- 8,725
I think that video has been posted about four times in the last hour or so, in different threads!
It also appeared much further back in this thread somewhere, back when we knew very little of GT5... hmm.
GT5 Sound Thread
- Thread starter Marry_Me_GT
- 5,638 comments
- 550,267 views
I think that video has been posted about four times in the last hour or so, in different threads!
It also appeared much further back in this thread somewhere, back when we knew very little of GT5... hmm.
- 244
It helps if like with like is compared.
The F1 road car is almost whisper quiet at low revs and has been well captured by PD.
The F1 tuner car is fictional while the F1 GTR has not yet been seen in GT5.
The F1 road car is almost whisper quiet at low revs and has been well captured by PD.
The F1 tuner car is fictional while the F1 GTR has not yet been seen in GT5.
shirakawaa
Premium
- 5,034
- GTP_shirakawaa
He doesn't specifically mention that improved sounds won't be heard until the final release, just that Yamauchi said that by the final release they will be improved. I think he was interpreting much what was said. Either way, the guy is not very clear, also he doesn't sound very professional and personally I wouldn't take for granted or over-analyze what he said in this video.
- 8,725
Thanks very much! I just watched it myself and realised that I noticed the mention of sound when it first appeared in the TGS thread, here.
Oh well, my memory fails me once again!
As usual, let's not get our hopes up then. 👍
- 35,594
- Addison,Texas
- GTP_RACECAR
Can someone explain to me why so many people expect a fictional tuned version of a car to sound like the real one it is clearly not based on? Honestly, I don't find it terrible and really, I don't expect or demand any LM Edition or Stealth cars fictionally done by PD to sound "realistic".
If they don't fix the sound's in this game, which is looks like they havent it will be such a dissapointment.
I've read through several pages and people are trying their best to hear simalarties in the engine sounds but this is crap.
They aren't even close. We've all resourted to other titles while waiting for GT5 and the sounds from Forza and even garbage games like NFS shift, still nailed it with the Sounds compaird to this.
GT5's graphics and gameplay look to be "next level" and the sounds arent' event on par with current / previous games. I shure hope we are all in for a big susprise, but I doubt it.
Sucks 👎
I've read through several pages and people are trying their best to hear simalarties in the engine sounds but this is crap.
They aren't even close. We've all resourted to other titles while waiting for GT5 and the sounds from Forza and even garbage games like NFS shift, still nailed it with the Sounds compaird to this.
GT5's graphics and gameplay look to be "next level" and the sounds arent' event on par with current / previous games. I shure hope we are all in for a big susprise, but I doubt it.
Sucks 👎
- 92
i need to hear the road version. hopefully it's not nearly as bad as the one in the video 
- 1,258
- NY, NY
- GTP_shawtyoner
- shawtyoner
What's really missing is that raspy sound from the exhaust on the exterior replay angles, that has always been the biggest let down in terms of sound IMO.
- 35,594
- Addison,Texas
- GTP_RACECAR
Because!! It's supposed to have a V12 in it, tuned or not. Unless the F1 stealth car is secretly powered by a hive of angry bees.
Where is a spec sheet that says its supposed has a V12 in it? I sure haven't seen it (probably why they are called "Stealth" cars) and funny enough, There are race cars in real life that don't share the same engine as there road-going counter parts (Nissan GT-R Ring a bell?). Again, its fictional just like the Ford GT LM, the Mercedes SLS Stealth car and pretty much every "LM Edition" That has been in GT throughout the years and as you say, its a placeholder so honestly I don't find it worth worrying about
- 244
People only need look a page or two back, there's a video of a stock F1 doing 200mph+ runs.
You'll notice the cars engine sound is drowned out by tyre noise and is barely audible even when pulling away from the pits.
Elsewhere there are numerous videos of the stock F1 in GT5 and as already stated it sounds realisitc.
You'll notice the cars engine sound is drowned out by tyre noise and is barely audible even when pulling away from the pits.
Elsewhere there are numerous videos of the stock F1 in GT5 and as already stated it sounds realisitc.
- 681
- cjrciadt
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNSeZU2MymI&feature=player_embedded#! hopefully we will hear these notes behind of the wheel of this ride 
👍
👍
- 177
- Rodpunisher
- Rod punisher
Have you guys heard the SLS sound from the latest GT5 video from Gametrailers??
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/nycc-10-gran-turismo/706012
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/nycc-10-gran-turismo/706012
- 128
- GTP_Keisu
Nice find! Haven't seen that video yet. That SLS has a nice grunt to it.
- 2,112
- xNEVER-ONEx
- 5,704
- Edison NJ
- jdmking13
- Lucid killer 58
That GameTrailers SLS vid sounds different to what we've heard in the Best Buy demo interior sound. It doesn't appear to have the drastic change going from cockpit to chase cam.
It definitely sounds like an SLS, even a bit like the GT3 SLS vid above
Sure does, listen to mine sounds way better than Game Stop demo version. 👍
[YOUTUBEHD]aVpwrdE8GqA[/YOUTUBEHD]
- 4,878
- CoolColJ, GTP_CoolColJ
How about a Jaguar XJ13 race car on Le Mans?
Jaggy shadows but the trees look different
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/nycc-10-gran-turismo/706014
There is a series of clacks at the end, sounds like either a backfire or the gearbox
Jaggy shadows but the trees look different
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/nycc-10-gran-turismo/706014
There is a series of clacks at the end, sounds like either a backfire or the gearbox
Last edited:
- 1,409
- mileret
I can clearly hear that it consists of just three samples again, sounds slowened in low rpms and like V6 in highest rpms, obviously without any balls again. Highly revved engine under stress should have some balls.
Please, listen to that "whisper quiet" and you have to admit that it's not true. Whenever you touch throttle, the sound is growing right into your bones in the car. But with all that power, the guy is very careful of course.
That tuned McLaren in GameStop video is good just for laugh. Weak, inadequate, taken (probably) from Zonda R and with no real basic in BMW V12 engine used in McLaren F1 at all. It just sounds different, due to constructional differences to AMG V12 engine derived from CLK GTR used in Zonda R.
Last edited:
- 1,409
- mileret
Obviously better sample recording and different rpm blending points have produced much better results than those PD's attempts. If they used five or six well recorded samples per range and variations for throttle positions (cruising / engine braking) we could finally hear engine sounds on par with that wonderful graphics and physics. Wonderful V8 rumbles in 1200 while feathering throttle, massively screaming V12s or roar and sputter of fivecyllinder in Group B Audi S1, not this despair...
- 8,725
That video is mostly intake, whilst the game doesn't do intake (and never has, for whatever reason) and the majority of the difference in the AMG and BMW units is, funnily enough, the intake - which you can hear through the exhaust on the overrun on the real cars. BMWs always have prominent intake noises, but the McF1 does have a comparatively subdued exhaust note. With a bit of careful attention, you can make the exhaust note of any V12 sound like another, assuming they have similar cam timings etc.
By the way, you don't record samples, you extract samples from recordings, and make them loop - subtle / nit-picky / whatever, but it really is an important distinction. It's really quite an involved process, so PD's recordings are probably no worse than anyone else's, it's what they do with those recordings that is different.
The SLS sounds OK in that GameTrailers vid, I'd probably be satisfied with that, but the Jag still sounds a bit contrived.
- 812
Holy Messerschmitt Batman!
👍
👍
- 8,725
I listened to that video three times and have come to the conclusion that it sounds a lot like a 90° V-Twin. Some very strange breathing apparatus on that car, then...
- 812
Similar threads
- Locked
