Citizen Kane
4K - HDR10 - DTS-HD MA
Film - 9/10
I’m ashamed to say in all the years I’ve been watching cinema, I’d never seen this film. Considered by many as a masterpiece.
I won’t give away the story as some may still never have watched it, but I have to say I found it entertaining. Maybe a little over melodramatic in places but overall a great turn of performances by the main man and his co-stars.
As far as the story goes it’s interesting but it just didn’t keep me enthralled enough.
Image - 8/10
I’m watching this for the first time in 4K, so I’ve never seen it on any other format to do a direct comparison.
So does it look good on the new 4K transfer? Yes and no, it’s a real mixed bag. I’m sure it looks much better that previous formats but it’s by far not a stunner. Lots of transitions soften some shots and others looks really detailed and lovely.
It seems to have been shot with a lot of natural light so at times people are deep in shadow and while the HDR does help with shadow detail it’s not a way of film making we seen today or at least not very often.
Film grain is here but it’s well controlled and doesn’t hamper the image.
It’s safe to say this film isn’t a demo worthy disk to whip out and show off to friends and family, it is however a good transfer of a film 71 years old. I can’t seen this being any better beyond this 4K, the negative or what ever elements they used for this transfer can’t offer up anything more. The limitations of the film stock, camera & lenses just don’t lend themselves to a tack sharp image edge to edge.
If you’re on the fence about this film, I’d seek out a stream or a Blu-ray copy cheap. Watch the film and then decide if you need the 4K as it maybe disappointing to some people.
Sound - 5/10
The audio is a weird one. It’s not a soundtrack which is going to blow your socks off and it isn’t meant to. It’s a perfectly serviceable audio track. However the 4K is presented in 5.1 (from and original Mono!!) and the Blu-ray has the original Mono. Why this is I have no idea, it seems a very weird choice and I’d loved to have had the Mono on the 4K too.
Overall
It’s a good film and better than I expected but the image and sound were just about ok. I’ve given the image a better score, simply for its as good as the source will look I’m sure and I’m betting compared to previous formats and releases it’s a revelation to hardened fans. First time watchers though won’t miss out on too much by choosing the Blu-ray.
Singing in the Rain
4K - HDR10 - DTS-HD MA
Film - 8/10
Just like Citizen Kane, I’d never seen Singing in the Rain. I knew of two songs from the film but beyond that I didn’t know much. For me the film was a delight and rather quite charming. Donald O’Conner and Debbie Reynolds were excellent but Gene Kelly came across about creepy and he didn’t make me like his character.
There is no taking away from the Trios dancing and singing abilities and they really showed those skills here. Utterly fantastic. I found the amount of makeup on Gene Kelly to be distracting but the sets and costumes were excellent and brought everything together.
At first I couldn’t tell if the cheesy comedy was intended or just part of it being it’s age. Turns out it was part of films intent and once I learnt that I enjoyed it more.
Image - 9/10
It’s a stunner, it’s not always pin sharp but you can tell this is not an encode or scan issue but just the lens choice and cinematography choice. For example there are a few shots of closeups and they look quite soft, then the image zooms out and you realise it’s actually a very long zoom and it was the limitation of the lens which had caused the softness.
The film is presented in Technicolor and boy is it a rainbow on the screen. So much so you can see that some shots show the actors to have really white teeth and they almost look like Ross in that episode of Friends. But then there are some closeups and you can see the true colour of their teeth and they’re not as white as you expect.
HDR is wonderful here and it’s a lovely deep and vivid image throughout. Highlights shoot off the screen and the deep rich colours give them a solid grounding. Grain is also in effect but again it’s under control and not distracting.
Sound - 8/10
Presented in 5.1 it’s a lovely soundtrack and while most of the film there isn’t much going on apart from dialogue etc. the musical numbers sound excellent and never harsh. Otherwise it’s standard fair and well rounded.
Overall
I’m not sure what I expected from this film. I’m not adverse to watching a musical but I’m not one to sit and watch them all the time. However this one grabbed me and I enjoyed it very much. I can see myself watching it again at some point.
Flatliners
4K - Dolby Vision - DTS-HD MA
Film - 10/10
Joel Schumacher brought us an excellent film coming off the back of Lost Boys and it brought him back to work with Kiefer Sutherland, a winning combo.
From the first time I watched this film I was hooked and I’ve owned a copy on most formats apart from Blu-ray. The last copy I owned before this Arrow release was a DVD version, before that it was VHS.
The casting is excellent, the premise is fun and it has some rather dark scenes that as a younger viewer I found creepy. It’s not an out right horror movie and more of a thriller with supernatural elements.
If you’ve never watched it I can highly recommend it.
Image - 9/10
I didn’t give this film 10/10 for image but I was close. This new Dolby Vision scan is a looker. It’s got a huge amount of detail retrieval compared to the DVD I’m used to and the colours just wash the screen and add to the movies already tense atmosphere.
For the most part the DV pulls out lots of shadow detail and really is a feast for the eyes, however it can look a little dark at times and I can advise to watch this in a darkened room or at least light controlled one.
Those on the fence with this version, fear not, it’s a revelation and I’m super happy to have this in the collection.
Sound 8/10
It’s not a huge action packed film so the soundtrack holds up well for a dialogue heavy film. What little ambiance is there is rendered lovely but I felt more could be made of it and the film would lend itself to an Atmos of DTS-X soundtrack with some light overhead actions and a more spacious side channel mix. But for what it is you can hear the speaking and the music and effects don’t go too far.
Overall
This film is a favourite and when I knew it was getting and Arrow 4K release I’d been watching and waiting with baited breath. I wasn’t disappointed and it’s one disc I’m very happy I own.