FM Vs GT - Discussion Thread (read the first post before you post)

  • Thread starter Scaff
  • 8,743 comments
  • 540,306 views
Actually I hope this helps:



Recorded on October 17, 2011. Unfortunately the position of the camera and the slight camera tilt needs to be consider, however between 1:16 and 1:26 you can see that the banking on that curve isn't as pronounced as it is on GT5, likewise the curve itself seems to be more pronounced on these three games(FM4, FM3 and GT5), but FM4 seems to have the least baking and actually seem more similar to the RL version.
 
Last edited:
laguna2.jpg

laguna-1.jpg


Well from this image it seems that the corkscrew in FM4 isnt as accurate as the one in GT5 and in fact it is a bit exagerated... :dopey::dopey::dopey:

Well well.

Actually I hope this helps:



Recorded on October 17, 2011. Unfortunately the position of the camera and the slight camera tilt needs to be consider, however between 1:16 and 1:26 you can see that the banking on that curve isn't as pronounced as it is on GT5, likewise the curve itself seems to be more pronounced on these three games(FM4, FM3 and GT5), but FM4 seems to have the least baking and actually seem more similar to the RL version.


well well well, seems like all three games have it wrong. Iracing and GT5 have more pronounce corkscrew, Forza 4's Corkscree is free flowing.
 
I don't think any Forza player would complain if Turn 10 were to announce more accurate tracks. However I don't think track discrepancies hurt our enjoyment of the game to the extent that we'd rather play a competitor's. It'd take the combination of a number of negative factors to completely turn me off a game.

Some GT lovers call Forza more of a game than a sim. Actually, I think it integrates its sim aspects well into a fun game to play.
 
I don't think any Forza player would complain if Turn 10 were to announce more accurate tracks. However I don't think track discrepancies hurt our enjoyment of the game to the extent that we'd rather play a competitor's. It'd take the combination of a number of negative factors to completely turn me off a game.

Some GT lovers call Forza more of a game than a sim. Actually, I think it integrates its sim aspects well into a fun game to play.

Well if you do your research, you will find FM4 is much more of a sim than GT5 as far as physics, tuning, and upgrades go. Watch some of Scaffs recent vids. If you want to get as close to a sim on a console, FM is the way to go.

I have said it before though, GT5 nor FM4 are really sims. They are games with sim-like physics. That does not take anything away from them.
 
Well if you do your research you will see that you have a funny way of showing it...

Please enlighten me then. I guess my writing skills are not up to par, and I cant seem to convey a message.

So instead of just trying to be a jerk, why dont you show me where I am disagreeing with anything UKMikey posted. All I did was add to his point.
 
Well if you do your research, you will find FM4 is much more of a sim than GT5 as far as physics, tuning, and upgrades go.

That part implied disagreement to me, and I was actually going to post the same thing T-12 did but he beat me to it.
 
Please enlighten me then. I guess my writing skills are not up to par, and I cant seem to convey a message.

So instead of just trying to be a jerk, why dont you show me where I am disagreeing with anything UKMikey posted. All I did was add to his point.

I just tryed to show you in a funny way why T12 told you that... I thought you would understand because I did and English isnt even my native language... But if that makes me a jerk so be it...
 
That part implied disagreement to me, and I was actually going to post the same thing T-12 did but he beat me to it.

Ok, I guess I can see that. Maybe if I wrote according to Scaffs and others research, or after some research?

Sorry if I offended you UKMikey. I was just agreeing and adding to your post.
 
Well if you do your research, you will find FM4 is much more of a sim than GT5 as far as physics, tuning, and upgrades go. Watch some of Scaffs recent vids. If you want to get as close to a sim on a console, FM is the way to go.

I have said it before though, GT5 nor FM4 are really sims. They are games with sim-like physics. That does not take anything away from them.

Both games are the same as a sim... All calculating the same physical variables the same way. Hack them, then find out which one lacks.

Add reason why FM4 pwns please:tup:.
 
Both games are the same as a sim... All calculating the same physical variables the same way. Hack them, then find out which one lacks.

Add reason why FM4 pwns please:tup:.

No, they dont. No reason to "hack" them to find out. I have already stated one reason FM4 is more sim-like than GT5. Please read.
 
So why not have a dedicated thread for GT5's Laguna? I sense a conspiracy! :scared:

I sense a new person thinking they know the forum and it's people before they've gotten their feet wet. There is no conspiracy, and just cause it's a forum named for GT doesn't mean fans can't criticize.
 
No, really? If everyone is just lapping the 'Ring, why is there a 200,000+ GT5 community on here discussing everything from tuning to trading to course making to arranged events and even more, and barely 1,000 users on Forza's community (which basically consists of this thread), where all those Forza... (you know what I mean, but if I said it Scaff would be after me) lives.

I'm not sure how comparing two fan site's populations is in any way relevant - especially as Forza Planet has yet to be officially launched, and is not even three months old. Nevermind the large amount of inactives here.

Judging by that last sentence, I suppose it's much too hard to grasp that some people actually can (and do) enjoy more than a single franchise. These are video games, not life-long partners - the idea of pledging unflinching allegiance to either one is frankly silly.

Both games are the same as a sim... All calculating the same physical variables the same way. Hack them, then find out which one lacks.

Add reason why FM4 pwns please:tup:.

Well, except they don't calculate the same variables, and it's highly unlikely they handle them in the same way, either.

GT does lack tire width modelling, though (or at least fudges it, massively).

...

As for the issue of "why isn't this in the GT5 section", I posted something similar at FP, and it can be echoed here - ForzaPlanet's (and this subforum's) general populace is relatively unique in the Forza community, in that the vast majority are also members here, and have played the GT series, usually pretty thoroughly. While that doesn't erase bias (we all have it, to some degree), it certainly does afford those members a more balanced viewpoint from which to contrast and compare both series, especially their two newest titles.

There are bound to be Forza players who haven't touched GT5 yet blindly hate on it, yes, but at least over at FP, it's much less likely, and definitely less likely than the amount of GT players in our GT5 section who have never touched FM4.
 
Last edited:
Looks like from those pics that GT5 has a better representation of the corkscrew as it is closer to iRacing. FM4 one looks too flat as you can see the ground below which you should not be able to.
 
Looks like from those pics that GT5 has a better representation of the corkscrew as it is closer to iRacing. FM4 one looks too flat as you can see the ground below which you should not be able to.

Looks...from that camera angle.

Also, before you pass judment, it would add more weight if you actually played all 3, not just 1.
 
Looks...from that camera angle.

Also, before you pass judment, it would add more weight if you actually played all 3, not just 1.

Don't pass up his judgement, sure he hasn't played all of them but it doesn't take Einstein to see the differences. If i am correct Scaff came to the same conclusion, and i am sure he has played at-least 2 of those games.

Scaffs comment.

Opps - my bad missed the bottom screen grab (!!!!!!!!!!!!!), yep that's an issue indeed. Which gives problems with both GT5 and FM4's versions.



Scaff
 
Looks like from those pics that GT5 has a better representation of the corkscrew as it is closer to iRacing. FM4 one looks too flat as you can see the ground below which you should not be able to.

Can I ask, are you ever going to answer my questions regarding the second Cobra video?

Basically your reply to this entire post......

https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?p=6484112#post6484112

....would be of interest to me.



Don't pass up his judgement, sure he hasn't played all of them but it doesn't take Einstein to see the differences. If i am correct Scaff came to the same conclusion, and i am sure he has played at-least 2 of those games.
I did and I have (well three if you count GT5, FM3 and FM4), still want to grab some shots myself from both GT5 and FM4 and try and match the cameras track position and height as much as I can, see just how much of a difference we are talking about.



Scaff
 
Last edited:
Don't pass up his judgement, sure he hasn't played all of them but it doesn't take Einstein to see the differences. If i am correct Scaff came to the same conclusion, and i am sure he has played at-least 2 of those games.

No according to him, he has only played GT5. And seeing a difference in a screen grab, and actually playing all 3 are different.
 
I don't want to break up the flow of discussion revolving around Laguna Seca, but since this is the thread to discuss Forza vs. GT, I have something new to add.

This is just me, but aside from Forza fan boys and GT ones, I've noticed a third type of person. They're basically guys that criticize GT and talk about how great Forza is, but yet continue to play GT5 all the time. Also, despite talking about how great Forza is, they can't seem to get themselves to play the game even if they have the means (i.e. own a Xbox 360).

Aside from seeing people online who fit this description, I have a friend I know in person who is like this. It's kind of funny and painful to watch him play all the time and yet complain, but after looking at the features in Forza that are not in GT5 and getting hyped about them, when he does get the opportunity to play Forza 4 he kind of shrugs off the game with a vague statement, "The handling feels wrong", despite still having an opinion that Forza is the better game. From there, he goes back to playing GT5 and back to the old bickering.

I've actually told him this, but these kind of people remind me of girls who keep on dating jerks and complaining about them, but yet when a non-jerk (though not necessarily a "nice guy") who is a much better match for the girl shows interest in her, she either tells him they're too good of friends or he's too nice of a guy. From there, she goes back to being with jerk guys and complaining again.

I should note I'm not advocating one game over the other here, but I just wonder why some people complain about GT5 so much but yet continue to play it? This even makes less sense when some of these people talk about how great another rival title in the racing genre is but seem to back down when they are offered to play that game or they try it out.
 
I don't want to break up the flow of discussion revolving around Laguna Seca, but since this is the thread to discuss Forza vs. GT, I have something new to add.

This is just me, but aside from Forza fan boys and GT ones, I've noticed a third type of person. They're basically guys that criticize GT and talk about how great Forza is, but yet continue to play GT5 all the time. Also, despite talking about how great Forza is, they can't seem to get themselves to play the game even if they have the means (i.e. own a Xbox 360).

Aside from seeing people online who fit this description, I have a friend I know in person who is like this. It's kind of funny and painful to watch him play all the time and yet complain, but after looking at the features in Forza that are not in GT5 and getting hyped about them, when he does get the opportunity to play Forza 4 he kind of shrugs off the game with a vague statement, "The handling feels wrong", despite still having an opinion that Forza is the better game. From there, he goes back to playing GT5 and back to the old bickering.

I've actually told him this, but these kind of people remind me of girls who keep on dating jerks and complaining about them, but yet when a non-jerk (though not necessarily a "nice guy") who is a much better match for the girl shows interest in her, she either tells him they're too good of friends or he's too nice of a guy. From there, she goes back to being with jerk guys and complaining again.

I should note I'm not advocating one game over the other here, but I just wonder why some people complain about GT5 so much but yet continue to play it? This even makes less sense when some of these people talk about how great another rival title in the racing genre is but seem to back down when they are offered to play that game or they try it out.

Yeah, I have seen that also. But, I have also seen the reverse; they complain about Forza and that T10 should include something GT has but then continue to play Forza. You can never please some.
 
Yeah, I have seen that also. But, I have also seen the reverse; they complain about Forza and that T10 should include something GT has but then continue to play Forza. You can never please some.

There is a fourth type, I'd say which is the type that plays all racing sims and criticizes them all, but does one more than the others because that game may deserve it. I'm glad GT got me into the sim racing scene and gave me the ability to do something that in real life is expensive and something that many would be drivers never get big at. However, I'm willing to call GT, FM and others on their crap. What I see too much of here and on the GT5 section is a bunch of apologist or naive players that are star struck and can't get off of cloud nine with GT5 to save their lives.

I know GT5 isn't doom and gloom rubbish but when compared to it's past iterations, something is missing and it does have a lackluster feel, but also a feel that it's trying to catch up with a group of racing games that are trying to appeal to a younger crowd that isn't so much into sim racing but car chases, this is easily seen on the public rooms that dominate the GT populations more so than GTP users sadly. Over this past year though PD has tried to restore the game to where it once was and doing exciting things or gearing up to do great things in GT6, but I don't think they should have made GT5 an experimental game when the GT5P was great in itself. I tend to enjoy GT5 from time to time, but then the bar is knocked down due to new moves that are too radical, like the tire update.

FM to me for a long time wasn't that great with setups and car control and seemed to go one of two ways for me. Either far too much understeer or the opposite too much oversteer. You'd think that upgrades would make it better but, that wasn't the case really and at times it became worse. This new game seems to have ironed out that to a degree. The things that trump GT5 are the non-Pokémon collecting paint system, livery graphics and personalizing cars, then you have more performance parts, great sounds and visual scenes. However, the cars at times seem to have too much glare and the shadow isn't very consistent and this game still gives me the same feeling with cars that aren't always accurate like the Enzo and Viper ACR. Yet the new game also does something that GT has yet to accomplish at least not since GT1 and GT2 and that is a diversity of cars from across the world.
 
Last edited:
There is a fourth type, I'd say which is the type that plays all racing sims and criticizes them all, but does one more than the others because that game may deserve it. I'm glad GT got me into the sim racing scene and gave me the ability to do something that in real life is expensive and something that many would be drivers never get big at. However, I'm willing to call GT, FM and others on their crap. What I see too much of here and on the GT5 section is a bunch of apologist or naive players that are star struck and can't get off of cloud nine with GT5 to save their lives.

I like you. You can come over to my house and make whoopie with my sister. :):)
 
I made a video (not bias) on a comparison on GT and Forza. Before i was a gt fan i was a heave forza 2 fan, not gonna lie.. But this video explains why i switched to GT5. If i said anything you think is bias, please tell me and i will re upload an improved version. I basically went over personal experiences and opinions and observations of both games.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b8fC...xt=C36334a7UDOEgsToPDskJVGUoZH6HcvlU6RnfJshvC

Any chance you could write up a summary, because video is a bit of a generous description.

11 minutes monologue with swearing and the occasional screen shot would be more apt, and to be honest I lost the will to follow it after about a minute.


Scaff
 
Back