GT5 Sound Thread

  • Thread starter Marry_Me_GT
  • 5,638 comments
  • 550,031 views
Anyone besides me think the Citroen sounds more like a V10 then a V8?
 
I don't think the Citroen GT in GT5 is the same as the one Citroen decided to build in real life. ie this one has 7 gears
 
I don't think the Citroen GT in GT5 is the same as the one Citroen decided to build in real life. ie this one has 7 gears

The one built in real life is a rolling concept that just happens to have an engine but couldn't really be pushed while this in game one is more like what a mass produced, full-fledged road car would be like.
 
Sounds like it's running the Gallardo/R8 engine :)

Thats exactly what I first thought. Maybe it is a V8 but just revs differently, like how the V8 in the Ferrari F430 Scuderia revs completely different from say, the Corvette ZR-1.
 
In some points in those rally and that Citroen GT, you cannot see anything, there is just so much stuff flying up at your screen, it literally forces you to play in 3rd person view.. is it that bad for real?
 
In some points in those rally and that Citroen GT, you cannot see anything, there is just so much stuff flying up at your screen, it literally forces you to play in 3rd person view.. is it that bad for real?

Bad video quality makes it much worse than it really is, but it's probably still very hard to see much, but I think that's very realistic. You really don't want to be right behind someone else in Rain/Snow. Same thing happens in F1 2010 if you have played that.
 
In some points in those rally and that Citroen GT, you cannot see anything, there is just so much stuff flying up at your screen, it literally forces you to play in 3rd person view.. is it that bad for real?
Doubtful. It's being recorded off-screen, so we're missing most of the dynamic range of the image. No shadow detail, blown-out whites, etc. I'm sure the snow is somewhat obtrusive, but probably nowhere near as bad as it seems.

Back on topic, though, I'm very impressed with what I'm hearing in these videos so far. Can't wait to see/hear some direct-feed footage.
 
Thats exactly what I first thought. Maybe it is a V8 but just revs differently, like how the V8 in the Ferrari F430 Scuderia revs completely different from say, the Corvette ZR-1.

It's supposed to be a Ford V8 in the Gt by Citroen, the sounds are much nicer than previous GTs, the gear changes, the engine stutters over bumpy roads, in the Yellow Gallardo MOnza video, after the first spin, the car takes off from low rev, it sounds like satan for a second, wish he woulda held on..
 
It's supposed to be a Ford V8 in the Gt by Citroen, the sounds are much nicer than previous GTs, the gear changes, the engine stutters over bumpy roads, in the Yellow Gallardo MOnza video, after the first spin, the car takes off from low rev, it sounds like satan for a second, wish he woulda held on..

The car Citroen made is not the same as the one GT, it doesn't have 7 gears that's for sure :)

And one the in GT5 revs pretty high, red lines at 8000rpm, and the rev counter goes all the way to 12k
 
the sound of the citroen by GT is very very ipressive, I would even say it is scary driving this car at night+ rain (the video provided by tekken90)

In the cramped cocpit with water spraying to your windshield, the headlights illuminating the mist and barely seeing the road you can bet your *** it's scary ;)
 
Yesterday i told tekken90 to record F430 so we should have another out of the way

EDIT: oh and i don´t know how about you guys but that R8 still sounds horrible to me
 
Last edited:
The upshifts don't sound right at all in that snowy wrc video, they are very flat sounding. The downshifts sound spot on, though.

That's what annoys me the most! Was really happy about the engine sounds not sounding like vacuum cleaners at first but now this.. Almost 6 years in production but they can't even manage (or don't care) to make right something not so complex as upshift sounds? It's so demotivating.
 
It's supposed to be a Ford V8 in the Gt by Citroen.

But that same one with the Ford modular V8 was the rolling concept, which seemingly never upshifted past 2nd gear whereas the one in the game is again, based on a mass produced Road car.
 
When the Citroen enters the tunnel and reaches top speed,

its looks like a spaceship entering warp speed.. :drool:

I didn't realize how long the straights were on SSR7 until watching that video....my god am I going to have some fun ripping out top speeds with some amazing cars in this game...especially if they sound great.
 
That is becuase of the different firing order:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firing_order#Ignition

That but most of all how the crankshaft differs in the two engine designs.

In a Ferrari the crank is basically a 4 cylinder crank where two connecting rods sprout from each lobe.
In a Chevrolet smallblock the crank has a lobe for each individual connecting rod.

By using the doubled 4 cylinder crank the Ferrari V8 revs smoothly like a 4cyl would, by having an individual space for each connecting rod a Chevy sounds lumpy and uneven when each cylinder fires.
 
That but most of all how the crankshaft differs in the two engine designs.

In a Ferrari the crank is basically a 4 cylinder crank where two connecting rods sprout from each lobe.
In a Chevrolet smallblock the crank has a lobe for each individual connecting rod.

By using the doubled 4 cylinder crank the Ferrari V8 revs smoothly like a 4cyl would, by having an individual space for each connecting rod a Chevy sounds lumpy and uneven when each cylinder fires.

They're both even-firing engines. The difference with the cross-plane crank is that each bank of four cylinders is uneven firing, just like the 2009+ Yamaha R1. I.e. the order of firing, in terms of cylinder banks is, for example: L, R, L, R, R, L, R, L
This was actually perceived to be a drawback to the design, but most people love the resulting sound. :dopey:
The flat plane has an ignition event following in the opposite bank every time (i.e. L, R, L, R, L, R, L, R), so does tend to sound like two synchronised / interlaced fours.
The intake sound of a flat-plane V8 is unique, and not really comparable to the ordinary straight four, and is only superficially tonally similar to the cross-plane V8.

As for smoothness, the cross-plane wins hands-down, whilst the flat plane has a tendency to vibrate (assuming both engines are using a fully counter-balanced crankshaft, which isn't a guarantee on old cross-plane V8s...). That's why Yamaha went with the cross-plane in their MotoGP bike, as per the video I linked above. :)
The effect is less severe with the flat-plane V8, owing to the V-angle, but is still noticeable as a vibration.


I notice the NASCAR cars sound as they did at GamesCom, and it's a shame that R8 vid is such a mess. Still, keep 'em coming! :D
 
Back