I'd be saying everyone that has already been said... Hendrix (my arse he wasn't the best - he still is! If you could hide crappy untight playing behind distortion Kurt Cobain didn't do too well... you really can't hide behind it... Hendrix has pure voodoo soul, better than being anally in-time with a metronome IMO), Vai, Satch, SRV, Gilmour, Eric Johnson etc etc...
Except I'd elevate Mark Knopfler RIGHT up there near the top, along with Jeff Beck! Knopfler is even more 'tasteful' than Gilmour IMO, which takes some doing! His lines always just fit perfectly... and every tone he ever uses is just beautiful.
I also absolutely love Buddy Guy, that guy just cracks me up with his funny phrasing etc. He's the Thelonius Monk of the guitar world IMO!
There are so many awesome blues guys too... Albert Collins, both BB and Albert King, Hubert Sumlin, John Lee Hooker, Robert Cray etc etc...
I don't go for the super heavy metal guys really, I like a more tasteful, bluesy melodic sort of thing. I only love Satch and Vai because IMO they are the only two "fast/shredder" guitarists that can still make me "feel" their playing... I'm going against the trend so far in this thread but I have to say that Vai is much more emotional than Satch, and his note choices are more interesting - more strange modes and scales which give a really great atmosphere to his tunes... rather than just rockin' out bluesy jams like Satch seems to enjoy (much more the bluesman than Vai IMO). I still love Satch however!
I have to rock the boat and say that Eddie VH is crap. Not much (diversity of) emotion evident, and his note choices aren't all that interesting, even if he plays them fast. I think Vai or Satch is better. Eddie also comes across as having loads too much ego (dunno if he really does) and I just don't like the guy for some reason, maybe he's okay and I just haven't heard his ummm, supposedly more subtle and 'moving' stuff... but all the stuff I've heard just sounds like wanky fun-time rockin' out fretboard gymnastics for the sake of it. Plus I don't really like hair-metal of the david lee roth era. I didn't like Vai in that era either, but I like Vai's new (solo career) stuff cause its more emotional and spaced out trippy...
Eddie sounds like he's still playin' real fast and stuff, but its still pretty predictable American hair-metal and rock riffs- nothing wrong with that - but Vai (to me) sounds like he's comin' from outta space, from a different place entirely. He just channels these liquid, wierd alien talking kinda strange solos that are just flow so well despite their speed... I've always been drawn to people that just exude that eccentric kinda psychedelic crazyness... and Vai has definately picked up that mantle after Hendrix IMO...
Can anyone tell I like Vai?
I'm amazed I didn't find this thread before!