Give us better sounds - PLEASE !!

  • Thread starter steamcat
  • 4,667 comments
  • 347,665 views
Just realised that the Aud R18 TDI, with it's V6 diesel, has the same engine sound as the Audi R10 TDI, with it's V12 diesel, from GT5. They are quite different in reality.
 
Consider getting a sound bar with a subwoofer! I picked one up a month ago and it has completely trasnformed the sound for... everything. I have the woofer by my couch. The sound is much richer and has a lot of depth now. I can't complain about the exhaust pipes anymore.

A good sound system is invaluable in any racing sim no doubt. For some reason I lost my sound from the amp a couple of nights ago (accidentally programmed the wrong source from the XMB) and all I got was sound from the 10W tv speakers:yuck::yuck: Just for fun I tried to drive that way and it was terrible. The cars were very tinny and quiet sounding, everything was off pitch, no bass at all. Switch back to digital sound is the auditory equivalent of going from a 27" CRT TV to 55" LED 1080P it is that different.

I think I'm going to invest in a Buttkicker next to have some of the bass translated into ...well..buttkicking!
 
Some cars are not bad at all


Why does the physics look so fake? Everytime he's on the point of adhesion the car suddenly finds grip and pulls the car straight. At 1:37 the car floats.. Somebody please explain why this is.
 
No i saw the same inconsistancies in the KTM Xbow vid on the Nurb. Not the floating car but the impossible angles and speeds at wich the car stays on track. There are moments in that video that he should have losed control but the car simply maintains grip. He was driving hard with no assists.
 
Some cars are not bad at all

That's not a V8 sound, it's an inline 6. I remember it well from GT2, e.g. the Unisia Jecs R33 Skyline...

Not sure about the 6 banger but it does sound off to me too, it appears to be a real engine but not a 289cid small block Ford imo.

Maybe even a high CompRatio 4 banger? Escort-Cosworth?



How I think it should be:



Why does the physics look so fake? Everytime he's on the point of adhesion the car suddenly finds grip and pulls the car straight. At 1:37 the car floats.. Somebody please explain why this is.

Looks semi-realistic to me, actually we can see the driver making small-medium corrections, should it find grip though? I don't know.
 
Last edited:
Have been a long time reader of GtPlanet and want have some input into this thread.

I never was too bothered about the sounds in GT4 as at a young age I couldn't careless but going into GT5 I was hoping there would be improvements, but didn't notice much.

Now been reading threads about GT6 and the update malarky that Kaz has said they are working/researching on new ways to get sounds. I get all that but come on, Cars without decent sounds is like running 100M in your flipflop/sandals. It just doesn't work and you don't get that experience.

Recently I have been reading about Pcars and Asseto Corsa and Damn do those Sims get my heart bleeding with great sounds!

I have played GT6 for about 3 hours in total because the sounds just put me off knowing that the sound samples they have in place does not do it for me, so instead watch you tube videos and give me hope that one GT6 will have these sort of sounds in the future update.

I bloody hope future update does not mean in a years time cos that is just plain pointless!

Sample samples of two cars, BMW Z4 GT3, Zonda R and other car I don't know. Skip to 2:00 for the BMW sound!

 
Last edited:
Man the BRZ with Semi-racing exhaust sounds pretty good :)


Interesting that PD recorded different sounds for the BRZ, Scion FR-S and FT86 even if they use the same engine. Wonder if that translates to the sports/semi-racing and racing exhausts as well
 
Last edited:
Man the BRZ with Semi-racing exhaust sounds pretty good :)


Interesting that PD recorded different sounds for the BRZ, Scion FR-S and FT86 even if they use the same engine. Wonder if that translates to the sports/semi-racing and racing exhausts as well

Why is it good with Semi-racing?

I prefer cars with stock exhausts to sound good from the get go, not having to upgrade to poor exhausts really to be frank.
 
Why is it good with Semi-racing?

I prefer cars with stock exhausts to sound good from the get go, not having to upgrade to poor exhausts really to be frank.

It just does, I think it sounds OK stock, but nicer with the exhaust upgrades. Louder :)
Sports and race and nice too.
But I like nice combo of throaty and bass the semi-racing adds, and no hint of vaccum, hiss or whine!
You expect the BRZ, FT86 and Scion FR-S to sound and behave closer to the real things, since PD spend so much time with them and measuring them on track



Bought the Monaro - stuck a wing to make it look like the 24 hour racer, time for some Bathurst :)
Sounds a little better than in GT5, top end of the rev range is where it goes bad, same for the 22B - you get that Boxer throb with the exhaust upgrades, but lose it in the upper revs...
 
I think some of you are a little bit too emotionally invested in this game. I agree that the sound definitely needs work, but if you're getting depressed over it then I think you need to rethink your priorities in life. The updates will come.

Priority we do have set in place, we only expressing our concerns of the game as sound is essence of the car.

Watching top gear or any other car program, they always mention how great the car sounds which makes the car.

That is my 2 cents
 
It just does, I think it sounds OK stock, but ncier with the exhaust upgrades. SPorts and race and nice too.
But I like nice combo of throaty and bass the semi-racing ads, and no hint of vaccum, hiss or whine!



Bought the Monaro - stuck a wing to make it look like the 24 hour racer, time for some Bathurst :)
Sounds a little better than in GT5, top end of the rev range is where it goes bad, same for the 22B - you get that Boxer throb with the exhaust upgrades, but lose it in the upper revs...

True but stock sounds should sound as close to the real thing, upgrading the exhausts just means that its not done right first time and needs looking into.

I really need to get off this and start to stop complaining.

The nicest sounding car I own is the Pontiac Trans Ams, sound really bassy and that is what I should expect from all premium cars, to sound really good.

Even in Forza 5, some of the sounds don't even come close to the real thing and I don't know but every car I hear in Forza 5 is a small whine like sound which is so off puting at high revs!
 
Why is it good with Semi-racing?

I prefer cars with stock exhausts to sound good from the get go, not having to upgrade to poor exhausts really to be frank.
The same reason why even low-HP cars in Forza sound like they 500 under the hood. People like it LOUD.
 
Priority we do have set in place, we only expressing our concerns of the game as sound is essence of the car.

Watching top gear or any other car program, they always mention how great the car sounds which makes the car.

That is my 2 cents

It's ok to express your concerns. That's what this thread's for. However, when people start going on about how they can't eat because the sounds are awful, that's not expressing concern. That's just being melodramatic and adds nothing to the conversation.
 
True but stock sounds should sound as close to the real thing, upgrading the exhausts just means that its not done right first time and needs looking into.

I really need to get off this and start to stop complaining.

The nicest sounding car I own is the Pontiac Trans Ams, sound really bassy and that is what I should expect from all premium cars, to sound really good.

Even in Forza 5, some of the sounds don't even come close to the real thing and I don't know but every car I hear in Forza 5 is a small whine like sound which is so off puting at high revs!

Maybe the stock BRZ sounds like the real car, I dunno, I just said that the Semi-racing sounds good. A bit like how real cars sound better with aftermarket intake and exhaust mods...
 
Holden Monaro test drive at Ascari
If PD just add more samples in the upper rev range it would actually sound quite good, and is V8 like.

 
Last edited:
Maybe the stock BRZ sounds like the real car, I dunno, I just said that the Semi-racing sounds good. A bit like how real cars sound better with aftermarket intake and exhaust mods...

I agree it sounds good, but sounds like a straight 6 not a boxer
 
I agree it sounds good, but sounds like a straight 6 not a boxer

I drive an Impreza, and it didn't sound a lot different from my car's induction sound, which can range from V8 to Ferrari sounding :)
Only Boxers with uneven length exhaust headers have that "boxer" sound.
 
Tested PCM linear 5.1 instead of Dolby 5.1, gives better output, less problems and better channel balances and audio quality.
Weird if putting 48 kHz sample rate on PS3/XMB it won't give any sound, but when putting 44.1 kHz it's working fine, weirdest at GT6 shows on both cases 48 kHz linear 5.1.
 
Some cars are not bad at all

The only good exhausts on that car is stock and racing one. The 15th Aniversery one comes stock with sport exhaust.

Agreed. But, for example, the 03' VW R32, stock and semi-racing only sound like a real VR6, but you can't get very aggressive with the VR6 in the game with either.
Same for the Audi RS4, semi race got a very nice V6 noise, but only in the higher revs...midrange is :crazy:
 
Last edited:
It's ok to express your concerns. That's what this thread's for. However, when people start going on about how they can't eat because the sounds are awful, that's not expressing concern. That's just being melodramatic and adds nothing to the conversation.
I was exaggerating a bit for the sake of comedy. I guess I should have put a "hahaha" or an "lol" afterwards. Sorry I didn't contribute as you think I should.
 
I was exaggerating a bit for the sake of comedy. I guess I should have put a "hahaha" or an "lol" afterwards. Sorry I didn't contribute as you think I should.

I had problems sleeping after playing GT6 some hours. I heard the monotone engine sound after turning off the game :yuck:
 
Back