I understand what you're saying but if you look at his posts, he's not actually reviewing the game or speaking negatively about a gameplay aspect that he hasn't experienced for himself. He's just repeated what many of us have reported
He wanted the game. He's been involved in these forums from day one of the announcement of the console version. Like you and me, and everyone else here, he was excited and hopeful. The reviews here and on all racing sites are quite the mixed bag. That gives him pause that maybe he shouldn't buy the game, despite his initial excitement.
Yes, he has said now, more than a handful of times that he's not buying the game or he's glad he hasn't purchased the game or he'll wait until it's patched for the better. I get that may be annoying to you but would you consider cutting him some slack?
He's one of us, part of our community of guys who are so interested in racing games that we frequent forums to talk about the games and share ideas and compare notes and even disagree at times. We are a relatively small concern here. Take the positive that he's at the very least not insulting other people, not demeaning other people. He's simply disappointed and expressing it, albeit quite often. Lol
The world has much bigger problems. Let these forums be a safe haven and light hearted. Peace