- 11,660
- GTP_Orido
"Entry was refused due to network incompatibility with the room owner [768]"
Damn ...
"Entry was refused due to network incompatibility with the room owner [768]"
A good way to see if high BB is used when driving without ABS is by looking at the red brake bar during replay, with high BB like mine, when I brake deep and hard, I never have more than 70% red brake bar filled and yet I can still out brake most ABS driver. Low BB will most likely fill 100%, more so with ABS driver.
Nobody is joining my track day room ...
The problem with running high brake balances is that you lose the element of control and finesse in turns that require trailbraking.![]()
I agree to that for most steering wheel users, as the brake pedal are often have hideous sense of control and feedback. While in my case, I don't have such issue, I am using stick and it works very well for me. You can see that by watching a youtube video I posted several pages back in this thread.
It's a shame really that no ABS with steering wheel demands a pedal that rarely perform as it should without modification or expensive specialized pedal system.
The low BB number does have major disadvantages when not using ABS, longer brake distance, less brake bite in exchange for better control and precision for steering wheel users.
I made comparison long ago, BB value can be used to simulate the strength of old cars braking system, most of my vintage cars have low BB to replicate the old drum brakes, 2/0, 3/0 or 4/1 are common. Sadly this means that steering wheels users that have low BB when driving without ABS would be having the brake strength that is less than optimal, as less than 6 total value of BB means braking strength / bite will be severely reduced.
The problem with running high brake balances is that you lose the element of control and finesse in turns that require trailbraking.![]()
My DFGT pedal, although a bit lifeless, is fine for no ABS, you just have to learn to use your ears to listen to when the tyres are close to lock up and your hands to feel it. In fact I think that the brake pedal is easily a match for a stick.
BB values like 4/1 are not "low", you can easily lock up the brakes in heavy braking zones. The tenths/hundredths that you gain in heavy braking will be lost in the more complex corners because you simply don't have the same amount of brake travel with higher brake balances. 👍
Hmmmmm I'll try to share my experience and answer some of the questions since I'm used to a wheel more.
Well everytime I use a really high BB setting like 6/2 on a stock Ferrari F430 on Sports Hard for example I'm only allowed to press the brake pedal to about 30-40% before lock up; trail braking is impossible to do as well. That's why I mainly use 4/1, 3/1, 3/0, 2/1 for stock street cars like these. But then again going back to the same 6/2 BB value on a race car like GT500 Xanavi Nismo Z on Racing Hard tires is more practical and I can brake again up till 80-90% before lock up which is a realistic threshold for me. This for wheel users out there I don't know correct me if what I said is wrong
Mmm, 4/1 is low if compared to the performance gained while using 9/6 BB, it made a world of difference to me, I can scrub off speed a lot faster and in shorter distance - comparable to ABS with high BB. This is very noticeable when driving a heavy car and low grip tires - sports hard or lower.
A good measure stick is the 1st chicane at Monza. During the last Italian Cars Monza TT seasonal, I was using 458 Italia, 550pp, SH tires, 10/6 BB. My brake point with the 10/6 BB is just right at 200M mark, I usually traveled at 171 mph, and enter the chicane at less than 50 mph. With lower BB, I would have to brake earlier.
If you are using 4/1 or 5/2, try to take any car at Monza, reduce the BB to 2/1 or 1/0, and notice the longer brake distance and less bite at high speed - even at the same brake force applied ( red bar on HUD )
Now, you said that with 4/1 you can still lock the wheels, I am curious how much of the red brake bar on the HUD is filled when this happens ? With stick, 4/1 BB, usually I need to fill at least 75% to 80% to lock up the wheels.
I have been hearing how hard to prevent lock up when using pedals, so I wonder if GT5 have different way to manage the input value when not using stick. For reference, 10/6 BB on 430 Scuderia in stock condition, online and CM tires, I can have the red brake bar HUD filled to 55% at most condition ( straight line braking and high speed ) before the wheels lock up, when trail braking, 25% is enough to upset car balance and eventually locking up when inside a corner.
Personally I think that high brake balances aren't as fast, you are only gaining time in the split second it takes for the person with low BB to reach threshold, beyond that the person with low BB has more control to modulate the brake pressure and gains the advantage.
At Monza's first chicane with 4-2 (my default) I can hold 100% pressure for less than half a second before I have to ease the brake out, however in other slower corners I barely use 60%. Lock up can occur anywhere in the brake travel depending on my speed, at full speed I need 100% to lock but as I slow, If I don't feed the brake out properly, I can lock anywhere down to about 30-40%. 👍
I'd have also have said that braking with no ABS is actually easier with the pedals than stick. With the pedals you can modulate the brake much more effectively.![]()
Threshold and trail braking are what you said here, I always do them when braking, apply high pressure when in high speed, modulate accordingly as I get a lot slower and trail brake into the corner. High BB offer a lot less room to play before lock up set in.
I don't want to sound bad or anything, but with DS2 stick I have, I can modulate from 10% to 100% brake pressure without any slight of issue and can still compete with steering wheel users who uses ABS. Have you watched my video several pages back ? You'll get the idea, it was at Monza, 458 Italia, CM tires and rain.
That is exactly what I'm talking about. You simply do not have the same level of control with higher brake levels, you've said before you get to 70% (?) pressure and lock up, therefore you are robbing yourself of an extra 30% of brake travel that would be extremely useful.
And yes I did see the video.
I understand that you obviously prefer to play this way and I'm not trying to change that.![]()
That is pedal travel, correct ? How about the percentage the red brake bar on the HUD ? How much is it filled until lock ups often happen ? It should be around 60 - 70 % during straight line braking with 6/2 BB F430 on SH. The red brake bar in the HUD is my reference as I can't measure button travel on stick controller![]()
Sorry yes I was trying to compare how 6/2 BB would be more suitable for race cars than it is for normal cars. Referring back to the stock Ferrari F430 if I brake to 60-70% red bar when using BB settings in the range of 6/2 or higher (6/2, 6/3, 7/2, 7/3 are the values I normally use on race cars), my tire hud indicator turns completely red within 1~2 second and I must ease off the brakes again. But with a BB of 3/1 on the stock F430 I'm able to keep the tire indicator light pink where I want it to be at 80-90% threshold
But yeah shoutout to that vid of yours I still think it's one of the best ABS OFF vids I've ever seen out there. Hopefully one day I'll be able to drive like you and master the art of high BB!
That would be about the same with stick then, the only hurdle with pedals is the common lack of feel and resistance like a real life car pedalIf only PD did special routine for input adjustments on the pedal to compensate for the lack of feel and resistance, we could have larger base of no ABS drivers.
By the way thanks for the compliment of the videoit was a long journey to get used to no ABS driving, I learned it from the 1st release day of GT5, and until now I am still learning and practicing, as I consider myself still just an ordinary driver
If only I have capture card, I could upload many of my no ABS run with various cars using comfort tires ... it would be great for luring ABS drivers to let go![]()
Yes I agree! Haha you dont happen to have that vid of the ABS-off race we had a while back with Morgoth do you? I remember it was a real close one we all finished within 2 seconds of each other. Im looking for it right now but I can only find the other one we had which wasnt very good, some guy crashed into the back of one of us at the start and ruined it hah. I think I lost it but nvm if you cant find it. I did really bad in it anyway haha I remember I was experimenting with high BB settings that day
You should consider a wheel sometime soon! Im sure you will like it! If you already have no problem driving with a stick you definitely wont have any problems driving with a wheel either. Im thinking about selling my G25 soon. Ill make sure to put you as my top priority if I come to it!
Sadly this means that steering wheels users that have low BB when driving without ABS would be having the brake strength that is less than optimal, as less than 6 total value of BB means braking strength / bite will be severely reduced.
I don't understand your logic in this statement and as a wheel user I can tell you it is not accurate.
Nothing is preventing a pedal user to apply the same force to the brake as a controler user.
Beeing involve as you are in the finesse of GT5, I suggest that investing in a DFGT will be money weel spent in your case, they are ways to have the wheel out of site for the girl friend to be happy and for the simulation to be more rewarding.
You are right, nothing is preventing a pedal user to apply the same force to the brake as a controller user. The way the pedal interact with the user ( lack of feel and feedback ) is what hinders most wheel users to have high BB, which I have tested to have shorter stopping distance due to more force applied.
I did thorough tests a while ago, using ABS:1 to remove inconsistency. BB 0/0, 5/5, 10/10 full brake force applied until full stop, all reflect the stopping distance lessening with higher total values of BB. I did it at SSRX with Corvette and SH tires.
And to top that, my experience when I used low BB number when driving without ABS, I have a hard time out braking ABS drivers who have usual BB like 5/3 or 7/5. I did also raced with no ABS drivers who uses low BB 3/0, 4/1, still struggling with similar low BB, then I increase the BB to 8/4 then 9/5, only then I begin to able consistently brake as deep and late as most ABS drivers, and often out brake them mostly during shuffle races.
The last time I have a wheel for console was when I played GT3 on PS2, I had the cheap Madcatz wheels if not mistaken, it was very basic and broke within 6 months![]()
You are right, nothing is preventing a pedal user to apply the same force to the brake as a controller user. The way the pedal interact with the user ( lack of feel and feedback ) is what hinders most wheel users to have high BB, which I have tested to have shorter stopping distance due to more force applied.
I have to say, I'm still confused as to how a DS2 controller has more "feel" through the stick than the pedals of a DFGT do.![]()
I guess it is the same principal as playing guitar, much easier to play with the fingers than the foot.
Joke aside, with enough dexterity, you will know exactly where that DS2 lever is at so with enough talent you can have more accuracy than a foot on a potentiometer brake pedal, I am talking hypothetically, as I am using a foot to brake and I know I do not have the dexterity to control the brakes with such precision with my finger.![]()
But I'd have said that the analog sticks on the DS controller are awkwardly placed for precision.
And if using hand controls in cars was more effective than pedals (IRL), pedals wouldn't exist.![]()
I have to say, I'm still confused as to how a DS2 controller has more "feel" through the stick than the pedals of a DFGT do.![]()
Eric1512I think I will start to learn how to not use ABS. Any tips?
But yeah shoutout to that vid of yours I still think it's one of the best ABS OFF vids I've ever seen out there. Hopefully one day I'll be able to drive like you and master the art of high BB!