You raise quite a few good points Dave,
Please allow me to add/ask/correct/suggest and elaborate more:
You're assuming that GT7 will continue in the vein of GT Sport. GT Sports whole purpose was competetive online competition, e-sports. GT7 may pick up that mantle, but other than GT Sport Live which is just where videos and media from GT Sport can be found, we've seen no suggestions that GT7 will be a big e-sports game. Yet.
Everything that GT Sport is, GT7 will definitely pick everything up and add the traditional as well as the part we have yet to see...
GT7 = past, present (GTS), and future.
So yes, GTS and the competitiveness of it and the association with the FIA, will be an full integral part of GT7.
For those of us not interested, in the online part, which is the majority of the GTS players, given to those who can afford to make the jump, will spend most of their time in the "past and future" aspects of GT7, rather than the "present" (aka GTS within GT7).
It's entirely plausable that GT Sport will continue to host the e-sports and then at an approprate time the baton be passed to GT7.
Absolutely! Kaz and PD, as well as Sony and FIA want people to jump to the more powerful console as soon as possible (no doubt about it), so the push to have esport on GT7 will be there...
However, I don't think GT7 has to have a big e-sports involvement.
see right above. GT7 will have a big e-sports involvement, esport is one of the icons on the main menu of GT7.
Very few people actually compete in GT Sport competetively, ....
yes i agree but...
so from a business perspective there's not a huge amount to be gained from gearing GT7 in that direction. They might choose that providing a more classic GT will be following the money.
again yes i agree, BUT
I do not think that they will separate GTS and GT7 as you described, because:
1) Sony would want to push as many people onto the PS5 as soon as possible, therefore they will incorporate GTS into GT7 to give the early adopters the advantage of a more pleasing and satisfying experience...
Despite the current numbers (low number of people actually playing eSport compared to the number of people owning GTS), but the future is clearly in eSport and online racing competition.
PD has an edge over all other racing games by virtue of the association with FIA.
PD might not have F1, but the association with FIA cannot be taken lightly and is PRICELESS.
and for this reason, eSPORT will continue to be a very important aspect going forward, including with GT7.
HAVING SAID THAT, Kaz/PD and Sony ALSO have the "obligation" to allow people to continue playing GTS for at least the next 2 years (as they have done in the past) because, as much as they want people to upgrade to PS5, the reality of things is that only a few Millions (a dozen tops) can jump to the next Gen console...
Realistically, Kaz/PD/Sony cannot force people to upgrade to PS5 overnight... that is ethically not possible.
For this reason, I do not think that they will separate GTS and GT7 as you described, because:
2) If they severe all ties with GTS, then GT7 would become the only active GT game (whenever that is released), at which point there will be lots of moaning and crying !
Business-wise, it would be very unwise...
I do not think that they will separate GTS and GT7 as you described, because:
3) Technically, it would make little sense to have official competitions on two different consoles... Or two-tier competitions...
So i suspect that the GTS portion of GT7 will be exactly the same as the GTS on PS4, in the name of fairness.
Meaning that any update withing GT7 with respect to GTS (esport), will be reflected onto GTS on PS4.
For the next two years while Sony support the overlapping of players on PS4 and players on PS5, that situation will be as such.
What you will see in GTS on PS4 will be what you are seeing now, but for PS5 players, they will benefit from ray tracing and what not.
?
At the end of the day, as I'm sure you understand and aren't arguing against, we don't know at this time. We might see cross platform online competition but it's unlikely in my opinion.
well said. Our opinion differs. We are simply discussing the possibilities (or not) based on what we dont know...
We've already seen hints the GT7 is using a different tyre model in the video, I'd wagers the physics are an evolution of GT Sports engine, but they won't be identical so lap times likely won't be either.
As much as i want to GT7 to have a new updated tyre model or driving physics... i dont think so, because PD want to save time and just use what we already have from GTS, the same way as for car graphics and models.
For this reason, competition on cross platform can happen.
And if there is any tyre model or driving physics being updated in GT7, i wager it will be reflected onto GT Sport.
The car and track selection is different too, so you would essentially be limiting GT7 to GT Sport in the online e-sports competitition and leaving t hose fewer people who are more intereted in the e-sports over the traditional single player experience with little reason to make the switch form GT Sport to GT7.
Fair point being made.
Why wouldn't GT Sport benefit from a car list update ?
At least make the new car available only for the e-sport portion?
PS5 players will retain all their benefits from being early adopters.
PS4 players will be able to still play GTS against GT7
but while we discuss this particular scenario,
i still dont see why we PS4 wouldn't be able to also purchase a GT7 that is playable on the PS4 at a degraded mode, which would have everything in GTS, making the GTS stand alone game obsolete... at least with this scenario, we would have the full roster of the GT7...
The only downside would be that we dont have a gaming experience as polished as those with the PS5.
That's just my opinion and how I read the intuition of course, and I respect; you may not see it the same way. We will have to wait and see and hopefully for both our sakes, GT7 delivers what we want.
agreed, same here, i am just sharing my gut feeling.
Gran Turismo had always been on one console, multi-platform never was an option to PD If you look back in his history. Besides, Sony has no intention to port PS5 games over PS4.
Yes i am aware of the GT history... but things are different nowadays...
Despite the Sony executive saying they want a clean switch, but maybe the will do an exception for Gran Turismo... they are at a situation where a large division will be created, as i explained just above.
Neither of us know for sure, and so i cannot say that you are wrong, but my guess is as is: there will be some sort of cross or overlap to allow for an easier transition.
No other games on PS5 has this dilemna... except for GTA, but that's an oddball.