So I read through five pages of this thread, got bored with the back-and-forth, but then pushed on up to this point so I can now write my post. I'm not entirely sure I can possibly expound more upon any of the points that I wanted to make, because a wide variety of contributors to this thread have already made them for me so I'll just make a few tidbits.
I don't know anyone with a Dodge Aries, but the grandmother of a friend of mine owns a 1986 Chrysler LeBaron. I don't necessarily think a lot of K-cars, but they are far from cool, really. I don't find them offensive, but that doesn't translate into "it's definitely cool". I drove it once, and don't recall it being remarkable in the slightest. Most I can really remember is that it didn't have much power. That's about it.
I can agree that this car was just what Chrysler needed to bail them out in the 80s, but as many people have stated in this thread, that doesn't make it cool. It's knowledge that esoteric to people who aren't into cars and/or wasn't even alive in the 80s.
@The87Dodge I feel for you. Really I do. I remember back when I was known as Irons, and I nominated my dad's truck, and defended it as a cool vehicle, and under the old ranking system, it did wind up making the "cool" category, and right now it's sitting in uncool. I was probably 15 when that was being polled, and I remember being fairly passionate about this old '80s Toyota. I was a little dejected that it ended up uncool, but I understand that for many people, it's not cool. Not too long ago, I nominated my daily driver, the Scion xA, and it did kinda sting how it got ripped apart, but at the same time, I can definitely understand why it wasn't considered a cool car. Hell, had I never owned one in the first place, I would have given it a "meh" at best. In the end, I was expecting it to get lambasted anyway, and I feel that you probably should have seen this coming, at least a little bit.
If it's one of the coolest cars of all time to you, then own that. You don't need our approval for you to think it's cool, so own it. Just understand that none of us really think alike or have the exact same tastes.