marcvic
Premium
- 882
- USA
- marcvic
Fair enough, but I think he'll get his fair share of "licks" from the non-admin members, right?
The more the merrier!
GT Sport vs Other Games: Comparison Video Thread
- Thread starter GTPNewsWire
- 2,529 comments
- 217,059 views
Fair enough, but I think he'll get his fair share of "licks" from the non-admin members, right?
The more the merrier!
- 15,532
- Cairo, Egypt
- GTP_SEMS
- 679
- mrPetros
I ain't so sure about that my friend
see here, even though gts has the less comparative luminosity, the plastic-y reflection on car is more pronounced
I think, unless things change dramatically, maybe we won't be seeing many (undoctored) fully lit, bright GTS photos from you
maybe you will start to appreciate the ..darkness more
edit:
for pcars2 to join here, console version(s) should be shown for comparison. no point comparing console to triple 1080s
But bring in the pcars1 console versions comparoos
Last edited:
- 2,150
- Jakarta
Well the thread title does say "Other Games".
Nah, this thread should be renamed "GTS VS The World" because frankly it is not just a game we compare here, but people arguments from around the world as well
. Heck, reading this thread have more explosive materials than Michael Bay movie tbh (sorry just can't hold it this thread is on fire lately though so...)
- 679
- mrPetros
also this comparative video here, says exactly the same (plastic) story
hey my friend @emula, what the heck is going on here??
*added bonus, check at 6:00 the 100% bogus reflection (prebaked and wrong) of the sun on rear window, while the shadow produced by the car to the tarmac says another story about sun position (should be in front-ish)
@emula!!! what we gonna do mate?? and plastic, and prebaked, and wrong? omg!!
hey my friend @emula, what the heck is going on here??
*added bonus, check at 6:00 the 100% bogus reflection (prebaked and wrong) of the sun on rear window, while the shadow produced by the car to the tarmac says another story about sun position (should be in front-ish)
@emula!!! what we gonna do mate??
and plastic, and prebaked, and wrong? omg!!
Last edited:
- 14,436
- Los Angeles, CA
- Lma_robot
- lImaRobotl
The discussion is that Forza is no more saturated compared to GTS. The thing about the "bullshot" quality shot, is that it's likely what we're going to be able to do once the X hits the shelves with the game.Gif with full sun on GTS VS bullshot of F7 and all this GTS remains the most authentic
Oooh look how saturated the colors in reality, that green then the grass, blind me
- 1,427
- Italy
also this comparative video here, says exactly the same (plastic) story
hey my friend @emula, what the heck is going on here??
*added bonus, check at 6:00 the 100% bogus reflection (prebaked and wrong) of the sun on rear window, while the shadow produced by the car to the tarmac says another story about sun position (should be in front-ish)
@emula!!! what we gonna do mate??
"my friend" the colour of that car is way more accurate on GTS (especially with HDR on)
real
Last edited:
- 679
- mrPetros
well, I dont know if you've seen one of those up close, but trust me the FLUSH iphone-type hdr post-pro, is not what you see in real life.
same for any other car depicted in this kind of post processing.
(I know you are never going to admit ANYTHING at all, but I'm still gonna try make you right )
so tell me, what about THE SUN? I say its both prebaked AND wrongly placed.
Which in turn means that shadows are prebaked and wrong -as in no relation to the reflections- too.
HOW is that acceptable from such a perfectionist as you are?
oh, and car shadows are blocky, 2008 era blocky. what about that too? where is the perfection in that?
ps. I'm pretty sure that if a forza dude brought up iphone hdr processed "photos", to present his case for realism, you would have ridiculed him quite a lot. maybe you may want to think about that before your next answer
same for any other car depicted in this kind of post processing.
(I know you are never going to admit ANYTHING at all, but I'm still gonna try make you right
)so tell me, what about THE SUN? I say its both prebaked AND wrongly placed.
Which in turn means that shadows are prebaked and wrong -as in no relation to the reflections- too.
HOW is that acceptable from such a perfectionist as you are?
oh, and car shadows are blocky, 2008 era blocky. what about that too? where is the perfection in that?
ps. I'm pretty sure that if a forza dude brought up iphone hdr processed "photos", to present his case for realism, you would have ridiculed him quite a lot. maybe you may want to think about that before your next answer
Last edited:
- 1,427
- Italy
well, I dont know if you've seen one of those up close, but trust me the FLUSH iphone-type hdr post-pro, is not what you see in real life.
same for any other car depicted in this kind of post processing.
(I know you are never going to admit ANYTHING at all, but I'm still gonna try make you right
so tell me, what about THE SUN? I say its both prebaked AND wrongly placed.
Which in turn means that shadows are prebaked and wrong -as in no relation to the reflections- too.
HOW is that acceptable from such a perfectionist as you are?
oh, and car shadows are blocky, 2008 era blocky. what about that too? where is the perfection in that?
ps. I'm pretty sure that if a forza dude brought up iphone hdr processed "photos", to present his case for realism, you would have ridiculed him quite a lot. maybe you may want to think about that before your next answer
shadows are blocky, 2008 era blocky. what about that too? where is the perfection in that? (cit.)
- 679
- mrPetros
why not compare: car shadow to car shadow, and dashboard shadow to dashboard shadow?
that video above is perfect for apples to apples comparison. are you afraid of watching it and commenting on it?
you prefer to paint red arrows on hand-picked, unrelated photos instead? unimaginable!!
- 3,280
- France
Endless discution I guess. Uncharted 4 is probably the most beautiful, realistic game in terms of graphics with wind physics on Nathan's chest hair. Though it was my least fun Uncharted. It was even a boring experience for me even though I'm a huge UC fan.
It's the same thing for racing games, they all look great today but at the end, fun is the most important aspect. It's a matter of taste, I prefer the art style of GTSport but I won't deny the beauty of Forza graphics.
It's the same thing for racing games, they all look great today but at the end, fun is the most important aspect. It's a matter of taste, I prefer the art style of GTSport but I won't deny the beauty of Forza graphics.
- 491
why not compare: car shadow to car shadow, and dashboard shadow to dashboard shadow?
that video above is perfect for apples to apples comparison. are you afraid of watching it and commenting on it?
you prefer to paint red arrows on hand-picked, unrelated photos instead? unimaginable!!
The worrying thing is that F7 has low resolution shadows in the xox version, which is the best version of the game with its fantastic 4k
- 1,427
- Italy
why not compare: car shadow to car shadow, and dashboard shadow to dashboard shadow?
that video above is perfect for apples to apples comparison. are you afraid of watching it and commenting on it?
you prefer to paint red arrows on hand-picked, unrelated photos instead? unimaginable!!
Not just the shadows, look at those rocks.... seems "1998 era"
My friend where is the perfection in that?
marcvic
Premium
- 882
- USA
- marcvic
*added bonus, check at 6:00 the 100% bogus reflection (prebaked and wrong) of the sun on rear window, while the shadow produced by the car to the tarmac says another story about sun position (should be in front-ish)
@emula!!! what we gonna do mate??
I could be wrong, but if the sun was directly over the top and slightly ahead of the car, wouldn't it reflect off the surface of the slanted/curved rear windshield?
Also, what do you mean by the plastic description?
- 679
- mrPetros
no my friend, I think not. I mean, 6:02 sun is dead center of rear window, and cars shadows are all back. you look at it.
about plastic, see iphone subaru pic posted above to understand
My Italian friend has been hammering forza6 for looking plastic, and now that gts is out, guess what? forza looks ...pale and metal in comparison
- 15,532
- Cairo, Egypt
- GTP_SEMS
GTSport looks "plastic-y"? . Well that's the first time I've seen that word thrown around.
- 6,838
- Europe
- GTP_Slim
- PzR Slim
I've just watched the vid this image is taken from again on my 4k OLED with HDR enabled and that is a terrible representation of what it actually looks like.FM7 (from gamersyde)
Edit: In fact I would go as far to say you have altered the pic to look worse than it is.
Here's the same pic taken off screen with my phone.
It's really sad and pathetic that you would choose to do that.
Oh and here is another. See if you can find a comparison shot in GTS
Last edited:
- 2,512
- S.C.
- MMXtreme
also this comparative video here, says exactly the same (plastic) story
hey my friend @emula, what the heck is going on here??
*added bonus, check at 6:00 the 100% bogus reflection (prebaked and wrong) of the sun on rear window, while the shadow produced by the car to the tarmac says another story about sun position (should be in front-ish)
@emula!!! what we gonna do mate??
I think GT looks way better in this comparison. Forza looks dull and flat.
- 679
- mrPetros
well forza6 until recently was looking "oversaturated" and "plastic". funny how perception changes, huh?
actually I read a very well written post regarding perception earlier today in this forum. enjoy:
https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/thre...ldnt-be-difficult.357091/page-5#post-11867512
- 14,436
- Los Angeles, CA
- Lma_robot
- lImaRobotl
So the problem with Forza is not so much the saturation, but the saturation? What materials are innacurate?
That image is horribly edited. Look at the sky, look at the lights, they is too much contrast and saturation going on there."my friend" the colour of that car is way more accurate on GTS (especially with HDR on)
real
Shadows look a lot better on this video at 1:47. There are some Major graphical glitches going on right there it seems. Textures don't even look that bad on previous games. They have more then enough time, you yourself said that these games aren't released yet
shadows are blocky, 2008 era blocky. what about that too? where is the perfection in that? (cit.)
Shadows looking pretty crisp there, but what I'm noticing is that the issues present itself when it goes over the gauges specifically.
It's not so much worrying, really. Although its interesting to see release footage 5 months in the future when the game releasesThe worrying thing is that F7 has low resolution shadows in the xox version, which is the best version of the game with its fantastic 4k
Oh wait, it's not over-saturated like everyone is saying?!
- 6,838
- Europe
- GTP_Slim
- PzR Slim
How dare you tell such bare faced lies! My pictures taken with a bloody camera off screen prove that you are wilfully misrepresenting one game in favour of another. Yet another forum member with credibility reduced to zero over their love of one particular franchise. It's unbelievably pathetic and the cancer of the gaming world.
- 14,436
- Los Angeles, CA
- Lma_robot
- lImaRobotl
The problem here is you, with your very noticeably uneven comparisons. Also the fact that you're straight out making up things like "Forza is still way more over saturated than GTS" when if you looked at, well any thing, that's literally not true. If you'd atleast try to come in a bit level headed when trying to make your comparisons, everyone wouldn't approach you in such a way.
To be honest, what he posted, and the video its from looks exactly the same on my end.
Similar threads
