- 2,945
- Austria
- GTP_SnowCrash
Actually, I agree and disagree with you at the same time. I don't think a BoP can be done for any car, if they are too far apart. You may even be able to get them to have the same lap time on one specific track, but wildly differing on others. That's not what a BoP should be, i.e. working on the majority of tracks. On some tracks a BoP can be expected to favour certain cars - Le Mans will favour one extreme of the spectrum and Tsukuba the opposite, but that's how it's supposed to be.A BOP can be done in any car, sure. We can balance a F1 car to race against a TCR (and I agree with you about the possibility to do personal BOPs for custom races and championships, and the ability to save those settings for online lobbies too, don't get me wrong). But considering the vanilla races, why would you botch the experience of simulating the racing of those cars closely in what they would perform, to accommodate them in a discipline where they don't belong? And other externalities, like the tire and fuel consumption, would be considered?
The Renault Mégane Trophy is best example why this doesn't work. Since it was added in Gr.4 we play a pendulum game of nerf it because is dominating/buff it because is useless. This happens with this car because 1. It has much more downforce and corner capability than the rest of the other road car derivatives. 2. Its completely race build. 3. It's much more lighter (955kg), which eats much less the tires (the 4C and the FWDs are lighter too, but the Alfa doesn't have the downforce, and the FWD chew the tires). Instead of keeping the class balanced for all the other cars, it always attracts the work for it. It would be much better if it was in Gr.X, since it is an one make spec series anyway, and we already had the Mégane "TCR". It will happen too with the 155, because it ticks the same 3 characteristics of the Mégane. It kills the class and its a poor game design.
And about the work, IMHO It demands much more rework to keep balancing cars with completely different builds and characteristics, instead of keeping relevantly close ones together. With the addition of classic racing cars in GT7, it would be much better to create new classic car classes, and by the looks we will have a lot of them to fill!!
I actually tried to make a real BoP for the N-classes in GTS, because there is one in game, but nobody at PD apparently really cares about it, which results in wildly differing lap times. Surprisingly, the majority of cars could be BoP'd, if they had only tried. But also there, some cars cannot be made to fit the others. (e.g. the KTM X-Bow on the top end, and the US muscle cars from the 60's on the bottom end)
I do agree that the Megane Trophy shouldn't be in Gr.4 for the exact reasons you named. So, there you have it - you might be right about the 155, but I suspect the difference will be less than with the Megane.