Theoretically that's how it should be, but in reality is far from it.
Maybe for you, but in my experience it's done across the board from the rough schools to the selective ones.
I never understood the point of reading stories/novels that we have no interest in (universals the entire classes is forced to read) and writing essays either for English classes.
Senior English - when taught properly - is about concepts and ideas. It can be pretty abstract, which is a bit of a barrier to entry, but once you get your head around that, it gets much easier. For example, a few weeks ago I did
The Motorcycle Diaries with my Year 11 class. But TCM was the means to an end, not the ends in and of itself. We used it to explore the idea of "discovery" - the process an individual goes through to take their experiences and use them to shape their understanding of the world around them. Next year, my Year 9 class will be doing
To Kill A Mockingbird, and use it to explore how societal attitudes change (though I still need to pair it with something ... I want to do the Thrilla in Manila, but can't find a good text for it). The big risk is that you have to get the students to understand what they are trying to do early on.
Because I'm totally going to need to know why Romeo and Juliet wanted to copulate with each other while I'm swapping a 351W into a Ford pickup.
So you see nothing in the text about the conflict between family tradition and the desire of youth for independence, for example?
Personally, I have always felt
Othello is a better choice, since it's about prejudice and psychological manipulation.
Last time I checked English class was not History class. If the issues still persist today I would find those stories to be much more relevant in other subjects.
There is naturally going to be some degree of cross-curricular overlap. When I did
The Motorcycle Diaries, I had to cover modern history, economics and geography in some way, shape or form.
Never understood the purpose of making us study it in Shakespeare's English either. We don't use those words any more, what is the point?
It's not enough to read Shakespeare - you need to see it performed. Al Pacino made a great little documentary in the 1990s called
Looking for Richard, which is about the place of Shakespeare in contemporary society, using
King Richard III as an example. Shakespeare doesn't just teach is history or ideas; he teaches us how to feel. Many of his plays tap into themes that are still relevant today.
In
King Richard III, Richard schemes to usurp the crown of England by undermining and marginalising those around him. Sound familiar? It's
House of Cards.