Some "proper" sims on PC may have better physics or better FFB with a wheel or more content or better online but they also have their own share of flaws or weird design choices. But the biggest problem I find is the difficulty and expense to getting a good sim running on PC. Not all do you need a decent gaming PC but it takes time and effort to configure the sim and get the FFB working how you want on your wheel.
Someone like me, who is married with kids and have a full time job, I just don't have enough spare time to enjoy the sims properly.
GT7 just works so well out of the box. In a few minutes I can be having some racing races without any effort.
I tried my G29 with GT7 but honestly, it cannot beat the feel and immersion the dualsense provides. You can certainly tell PD developed GT7 with the dualsense in mind and really shows.
I'd be interested to hear from someone with direct drive wheel like one of the Fanatec wheels, whether the FFB and immersion is any better.
For me GT7 scratches that driving itch more than any other racing game of recent times (Sorry FH5)
I used to be a PC gamer since the 80's and got into building my own gaming rigs but I gave that up sometime after the PS3 released. Since then it's been PS consoles for gaming and laptops for business, finances, etc.
I was always big on flight sims, milsim games, etc. As
@Phaceless_Ph pointed out, even those of us that can afford it don't necessarily feel it's worth sinking a bunch of money into a driving sim rig with wheel, monitor, etc. ....if anything just for the space it would take up in my home office. Some are really into it and spend a lot of coin on all that hardware which is fine. I can see the allure as it makes it that much more immersive.
.....I still like more realistic aspects in my flight sims and racing sims though but on the other hand, I'm ok with using a controller. Especially now with GT7 as they are one of the first titles I've played that really have taken advantage of the new DualSense features. It's brought the immersion to another level since GTS for me as it really makes me feel so much more connected to the car / environment. ....I know more about what the car is doing now that I ever did before.
GT7 has it's shortcomings in some of their design decisions IMO but if I'm going to be honest, this is the first title I've played in a long time where I haven't run into numerous bugs. ....kudos to PD especially in this day and age of companies releasing incomplete and unrefined games.
I was really hoping for a proper career mode as well as damage model. ....those were my two biggest disappointments. Other smaller ones include an option to customize the HUD, the ability to fill races with AI when playing with friends and the removal of the less conspicuous cones to mark apexes and braking zones.
....but then there is the new DualSense features, the refined graphics, the more authentic feeling and challenging physics, the return of tuning, etc., etc.
If the measure of a good game is determined by how often you play then I would say I must think GT7 is a really good game. ....I haven't been able to put it down. I have been playing every evening so far since launch and even during the day at times which is extremely rare for me even though I'm retired. I haven't been this "into" a game for a while.
That ridiculous analogy I read earlier about GT7 being compared to the short-term infatuation one might have over a woman is silly. Sure, some can be easily blinded letting their emotions and expectations get the better of them but then again, what they described is what I felt about my future wife. .....and 22 years later I wouldn't have it any other way. My opinion never changed about her.