply trying to prank the pranksters. The sUn account and the other innocent bystanders had been banned by Jon's account - although it is possibly Jon who did that himself I have solid reason to believe it was sUn logged in as Jon. Either way, as soon as I banned that account (approximately 2:30p EST) the mayhem ended.
But the aftermath continued, complicated by the sudden slowdown of GTP service. During this time we were also trying to figure out the Jon/sUn connection, of course.
I unbanned Der Alta's real account and restored both of our names to the real thing. We set about figuring out which innocent bystanders had been banned and correcting that. I may not have gotten everyone back to their correct status; if not, please let Jordan know.
As soon as we felt the situation was somewhat stabilized, we posted information in the original "Hanging up my guns" thread. Fortunately, Jordan arrived back at that time and has made the explanations that you've all read.
I too apologize for what happened today, humbly and sincerely. I don't entirely see how the staff here abused the community's trust, since it was reasonably obvious up until about noon that it was April Fools, and since the actual damage was done by two particular members.
However, I recognize that it appears we did abuse that trust, and I accept full responsibility for that perception. As the initial instigator of the joke, I led the other staff to play along. It was I who gave the two problem members their cover or opening to damage the site. I did what I could to fix it as quickly as possible, but that genie will never go all the way back into the bottle. There's been damage done that likely would not have otherwise ocurred.
In that spirit I offer my sincere apologies to the community, my fellow staff members, and most humbly to Jordan, who trusted me in this position. Last year I was voted one of the most trusted members of this community, and I've punted that pretty far over the fence. I'll be communicating with Jordan about my status here and while I hope he sees fit to retain me so I can continue to help repair the damage, I'll accept whatever decision he chooses to make.