- 11,303
- Sweden
- eran0004
Yes it does. Why would they give the cars those sounds if they didn't think that's how cars should sound like?
Give us better sounds - PLEASE !!
- Thread starter steamcat
- 4,667 comments
- 353,302 views
Yes it does. Why would they give the cars those sounds if they didn't think that's how cars should sound like?
- 4,035
- Gothenburg
- Agremont
- 15,532
- Cairo, Egypt
- GTP_SEMS
PD always add external engine sounds during trailers,remember the Tesla at E3 2010
Beautiful soundtrack though
Beautiful soundtrack though
- 1,130
- Mexico City
- ppmike921
- MikeB0ssMan
You must be new to PD's trailers then, they always have dubbed sounds for their trailers, in fact, with this new trailer I could tell that a few samples were reused from the GT5 spec 2.0 intro. No hope here, I'm 100% sure that sound will be just as bad as it has always been if not worse.
- 71
- Maryland
- Sapphire-Wolf
- 8,723
Yup, marketers...
- 2,583
- Kelowna, Canada
- Antonisbob
- No...
^ What happened to the Van Halen in that opening movie? Well that just made it a lot less epic.
- 8,723
- 4,554
- Right here
- dj_ali007
All the cars from the trailer/demo" of E3 did sound like a toaster with 100HP. Hope that the other cars have better sound.
- 3,100
- Sweden
- 8,723
Yes, clearly. But tell that to the 15 year old me.
So is it your fault or PD's that 15-year-old you was a dunce? Your post is ambiguous.
They'd never get away with it if they somehow dubbed the visuals (they usually use in-game assets, effects and mechanics, just super-sampled / hi-fi), so I guess all the 15-year-old yous in the world need to get with the program and pay attention to what their ears are telling them.
Then maybe collectively we could give PD's trailer division the message that sound, like the visuals, ought to be transparent, too.
- 505
- OL_APEX
Sound comparison of the Sauber C-9 [turbocharged V8]. PD please take note!!!
Gran Turismo 5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMU8GMgDSNM
Forza 4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GRYk0KA5dWs
Real life
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQVWvNIzVSc
Gran Turismo 5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMU8GMgDSNM
Forza 4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GRYk0KA5dWs
Real life
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQVWvNIzVSc
- 4,035
- Gothenburg
- Agremont
- 3,100
- Sweden
It's the intro. But hey, sorry for being easily fooled and expecting it to resemble the sounds in the game atleast to a certain level. Lesson learned, ever since.So is it your fault or PD's that 15-year-old you was a dunce? Your post is ambiguous.
They'd never get away with it if they somehow dubbed the visuals (they usually use in-game assets, effects and mechanics, just super-sampled / hi-fi), so I guess all the 15-year-old yous in the world need to get with the program and pay attention to what their ears are telling them.
Then maybe collectively we could give PD's trailer division the message that sound, like the visuals, ought to be transparent, too.
Last edited:
I've never really understood all the hate on the sound. I happen to own a 09 370z and as long as my surround sound is on the car in Gt5 sounds almost identical. Yes they clearly got some cars wrong. SS camaro with titanium exhaust comes to mind, but most stock vehicles aren't as bad as people make it out to be. Maybe I'm a glass half full type of guy.
- 4,035
- Gothenburg
- Agremont
theofilosz
(Banned)
- 409
- Greece
- the0f1l0s
There is still big difference between Forza 4 and the real car BUT I would take Forza's sound over GT5 without hesitation.
Forza sounds like a real car and gives you a good feeling you want to rev it up!
The GT5 sound is awful!
At least I hope that PD for GT6 will put some more generic sounds that will make you to want to volume up instead of mosquito or hoover sounds!!! Better to have sounds of something similar than nothing!
- 8,723
As long as that lesson wasn't just "don't trust trailers" but also "learn to trust your ears".
Hand-mixed dubbing is so awful it should be banned from all media, especially film. The unnaturalness of it should be apparent to anyone who has spent time near cars - but, as it turns out, in the main, spending time near and actually listening / paying attention to cars' sounds are not the same thing by any stretch.
It seems people don't really lean on their hearing anything like they do, say, their vision (or maybe it's just more easily swayed by our imaginations), hence iPods and the predominance of mp3s et c.
- 478
- Manchester
- United6694
One of the worst i've heard is the BMW M3 CSL, unless the inside noise in standards is generic, it is shocking
- 2,790
- Vancouver, BC
- liampage123
If only the engine sounds were as good as the soundtracks they picked.
- 8,723
The sound "inside" is the same as outside, just mixed differently. The "engine" note dominates in the internal view. The problem is that the real car has that virtually unsilenced intake, and GT doesn't have intake sounds.
All that's left is the engine noise, which is largely mechanical. The exhaust sound also happens to be from the wrong car, too.
- 478
- Manchester
- United6694
Ah ok, but its not even the intake sound, at the same speed, gear and revs the two are nowhere near from inside
- 2,012
In addition to both points, there's the perception that PD will not be able to fix all sounds (most probably requires new samples) for GT6, if ever.
It's the same that happened with cars and tracks: now we will have 'standard' and 'premium' effects and cars sounds, or with new distinctions like it'll probably be in GT6 (straight from ps2, improved versions of ps2 content, gt5, gt5 dlc quality, gt6)
- 2,790
- Vancouver, BC
- liampage123
Similar threads
