IMO there is such a thing as too much replay value (sometimes), with a lot of roguelites I end up feeling like a dog chasing a laser pointer, yes I'm having fun at the time but I feel like I never really achieve anything. Take Rogue Legacy for example, I beat it 21 times with the same character and did all the side stuff and yet still felt like I had more to do, I guess just because the game let me keep playing.
Yesterday was an unusually good nap day (for my kid, not me) so I managed to start and finish Donut County which I enjoyed. It's very short, dumb and not challenging at all, it felt like one of those games that exists purely to tell a story that wouldn't really work any other way and I appreciated that.
I've also been playing NFS Heat, basically just trundling through but trying to not grind either money or XP. It's a good game and I don't know why it isn't more highly regarded within the franchise although I wouldn't mind if the police chases were a little easier to end without having to resort to cheesing them by launching off a jump big enough to make them all crash, as if it's Blues Brothers or something. Also, turning the music off was a must.