@Touring Mars I have not tried the straight rye version of Bulleit. I have tried their normal bourbon and it is also very tasty. You might look out for Buffalo Trace; it is another good, lower cost bourbon that I have enjoyed.
Buffalo Trace is one of my favorite distilleries. They make wheated bourbons like Pappy Van Winkle's, which is supposed to be God Tier stuff. But the thing is... it's all the same whiskey. The only thing that changes is the barreling and ageing. You can get their WL Weller on the cheap instead, and it's damn good. It's basically a young Pappy, but I couldn't tell you how similar they are. Can't find PVW, and couldn't afford it anyway. The whiskey shortage and hipsters jacked up pricing and ruined it.
I've not tasted Bulleit bourbon but if the rye whiskey is anything to go by, it should be good! I'm looking to expand my drinks cabinet - which currently stands at a pathetic two bottles (and both are half empty already), and I need a nice bourbon that is not Jack Daniel's... don't get me wrong, I love JD, but it's about time I tried something a bit more refined.
Woodford Reserve is owned by the same people that make JD. Actually, Bulleit Rye is just LDI's pure rye mash. They were contracted by Seagrams to make a pure rye (like 95%) to use as flavoring for their blends and other drinks. Then I think Seagrams was bought out or bankrupted, and LDI was acquired by some other company that spun off that whiskey to private label bottlers. Bulleit is one such label, and a blend of varying amounts of Four Roses bourbon (they make good stuff too; owned by Kirin) and that pure rye comprises its products.
If you can find it, you might also try Elijah Craig 12. It is on the lower end price wise. I have only just tried it once and it seemed acceptable enough. However, I really need to try more of it to comment further. Bourbon is not the whisk(e)y type I have much experience with.
Speaking of expanding a drink cabinet, I need to expand mine. Mine consists of a bottle of Aberlour a'bunadh, Laphroaig Cask Strength or Quarter Cask (do not remember which one), Lagavulin 12, and a nearly finished bottle of Macallan 12.
Any suggestions? I am a beginner when it comes to bourbon.
FK says no to Heaven Hill, but their Rittenhouse Rye is pretty good. The Elijah Craig is their ryed bourbon. The Rittenhouse is great quality for the price and good for mixed drinks like old fashioneds and manhattans, etc. I also like Wild Turkey products. They tend to taste very bright and spicy.
There are rules for what you can call your drink based on the composition of the mash bill. It's gotta be half corn to be bourbon. Then you have ryed, wheated, and all kinds of bourbon. If it's a majority rye, then you have rye whiskey. Same for wheat. There's also corn whiskey, which I'm pretty sure is just straight moonshine because otherwise it's sort of redundant.
It's good to try whiskeys of all different types so you get to learn how the taste changes with the mash bill.