Just to clarify a few points/facts...
Naturally, I jump into the fray, defending MGS. And here's what really gets my goat: their attitude. I liken MGS to Halo 3 in its exclusivity; MGS is, after all, a major Sony publication.
Actually it isn't. It is a huge Konami publication. Unlike Halo 3 which is published by Microsoft and developed by Microsoft
(MS bought Bungie back in 2000), Sony isn't the developer or publisher of MGS4. Yes, MGS has so far remained exclusive to Sony, but it isn't nearly as important to Sony as Halo is to Microsoft.
A much better comparison would be Gran Turismo. Now you are talking about a series developed and owned by Sony and that has sold more games than any other PlayStation series, with the possible exception of GTA. I believe Sony sold around 25 million copies of GT3 and GT4 on the PS2 which was about 10 million more copies than Microsoft sold of Halo 1 & Halo 2, and several times more than the best selling MGS game for the PS2.
But they insist that since there's an audience for it, MGS should be carried over to the 360.
I actually agree with them, even though I consider the PS3 to be the superior platform. I've never been a fan of "exclusivity". That said, even if Konami wanted to release MGS4 onto the 360, they likely couldn't package it so all 360 owners could play it, because it would require multiple discs, or a large HDD, and let's face it, with some very rare cases, there have been no multiple disc games on consoles.
Now what is a possibility, and something I and many others have speculated might happen is that MGS: Online
(which is being sold as a separate game) could be made to fit on a single DVD, and would be an excellent multi-platform type of game, as no one can deny that there are a lot of dedicated online players using XBL... while not nearly as many as I believe Microsoft would have us believe, but still a very wide audience. What's even more intriguing is that Konami and Kojima Productions are just the right kind of people to pull off a multi-platform online game where PS3, 360 and PC players could all play with each other online... now how cool would that be! 👍
If Konami does do this, I'd be willing to bet MGS: Online would dominate the market and would even convert a lot of Halo fans over... maybe not the hardcore Halo drones.
Now as far as exclusive games go, I realize they are an important part of the console market, and while they certainly are not as bad an exclusive licensed games...
(yes EA, I'm looking at you), I never like the idea of exclusive platform games as it means they have less competition and they are also limiting their potential sales. While some may be more cynical then I, from my business background I know the more competition that exists, in general that means better products and/or lower prices. Also, if a company can sell more product that means they'll have a bigger budget to develop better game with in order to compete with the other games.
That said, I also see a benefit to exclusive platform games, in that a game can be developed to fully tap into the potential of a particular console's hardware and design, where as cross platform games might be a compromise on one or both versions.
This is especially true this time around as one of the big strengths of the PS3 besides its Cell processor is the ability to play a game off a single 50GB
(~49GB game data) disc compared to the 360 which is limited to games on 8.5GB discs
(~7 GB game data). That's a huge difference that has already been tapped into by Resistance: Fall of Men, and several upcoming games.
To make multi-platform games for these large games would mean having to make drastic cuts to the 360 version if the developer wanted that game to play on all current 360's.
Any way, it's certainly an interesting topic, but I wouldn't get too worked up over their comments. If anything it just goes to show how much interest there is in MGS4, and you can't really blame them for that.