Argue/fight, no. Discuss, yes.
To be fair, we don't have that many disagreements. We don't always agree on many of our beliefs, political values, preferences, and we some times have fun with each other on that...but part of being a mod is never letting things like that ruffle you, being understanding, responding to the topic of the argument, rather than attacking the individual, and appreciating those differences to some degree (within good taste and the rules, of course).
We essentially have to be unanimous (or abstaining) in banishment and minor punishments, we'll even consider a single viewpoint that's in the minority, if the mod has made a good case for a said situation or guideline.
In the end, Jordan gets the final say, and he'll speak up or give us a suggestion on a new/temporary guideline to follow or even those in which to be more lax about, if necessary.