Never done this before and since I've been in a DVD watching mood recently... well, here we go:
The Golden Compass - 2 Disc Edition
Dakota Blue Richards as Lyra
Nicole Kidman as Mrs. Coulter
Daniel Craig as Lord Asriel
I'm a sucker for 2 disc editions, so let's set aside the film for a mo. The extras disc is filled full of that guff which us closet film industry fans love. You get Mister Pullman and the surprisingly disarming Miss Dakota Blue Richards having their say, and both acquit themselves well on the small screen, with good insights and heartfelt emotion in their explanations and anecdotes. There's the obligatory "aren't visual affects cool" doc, which in this case is well warranted...
... because the film's effects are fabulous. See past the first thing you see, the not quite perfect walk of Stelmaria - Lord Asriel's snow leopard 'dæmon' - and soon you're rewarded with a polecat poking its tongue out at you in fullscreen amazingness. After this point, you simply forget the effects and gain the filmmakers Holy Grail - suspension of disbelief. They're dæmons, the soul made real, dancing around the screen as (of course) dæmons are wont to do.
Of course, this lets one concentrate on the plot - and you'll need all the help you can get. If you've read the book, then you'll be following along fairly happily, and it will take you twenty minutes to discover what everyone else figured out quicker - this movie shovels along at a heck of a pace. It reminds me of the last three Harry Potter movies. There's so much stuff to cram in, it's like a fairground ride - it just doesn't let up. After watching the film twice, I realised that it is only just over 100 minutes long. I think rounding it up to two hours (or a little more) and letting the film breathe a little would have given it a bit more dramatic tension at the beginning, to let the viewer get a little more deeply drawn in before the real thrill ride gets going; when Lyra joins the gypsy-like Gentian people.
Kidman is very good as the nasty piece of work that is Mrs Coulter. Between her and her Golden Monkey dæmon, you really see conniving, manipulative and just enough vicious to raise your hackles when she appears. Miss Richards is fine as Lyra; although some of the childrens' dialog scenes are a touch painful, when she is with more experiences actors onscreen it rubs off on her. I'd put her one up on Emma Watson, but one down on Daniel Radcliffe for their first bigscreen efforts. Craig is onscreen for too short a time, which is a bit of a shame. He is a good choice for Asriel, although some fans of the book confessed they thought he played it a bit too warm and wimpy. Lord Asriel of the book was, well, a complete double hard bastard. Perhaps Craig has got his Bond and Asriel mixed up?
There is one weak spot - music. Music is incredibly important to a film like this, and you need a strong melodic theme to go with the orchestrations and action. If you can't remember the theme when you leave, you won't remember the film as fondly. In some ways this film is better than the Potter films - but the lack of a really heart pounding theme means you won't spot it immediately.
I noticed the director chose to cut off the end of the book. This could be an error in judgment, it's going to be hard to start the next film the way the book suggests, but I'm sure they'll figure it out.
7/10 - and definitely worth getting the 2-disc, if you like watching that kind of shtuff.
(... and for reference, HP1 = 6.5/10, HP2 = 6.5/10, HP3 = 8/10, HP4 = 7.5/10, HP5 = 7.5/10 from me.)
Sorry, haven't seen the Narnia film, so no comparison there.
If you liked this... then I'll spout some drivel for Run, Fat Boy, Run sometime soon.
Oh, why wait. Run, Fat Boy, Run with Simon Pegg and Thandie Newton - Shaun of the Dead without the zombies or really funny dialog, and with an added annoying American. And IMO, a badly miscast Thandie Newton - who I always remember fondly as Dame Vaaco from The Ridicules of Chroni... Chronicles of Riddick.
5/10
Further proof that average American TV actors can't direct movies... although it might have been a bit more watchable if it was an all American cast.
If you want a funny Pegg movie, watch Hot Fuzz.
Three times.
(No, not one or two or four, but three.)