ok guys so I've been MIA for a while, busy with work, etc. A few weeks ago I started a conversation with a few of the regulars here about a big change in the way DC scoring is handled. In Hami's ford competition he scored the lap times differently by turning lap times into points. That kid of sparked an idea about how to integrate DC score into the point system that Hami used for the lap times that would allow us to have 1 true podium for challenges instead of a lap winner and a DC winner.
linked here is the google doc used for the mustang challenge. to the right you can see where the fastest lap is worth the full 10 points and other laps are then given point values based from how far behind they were. What I suggest is that we bump this up from a 10 point score to a 100 point score. We can then also score Drivers Choice on a 100 point scale by breaking it into categories. Then by combining both scores we would end up with a true "best" tune. Similar to the way that in racing 2 2nd place wins is worth more points than a win and a crash. We had a lengthy conversation (56 replies) and as a group decided that the 4 categories and their available points would be:
Corner entry @ 20pts
Mid corner @ 20pts
Corner exit @ 20pts
Enjoyment @ 40pts
I'll just give a short breakdown of what's included and how you would score each category.
-- Corner entry includes braking performance as well as turn in responsiveness and initial oversteer/understeer balance.
-- Mid corner includes how well the car holds a line, weight transfer, rotation, and how well it carries speed through a turn.
-- Corner exit includes exit grip and stability, LSD settings, and throttle control.
-- Enjoyment includes the most important part of DC scoring and is why it is weighted with the most points. It allows you to grade the personality of the car and your personal preference of the tune.
With this system it allows a car that is a blast to drive but a bit off the pace to still be a contender for the podium because that fun factor now counts toward a total score.
An example of how the new scoring system would look could be:
Mclaren MP4 - 49.475 - DC:84
Corner entry: 20pts - I love the braking. You can brake really late and it feels like it turns almost as well under braking as it does normally. You can also tap the brakes to tighten up the line and there is no disruption to the car whatsoever. Although it did not like making adjustments to your line once you started turning though.
Mid Corner: 16pts - It would coast into a corner well and held the line great. it seemed like it had to settle a bit before it really started rotating though
Corner exit: 18pts - it had lots of grip if you had your exit speed right and would really hold the line. If you hit the gas early though and had to lift even just a little, the car would wobble and take a second to regain it's balance and that would really slow you down.
Enjoyment: 30pts - I'm confident in this car as long as you are hitting your marks. It has lots of grip and turns well. It is not super predictable though and the exit understeer will sometimes catch you off guard. Despite being a MR car it felt safe and as though you are just along for the ride instead of barely controlling the reigns.
you can see that everything in our current review process is still included, including the short description of the car, it's just now broken into categories. Also rather than just reading that the corner exit had some understeer, the tuner can see that it was still above average with 18pts. that's because it turns great and holds the line of you aren't going to fast, but will understeer if you use the throttle too early. so it's still great turning ability, but not perfect.
I apologize for the large article you just had to read but I think that using this system would allow testers to give a more focused DC score while also giving more detailed feedback. It also includes everything we already do but allows the score to be more significant in where a car places. Thanks for you time guys and I look forward to any questions and discussion on this idea.
A special thanks to
@Bowtie-muscle @DaBomm4 @DolHaus @MrGrado @Otaliema @Ridox2JZGTE and
@shaunm80
also tagged for their opinion and input
@CyKosis1973 @Motor City Hami @krenkme @Lionheart2113 @praiano63 @brian wolf @Ronald6 @DigitalBaka @xande1959 @biffa3 @NEWDRIVER2
I'm I forgot to tag someone so apologies in advance, if there's anyone else you guys think need to weigh in on this please tag them.