- 13,913
- Adelaide
- Neomone
So by that logic no people are given credit, just the method. I am saying prayer and religion plays a part in the advancement of modern medicine.
But you're not backing this up with anything. You're just making the statement, and then showing a lot of Christians using the scientific method to do good.
I'm happy to concede that the church as a group has had a large impact through various means, particularly recently. They are one of the largest forces for providing healthcare to the underprivileged, as you have pointed out. If you want to argue that Christians are doing good things, I'm not at all going to argue with you.
But prayer and religious methods have done basically nothing as far as I can tell, and funding hospitals and clinics is by nobody's standard a "religious method". There's a reason the church builds hospitals to heal the sick instead of more churches: because hospitals work. If prayer was the most effective means to treat disease, why would they build hospitals?
The best you could say for religious methods would be that they've strongly encouraged caring for those less fortunate, but that's basically just the Golden Rule, which predates Christianity significantly. I'm not sure "don't be a dick" counts as religious method either.
Perhaps you can explain for me further what part prayer plays in the advancement of modern medicine. Or what part religion plays. Not the people, not the group, not the money that they have, the actual religion. As far as I'm aware, both can be removed entirely from modern medicine and it works just as well, with a few weird exceptions like some patients responding well to religiously themed placebos.
Anyone can use the skills and knowledge that science provides to heal, and that includes Christians. As far as I can tell, no one can use the skills and knowledge that Christianity provides to heal, and that includes Christians. They can use their money pretty effectively on science though, and they do so because it's a nice thing to do and they're generally nice people.