2024 Formula 1 Constructors threadFormula 1 

  • Thread starter Jimlaad43
  • 844 comments
  • 92,313 views
Season 3 Entrance GIF by The Simpsons
 
Don’t know what all the fuss was about, they just spent a bit much on lunches. Not surprising, have you seen how much a meal deal is now ?!
 
FIA - no fraud, no loss, nothing to see here

"There is no accusation or evidence that RBR has sought at any time to act in bad faith, dishonestly or in a fraudulent manner, nor has it wilfully concealed any information from the Cost Cap Administration"

RBR need better/more creative accountants and payroll department

 
They're not going to care about the fine but 10% reduction interesting.
You can't unlearn what you've already learnt though, and RB already have these regs down. Can't see that changing with the reduction, even on top of the reduction they already get as WCC.
 
I read somewhere the winning team gets reduced wind time compared to others, so maybe the extra 10% will hurt that. But, that car is already on a solid foundation for next season. :/
 
I read somewhere the winning team gets reduced wind time compared to others, so maybe the extra 10% will hurt that. But, that car is already on a solid foundation for next season. :/

Correct, they'll have quite a bit less time than those around them. While they may have nailed the rules, it does give other teams who see quite close to them now, a good opportunity to eliminate the gap.
 
Just out of curiosity, unless it is accounted differently in the team ledger, when they pay that $7mil fine, wouldn't that affect this year's (2022) cost cap? 🤔
 
You can't unlearn what you've already learnt though, and RB already have these regs down. Can't see that changing with the reduction, even on top of the reduction they already get as WCC.
Well said, it will be interesting to see if the lack of wind time effects them next year if at all but this looks like barely a slap on the wrist from the FIA.
I read somewhere the winning team gets reduced wind time compared to others, so maybe the extra 10% will hurt that. But, that car is already on a solid foundation for next season. :/
Yeah they're down to 63% from 70 after being WCC.
 
Just out of curiosity, unless it is accounted differently in the team ledger, when they pay that $7mil fine, wouldn't that affect this year's (2022) cost cap? 🤔
No, fines are specifically mentioned ad outside the cost cap.

Also, I know it's been mentioned somewhere, but for those saying this punishment is lenient or doesn't go far enough, kist remember this.


Now, yes, a breach is a breach, bit considering people were assuming a £4m+ breach and how much they could have gained in performance, this is definitely not to that level. Could they have gained performance from £400k, maybe, is that what happened? No.


That article covers what the exact breach points are. I don't see anything that could enhance car performance.

Effectively, a 7m fine for 400k overspend and they'll be sacking their accountant.
 
If my estimations are correct, Red Bull will earn more in additional 2022 prize money for the constructors title than the fine will cost it...
 
Might as well cheat next year again, tank those sanctions.
Cheat is quite a strong term to use when you read the breach list.

Let's face it, majority of 'fans' would only have been happy with points deductions, championship disqualifications and a rewrite of the 2021 final standings. Was never realistically on the cards.
 
Once again, a fine is nothing more than the retail price to break rules. If you can afford it, it's not a punishment.
It's still 14 times the amount of the real terms breach. The reduction in aero research will hurt them next season.
 
a rewrite of the 2021 final standings.
Nah, there's no way the FIA can overturn past results...


Anyone remember what happened to McLaren when it gained no advantage from a Ferrari engineer passing confidential data to a McLaren engineer?
 
Nah, there's no way the FIA can overturn past results...


Anyone remember what happened to McLaren when it gained no advantage from a Ferrari engineer passing confidential data to a McLaren engineer?
The illegal theft of documents which were brazenly copied in a shop and potentially directly led to technical directives based on knowledge no one should have had? What of it? That's not even in the same ballpark as a minor overspend and procedural error in the first year of a complex set of financial regulations.
 
The illegal theft of documents which were brazenly copied in a shop.....
You see, this is the bit that puzzles me about it all.

1, if you were a McLaren engineer, wouldn't you have the money (or the ability to claim on expenses) to buy a medium/large photocopier yourself for the amount it would cost to get it done in a shop?
2, If you were looking at technical diagrams which were being copied, how the hell could you know what was being copied? I could look at a diagram for an air inlet butterfly plenum and think it was a toaster, and I'd like to think I'm reasonably technically minded.
3, How the hell do you just phone up Ferrari F1 technical headquarters? Have they got the direct line on Scuderia Ferrari's website, or maybe the local Italian restaurant's owner would know?
 
When you look at McLaren's performance in 2008 it's clear that $100M fine had little to no effect on development, assuming they paid the fine at all...
 
When you look at McLaren's performance in 2008 it's clear that $100M fine had little to no effect on development, assuming they paid the fine at all...
I dunno, considering it was quite late 2007 when it was handed down and 2007 development would have been comfortably underway with eyes on the regulation changes in 2009 as well, their 2009 car certainly suffered in some way. Whether it could be attributed to how much the fine was is difficult to say but the timeline would be right for that impact.
 
I dunno, considering it was quite late 2007 when it was handed down and 2007 development would have been comfortably underway with eyes on the regulation changes in 2009 as well, their 2009 car certainly suffered in some way. Whether it could be attributed to how much the fine was is difficult to say but the timeline would be right for that impact.
Ferrari were equally abysmal in 2009 with no such fine, and then they were both frontrunners again in 2010.
 
Back