- 87,639
- Rule 12
- GTP_Famine
Sometimes I wonder if it shouldn't...
It used to be, and there are plenty of posts deleted even today which have "Off Topic" tags.
The thing is that discussions, like language, are organic. They grow and spread in wholly unexpected ways - like any discussion about GT5 will usually include FM3 and vice versa. Unproductive branches tend to wither and die all by themselves while productive ones will grow onwards and upwards. If no-one is being told to fudge themselves or foxtrot off, there's little merit in clipping the wings of a topic people clearly want to discuss.
If everything in this forum was required, rigidly, to talk about nothing but GT5, it'd be a lot smaller. And calmer, I grant you.
However, I will add a caveat below:
PS if being off topic is not againts the AUP, then what rules are we breaking and what power do you have to keep a thread on track! (I think I have found a loophole here haha)
We have a catchall:
You will, if asked by a representative of the forums, cease posting any content.
Basically, if we think a discussion topic is going to be unproductive, we can nip it in the bud with a short "Back on topic, please" note. Not because the topic is the only thing permitted to be discussed, but because it reminds everyone that we're here for pretty much the same thing - because the thread title was interesting enough to draw us in to discuss the topic of the thread.
It's a fun old life, being a moderator. There's fine lines everywhere you look.
Just think though, in 31 days, there'll be a huge influx in this forum of people asking for prize car lists and wondering why they can't do "x" event. And you'll all look back on this and laugh. Meanwhile, my computer will be off.