- 2,789
- mount doom
- coilerdh
- no.no.
Ferrari F458 in GT5 (New video post 67)
- Thread starter tnaa777
- 567 comments
- 58,288 views
- 2,980
- Greensboro/NC/U
- jarod336/GTP_torque
- Paperorplastic/ manherollen
- 323
- Porto
- Mr_M1m3
- 1,335
- WA
- TEAM-SWD-daus26
Right, but you're mixing yourself with the term "identical." You say it looks identical but the lighting is GT5 is better. Wouldn't that practically mean one looks better than the other? We already know Turn 10 amped up their polygons big time, which is probably why they are now able to be compared with some of GT5's cars. But without proper lighting, it would just look more cartoony than it should be. And don't make me start on the quality of the interiors.
The only identical thing we can say about the cars (exterior!) is the number of polys. They both look smooth and well done.
As for the damage modeling, I don't see how that can fit in the discussion in terms of visuals on lightings and textures.
And I may have to disagree with you on the wheels and tires in Forza looking better. If it is then good, but that's not what I'm seeing in this video, but it may be just me.
- 2,980
- Greensboro/NC/U
- jarod336/GTP_torque
- Paperorplastic/ manherollen
the car's look 2 different gens apart.
- 676
- Toronto, CAN
- Guynemer27
@kohanson
Not very fair your comparison, get TWO INGAME shot, not the 2 screens that suit your partisanship the most... you took the front end UI car from GT (where the car is at its most beauty/polygons/reflections/details and an ingame shot from Forza.
If you want to be fair, take also a selection screen of the 458 (unfortunately not in the Forza video) in Forza3 which shows also great polygons/reflections and details
Not very fair your comparison, get TWO INGAME shot, not the 2 screens that suit your partisanship the most... you took the front end UI car from GT (where the car is at its most beauty/polygons/reflections/details and an ingame shot from Forza.
If you want to be fair, take also a selection screen of the 458 (unfortunately not in the Forza video) in Forza3 which shows also great polygons/reflections and details
- 2,980
- Greensboro/NC/U
- jarod336/GTP_torque
- Paperorplastic/ manherollen
- 1,048
- GTP_bullie77
I wonder why people take such radical party comparing something so shallow as a video game. It's a video game for ***** sake!What's the point discussing if GT5 has better lightining or if FM3 has damage, like religious fanatics! The aim is to have fun and enjoying whatever game you play!
Sounds like kids discussing who's got the bigger 'wheenie'
- 2,789
- mount doom
- coilerdh
- no.no.
What's the point discussing if GT5 has better lightining or if FM3 has damage, like religious fanatics! The aim is to have fun and enjoying whatever game you play!
Sounds like kids discussing who's got the bigger 'wheenie'
Not funny all the time, but thats how the world goes round
What's the point discussing if GT5 has better lightining or if FM3 has damage, like religious fanatics! The aim is to have fun and enjoying whatever game you play!
Sounds like kids discussing who's got the bigger 'wheenie'
Mine's definatly bigger.
- 10,270
- Bonn
- GTAce
What's the point discussing if GT5 has better lightining or if FM3 has damage, like religious fanatics! The aim is to have fun and enjoying whatever game you play!
Sounds like kids discussing who's got the bigger 'wheenie'
Why complain? If you dont want to discuss it dont do it.
From a graphics nut point of view, its just pretty astonishing what PD achieved so far.
- 477
Comparing the italia 458 between Forza 3 and GT5..
Forza3
Gran Turismo 5
You are comparing a pic taken from an HD vid to a pic taken from a low res blurry vid.
Also one of those cars is actually on a track truly from gameplay and the other is ....not.
Not exactly the most fair comparison you could have made. Although I'm sure that was the point.
If you are going to use that GT 5 trailer pic then I suggest you use this trailer Forza 3 pic.
Last edited:
- 1,048
- GTP_bullie77
I'm not complaining! I'm stating a fact how such ridiculous subject can cause such a controverse between 2 civilized people!
Neither I'm addressing if the graphics are astonishing or not. I'm my judgement they are, and I'd like best the ones from GT5. If someone's thinks the otherway around, that's fair enough! It's called AN OPINION!
- 1,335
- WA
- TEAM-SWD-daus26
What's the point discussing if GT5 has better lightining or if FM3 has damage, like religious fanatics! The aim is to have fun and enjoying whatever game you play!
Sounds like kids discussing who's got the bigger 'wheenie'
Right.
It may not matter for us, but it may matter for the repuatation of PD and Turn 10. If PD didn't care and just let Forza surpass them (or vice versa), then that's that to them and possibly losing the support of many fans and then the sales. The media have hyped up the heated rivalry between the two to the max, so it's no brainer many are getting involved in such discussion.
And yup, Coiler, it's how the world goes 'round. The truth in this world are jumbled up by people's many different interpretation on things.
- 2,980
- Greensboro/NC/U
- jarod336/GTP_torque
- Paperorplastic/ manherollen
Well now all im hearing about GT5 version is that it's CGI... Why do forza fans always take the it's CGI route. it happened for the E3 GT5 trailer and now it's happening again.
- 477
Nobody is accusing the vids of being CGI. It's CGI using ingame assets. HUGE difference.
And it wasn't only the GT 5 vid from E3 that did that. One of the Forza vids was exactly the same thing.
So any Forza fan running around claiming "buh buh it was all CGI" is misinformed and a hypocrite.
omg! i was watching the wrong trailer( based on color schemes)
light red in color : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eSseZtGivqs
dark red ? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4a0MMk3VFps&annotation_id=annotation_344604&feature=iv#movie_player
light red in color : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eSseZtGivqs
dark red ? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4a0MMk3VFps&annotation_id=annotation_344604&feature=iv#movie_player
