- 8,721
Don't count on it.Thank you Dr. Freud. I guess I can skip all that expensive psychoanalysis and just stop in here once in a while for a chat.
Sound Update (PD is now hiring! + Email!)Answered
- Thread starter FoRiZon
- 1,262 comments
- 96,281 views
- 8,721
And that would be the "change the argument to one I'd rather have", a classic in itself, and firm favourite, I've noticed.
I never asked anyone to prove or disprove anything.
I questioned the logic of continuing a discussion about conclusions drawn from figures, when those figures weren't even understood or investigated by both parties. The first thing to do is establish a common basis of discussion, and then present arguments, not assume the party line based purely on the person who dug up the figures. Following the link provided should have been enough to raise questions as to the exact nature of that basis, and should have been the first thing JP did.
Besides, "on the basis of who posted it" sounds an awfully lot like "play the man, not the ball" - but that's yet another classic, given the participants.
I never asked anyone to prove or disprove anything.
I questioned the logic of continuing a discussion about conclusions drawn from figures, when those figures weren't even understood or investigated by both parties. The first thing to do is establish a common basis of discussion, and then present arguments, not assume the party line based purely on the person who dug up the figures. Following the link provided should have been enough to raise questions as to the exact nature of that basis, and should have been the first thing JP did.
Besides, "on the basis of who posted it" sounds an awfully lot like "play the man, not the ball" - but that's yet another classic, given the participants.
- 2,534
- Johannesburg
- Tayeedz1
@Griffith500 @Johnnypenso @Tenacious D
Anyway in other news, apparently the FT-1 VGT sounds sick. The update on my side keeps failing so my comments will have to wait.
Anyway in other news, apparently the FT-1 VGT sounds sick. The update on my side keeps failing so my comments will have to wait.
- 28,470
- Windsor, Ontario, Canada
- Johnnypenso
- 2,534
- Johannesburg
- Tayeedz1
The good kinda sick Mr Penso
Alright, so I've managed to finally get the update. The FT-1 VGT sounds nice. It's not mind boggingly amazing, it's nice, that's it. I'd expect the Supra to sound the same though but the FT-1 does the job.
I'll leave the floor to @Griffith500
Last edited:
- 10,222
- South
- HarskGaming96
Indeed! They really did.My appologies in advance if I sound like a smart as, but "4 valves per cylinder" doesn't tell you how many cylinders an engine has. Most V6 engines have 24 valves.
And yes, they screwed up many sounds...
Look for RS200 Rally Car'86.
Real sound:
GT6 sound is really close to real one.
- 4,382
Sorry for off-topic, but best sounds on current gen ATM: FM5 and H2. Period.
- 4,992
- Nowhere special
- SweetLilPoppet
- SweetLilPoppet
I think it sounds lovely. It genuinely made me look up in shock when I first heard it.
@Speedster911 that's because forza is the only current gen racer ATM
- 4,382
Ah, yes. I overlooked that tiny bit!
GT7 should be something to look forward to. Other devs have set the bar way high.
GT7 should be something to look forward to. Other devs have set the bar way high.
- 2,884
- Near Reading, Uk
- JohnSchoonsBeard
- 10,222
- South
- HarskGaming96
KTM X-Bows is one of great examples of GT6 perfect sound. It is really close one.
The quality of video of real sound wasn't so good...
- 2,884
- Near Reading, Uk
- JohnSchoonsBeard
- 8,846
- Ottawa
- Automotive_Buff
"What is it? 4 banger with open headers? Meh they're all the same"
- 10,222
- South
- HarskGaming96
What you mean?
- 4,382
That IS the ticket right there. GT needs that grunt and life injected into engine sounds.
- 8,846
- Ottawa
- Automotive_Buff
- 4,382
I hate to bring this up again, but these 4 console games are really great examples of good sound mixing:
*Horizon 1
*FM4
*FM5
*Horizon 2
YES, they happen to be T10 games. They're the only examples I could think of that really stand out.
Perhaps PD could "borrow" a few ideas here and there.
I want to see GT resurrected. It's been too long.
*Horizon 1
*FM4
*FM5
*Horizon 2
YES, they happen to be T10 games. They're the only examples I could think of that really stand out.
Perhaps PD could "borrow" a few ideas here and there.
I want to see GT resurrected. It's been too long.
- 4,992
- Nowhere special
- SweetLilPoppet
- SweetLilPoppet
Now that driveclub is out, we can safely add it to the list too. Throw in pcars too. Their mclaren f1 sample is so close to reality it's scary. The zakspeed capri is another example, and once the game is complete every car will have the same standard of sound replication.
Now, if just one of them would include the v8 f type........
- 4,382
^^ Hmm yeah.. though vids left me somewhat leery, a final review should seal the deal.
- 4,382
Wait, are you referring to PCARS here or GT6?
FM4 seem to do a decent job of this, but Horizon's was far better. They improved it even more in FM5 and H2, pretty much no one who's driven a fast car in a tunnel would disagree with you on that one!
FM4 seem to do a decent job of this, but Horizon's was far better. They improved it even more in FM5 and H2, pretty much no one who's driven a fast car in a tunnel would disagree with you on that one!
- 16
- France, Lorraine
- GmSV2
GT6
why? example
in the empty streets of tokyo 246 and Monaco tunnel, and other large valley speedway there is no eco while driving IRL in a tunnel or an empty street with a car that makes a loud noise there will be a eco effect that there is not in GT and that's often lacking
why? example
in the empty streets of tokyo 246 and Monaco tunnel, and other large valley speedway there is no eco while driving IRL in a tunnel or an empty street with a car that makes a loud noise there will be a eco effect that there is not in GT and that's often lacking
- 4,382
Ah, well.. I believe this is nicely represented in PCARS. You should get into the Forza games, you'll like em, believe me.
Similar threads
