Ok, so feedback for the Xbox one controller.
Straightly put: it's really awkward for me. After a lot of settings tweaking, the cars are just too fiddly and overreacting to inputs, we are not looking at a Forza or gt level of controller experience for sure. It's hard for me to recommend this to a sole controller user
BUT
I said this in my Mito post and I'll say it again here. I feel something very special with this game. The tricky pad controls aren't completely blocking me from those insane physics below. Everything regarding physics feels so smooth and gradual, as opposed to the more erratic behaviour I received from PCARS on and off the wheel. There are way less times where I'm left thinking "wtf just happened?", the majority of it happens and I know it will and why. I'm gutted my t150 won't work with Xbox, but my plan was always to buy it for ps4 too. And this has only made me want it more. I can't wait to experience this game properly