This is just too much now, I just have to say something here.
I am of the the complete opposite view. Who wouldn't swap Midfield for say Hockenheim or High Speed Ring for COTA? I would absolutely love all the fictional tracks to be dumped and only have real world circuits.
There is certainly enough of them to fill any game. There is at least 10 good ones from just Australia! The list of real world great circuits (past and present) is huge, I see no need for adding fictional ones.
<Flame suit: ON >
I'm kind of half way between you both on this one, as I really like some of PD's original circuits. The newer ones, like Rome, Madrid, Cape Ring, aren't good at all, and looking at this new Tokyo one, I'm thinking PD may have lost their touch when it comes to creating unique original tracks, but their older ones like Deep Forest, Midfield, Apricot Hill, Trial Mountain, etc. are really good circuits.
However, at the same time, I also agree with you that there are just so many amazing real world circuits to choose from, that the only reason I can think of to make new original circuits, and not just do real ones, is not having to pay licence fees. Other than that, I would prefer it if every new circuit in a GT game from here on is a real one. As you say, there are a number of bloody good circuits in Australia alone, and when you start looking at just a small number of the better known circuits from around the world, what you're saying becomes quite clear. Any racing game dev could include 10, 20, 30, hell, even 50 circuits that just aren't in many, if any, other racing games at all.
Eh, to each their own. Modern Hockenheim is such an absolute bore of a track for me that I'd much rather have something like Midfield. COTA's a little better, and with its numerous variations, offers a lot more options than HSR, so that's a harder comparison for me.
I must be one of the few people who actually quite like the modern Hockenheim layout. It's fun to race on, and has plenty of good overtaking opportunities, and in it's own right, is quite a good circuit. The only problem I have with it, and it's a big one, is that it's existence killed the original circuit, which was not only better, but had such a unique character, and deserved preservation. I have the exact same opinion of the Red Bull Ring. It's a great circuit (significantly better than modern Hockenheim IMO), but at the same time, it's a shadow of the track it replaced, and it replacing Osterreichring meant the demise of Osterreichring, which is truly sad (just as sad as Oran Park raceway being demolished to make way for a housing project
).
Original circuits are increasingly what differentiates the track lists of all the different games. Places like Brands Hatch, Laguna Seca, and the 'Ring are in just about every semi-serious racer now
That's the problem though isn't it? Other than fantasy tracks, every racing title seems to contain the same circuits as every other racing title. I think
@TT92's point was that there are hundreds of circuits around the world that deserve to be represented in a racing sim ahead of fantasy tracks. One of the things I loved about Codies' Race Driver 3 was the fact that it had so many tracks not found in other games, including literally every V8 Supercar circuit (including the late Oran Park). Other than that, I agree with you that PD's earlier efforts were very well designed, and their later efforts are best left forgotten.
My only wish is that the original creations be made less smooth, with more bumps and subtle surface changes typically seen in the real-world stuff. That'd really sell it for me.
When it comes to tracks, what has never sat well with me is hearing about how places like Rome and Madrid could take up to two years to model. I understand why it takes such a long time – PD wants to capture every detail accurately, which can pile up in an a dense urban environment – but when the resulting circuit is pretty meh, it just seems like a waste to me. Perhaps with the addition of Scapes, eye-candy-heavy circuits may be rare.
I couldn't agree with you more on these two points 👍