If you read/watch the entire reviews instead of just browsing the scores you'll see why they came to that particular rating. The one right here on GTP is a good example: quite balanced, mentions they encountered issues, still gave it a high rating. Apparently the issues they found were not bad enough to give the game a bad overall rating. On PS4 no less.
True, but how long, and how in depth do reviewers go? Are they coached? Personally, the first thing I did in the game was pull the Ferrari GTO out on track. It had zero FFB on my T300 wheel. I can say that with full confidence, because after the 2.0 patch, there's
tons of FFB now. So it was obviously missing, and it got put in. Take the Indy Car with the Oval Track setting, there's no FFB now. I now know this because this is the same feeling I had with the Ferrari, and it got fixed. These cars are not "done" yet. It took about eight hours for me to really find out how incomplete this game is. And about another eight so far to figure out how to steer around the unfinished parts.
Oh, it actually took me ten minutes to figure out the game wasn't done yet. But I just figured I found the only bug by chance. Nope, I found out it was a poop show right out of the gate. There were many more bugs to be found. Imagine... You get a new game with a car you've always dreamed about driving... seen reviews about how well it drives in the new PCars 2 game... get it on PS4 the day it comes out... load it up... watch some weird washed out introduction video (that I still haven't watched in entirety, because I'm hoping for that GTSport "goosebumps" feeling)... pick the car your dying to try... and your steering wheel feels like the most light weight, squishy, no response wheel you've ever experienced. And then when you complain about it, others accuse you of not knowing what a Ferrari GTO is supposed to feel like. Give me a freaking break. I've owned a Logitech Driving Force wheel, a Logitech G27 wheel, a Thrustmaster T300 wheel,, GranTurismo 5, GranTuismo 6, Shift 2, countless Need For Speed games, The Crew, Dirt 3, Dirt Rally, Dirt 4, Assetto Corsa,
PROJECT CARS 1, for crying out loud, when I say a car has no freaking FFB, I know what the heck I'm talking about. What's frustrating is when somebody reads a post, doesn't experience the same problem, and assumes you don't know what the heck you're talking about.
Now that... is a RANT.
Oh, and I finally got to drive that Ferrari GTO post 2.0. And it's friggin' amazing.