- 29,377
- Glasgow
- GTP_Mars
First of all, it's good to hear that this. Concerns regarding bloodlust notwithstanding, it is perfectly understandable to see people in the streets of New York celebrating.
I too do not share Danoff's cynicism regarding Obama's speech in many regards - while Obama perhaps could have emphasised the bigger picture more, I feel that it goes without saying how important this is in the wider context. Obama does say "thanks to the tireless and heroic work of our military and our counter-terrorism professionals" and praises their "extraordinary courage and capability", but I don't blame him for mentioning the current administration's redoubling of efforts to take Bin Laden out. While it will be viewed by some (cynics included) as a mere point-scoring exercise, I don't see it that way myself. Bin Laden was likely never going to be taken alive, so killing him was arguably the only way to serve justice upon him - and hence, whoever was at the helm when it was finally achieved deserves praise, not criticism. Bush had eight years to do it, but it clearly wasn't a priority - he even pretty much said so himself. Obama's speech does have an element of triumphalism to it, but then again, why shouldn't it?
One thing is for sure - this makes Pakistan (or atleast the Pakistani authorities) look very bad indeed.
I too do not share Danoff's cynicism regarding Obama's speech in many regards - while Obama perhaps could have emphasised the bigger picture more, I feel that it goes without saying how important this is in the wider context. Obama does say "thanks to the tireless and heroic work of our military and our counter-terrorism professionals" and praises their "extraordinary courage and capability", but I don't blame him for mentioning the current administration's redoubling of efforts to take Bin Laden out. While it will be viewed by some (cynics included) as a mere point-scoring exercise, I don't see it that way myself. Bin Laden was likely never going to be taken alive, so killing him was arguably the only way to serve justice upon him - and hence, whoever was at the helm when it was finally achieved deserves praise, not criticism. Bush had eight years to do it, but it clearly wasn't a priority - he even pretty much said so himself. Obama's speech does have an element of triumphalism to it, but then again, why shouldn't it?
One thing is for sure - this makes Pakistan (or atleast the Pakistani authorities) look very bad indeed.