The problem humans have with sound is two fold:
1 humans have a limited hearing range and like our sight, smell, taste and touch it has the ability to fade over time or with damage done to the specific body part.
2 training, if you train yourself to hear specific things you are able to, this conditioning of specific frequencies is done over time and repeated listening sessions and a lot of the time you don't even know it.
I love music and to be truthful I don't mind how I listen to music. But I do prefer a HD FLAC/WAV or Bluray/DVD audio file over anything else, this is simply because my audio set up allows for this digital signal to be uninterrupted until it hits the DAC whic then is put through the Amp and out of the speakers. This keeps the audio clean, precise and clear.
The problem with that is then how the music was recorded, if I play a poor recording it shows out like nothing before and that's because a CD player with DAC then through phono cables masks the poor quality. If I play a really stunning HD file like Daft Punk RAM (known throughout the industry as one the best recorded record today) then it's such a smooth and beautiful sound it just blows me away each time I play it.
Vinyl can't reproduce all the frequency range of human hearing, but it does have a distinctive sound and I can confirm, playing Daft Punk RAM on vinyl really doesn't take much away from the studio master files when played on a good system. I know this because I own both versions of the album and played them on one system with same amp, speakers and cables. As for the CD version? It's not bad, just not as good as the others, but this is all subjective and what sounds good to me maybe horrid to you.
On the flip side, Power Gloves - Blood Dragon OST sounds too clinical on Studio FLAC but positively beautiful on Vinyl.
I would never discount a format or judge anyone for preferring a specific way of listening to their music unless they were going to damage their hearing (I'm looking at you white iPod earphones).