I can appreciate how accurate AC and other simulators can be when it comes to a realistic driving experience. They've come a long way in the last decade. But, for me personally, I don't enjoy them as much as the simplistic approach to driving. When I sit down after a long day in college, the last thing I want to do is become aggravated that I can't drive a car at a reasonably decent pace. Maybe I'm more of a "plug n' play" kind of guy. I simply don't have the time, nor patience to sit there and mess with a setup and learn the car, just to run a few laps of the Nurburgring in an online lobby.
Some guys are going to enjoy different styles. Bless those guys who can run in a pack on iRacing. God knows I couldn't!
Right there with you. I did the PC sim thing over a decade ago, and don't have the patience to have to deal with everything anymore.
I think everybody has a bunch of personal sliding scales, for any number of aspects of games they deem important. For some, a big car list. Others, physics. Maybe it's sounds, customization, online play options — the list is different for everyone, and the priorities given to each scale are also different.
Plus, you have some games that are better suited to different things. The Horizon and Motorsport titles from Forza are perhaps the best example: covering two sides of the same genre.
Perhaps where things get murky is when people present these personal preferences as facts. "I like GT because I find it fun" is a perfectly fine thing to say. "GT is fun so therefore has the best physics" is just... bizarre.
Or you have the folks that go on about how [insert game] is immensely fun, that they can lap for hours without getting bored, and that "you need to try it before you knock it". But someone can have that feeling with
any game. Just admit it's because of the name on the box — no need to waffle on about some conveniently-impossible-to-name
soul of the game.
I just hate the fact that nowadays, all it ever seems is that GT is in some sort of argument where "this is better, it's outdated, LOL vacuum cleaners." If people enjoy different things, more power to them!
Eh, it works the other way too ("lol GT is bestestest"). Though I do agree with that last sentiment, very strongly: I'd much rather play as many racing games as possible. The idea of playing only one is sad.