POLL: Do You Like The <1,000,000 Cr. Gift Restriction?

No, it's more like they make this machine like you say and then start giving everyone free meals right outside the restaurants front door!

How is GT5 analogous to a restaurant in the first place?

So dupers are killing GT5's profit margin? Not in the slightest.

Are dupers keeping people away from GT5? Not in the slightest.

Your analogy suggests that duping has some negative effect. What is this effect?
 
This sucks, LOL. I voted dislike because I'm an honest trader and car collector as well as a racer. :grumpy: :mad:

This limits a lot of things for us who also enjoy the car-collecting side of the game. I understand the obvious exploit of getting free cars and such, as I've done it before too (that's how I got both Ferrari F1s for free anway :) :guilty: ), and them (meaning PD) trying to address the issues, but sheesh! This was a bit too much. Trading was one of the very best features in this game. And I met a lot of good people through it too. Online, yes, was indeed cluttered with people who had X2010s and other insane cars that they didn't deserve and/or acquire legitimately, but that's what lobby restrictions are all about. Besides, a game that's sold this much, and has a fanbase this big, expect way more than a few idiots to ruin your day. Online can be like Call of Duty, except with cars.

I don't understand why they would limit the trade to cars that pretty much anyone can buy without much hassle or are affordable through an easy 20 or so minutes of racing Indy (you know, that Indy). I don't care about your Enzo or F1. Or your Focus RS, or your Volvo C30, when I can go make a quick buck (a really quick buck, I might add) and buy one myself from the new dealership. I'm more interested in your shiny red X2010, or your prestigious Chaparral 2J, because I'm not about to spend 5 years grinding just to get one car... only to end up broke from buying it, and having to do it again :yuck:

At least allow really high end cars (race cars, cars worth 7 figures and such) to be sold for something in return (like 1/3 or 1/4 of the original price before it was bought), instead of getting rid of it for nothing, or return the ability to win prize cars over and over again (this could help immensely). Or heeeeeyyyyy... how about even more races to do! (And NO, I'm not talking about the seasonals, they're great). I mean, expanding A-spec (or at least B-spec, for that matter) so that it's got depth like previous GTs, or more (now there's an afterthought 💡).

For those in favor of this patch, and against "cheaters" (or whatever it is you guys believe us to be), think about it for a minute. No one got hurt duping. And yeah, it was unfair, to see newbies with the entire Le Mans squad in their garage (so why not do the same, and join them? Trading is fun after all), but majority of us aren't hermits, and have far more important things to do. You guys also have to remember that this is just a game, and who cares what you do in it, or to it, so long as it doesn't affect others and ruin it for them (and it didn't, other than a few feelings of envy and/or jealousy, with a mix of disappointment and distaste). This in time will alienate HUGE amounts of people (unless... unless of course, it's fixed again, and then another round of complaining commences :rolleyes:). GT won't have that same online community feel to it that made it so very special in my tiny library of great PS3 games. :nervous: :ill: 👎 :indiff:


Just my 2 cents. :cheers:

The whiners have won. They whined and whined and whined about how I play my own game, which has no effect on them, and ISN'T ANY OF THEIR BUSINESS.

PD gave in to the whiners and now THEY have made MY game less fun.

I won't be buying any more expensive cars. I can't afford them. I don't have time to sit for hours running circles at indy just to "buy" a "car" with "money" I "earn".

Think for a second and you'll see why I put all those words in quotes.

I didn't "buy" anything because it's already on my disc. I just unlocked it.

I put "car" in quotes because there is no car. It's just a bunch of ones and zeros in a game.

I put "money" in quotes because there is no money. Same as above.

I put "earn" in quotes because there is no sense of accomplishment associated with grinding. It's tedium. If there were more than a dozen A-spec races, or if the races paid a decent amount of "money" then I'd be happy to earn it.

The fact that PD decided to substantially sully the gaming (see the word GAME) experience of thousands of players based on the false pride of a few just disappoints.

"I have grinded Indy more times than you! I am AWESOME!!!" Think about it.
1. Who cares about the X1? It's retarded anyway. Let the people who want to race them online go ahead and race them. If you pull that car out in one my rooms, you get the boot, end of story.

2. These are virtual cars in a video game! They have no value, we all have them on the disc we paid $60 for.

3. Why do you want cars to be "rare"? Would you feel so special if you had a certain car and nobody else had it? IF that is the case, you really need to set some real goals in life and find a proper sense of achievement.

4. PD never said they wanted any car to be rare. The option to gift cars was included since day one. Therefore the X1, or any other "rare" car could have been passed around like a Taiwanese hooker eventually regardless.



3 great posts that I 100% agree with.

Those saying that duping affects you online. Well thats your fault then isn't it? You either don't go into the rooms that are full of idiots in their X2010's or you set restrictions on your own room. It's simple really.

Also, the X2010 is a bag of crap anyway. Its a stupid, pointless, completely unrealistic, absolutely ridiculous car. I have got one but only for B-Spec grinding cause it makes it so much quicker, I will never, ever drive it myself though.

I'll happily spend a couple of million on a car but anything over that then I'll back up my data and "buy" it for free as I simply cannot be bothered to waste my time grinding or redoing races that I've already done. The biggest money is the Dream Car Championship and to grind that enough times, in B-Spec using the X2010, to buy a 20,000,000 car, would take more than 20 goes, at around an hour and half a time thats somewhere around the 30 hour mark. More than a day of constant grinding just to buy one car, after which you'll be back at zero credits and you've got to do more monotonous grinding if you want to buy another car.

Duping hurts absolutely no-one. I've legitimately gone through the game to a point where there isn't much more that I can do (or want to do) so what is wrong with me doing the occasional back-up to get a car for free instead of throwing all my credits down the drain that I've wasted hour after hour after hour grinding to get?

This.
The pro-1.07 people need to read this, and get their act straight.
 
RedBullRacer
No, it's more like they make this machine like you say and then start giving everyone free meals right outside the restaurants front door!
No, they're giving it to people that already paid and are inside the restaurant.
 
You'd think with all PD could ADD to the game... more events to race, save feature for enduros, ff and rewind for replays, leaderboards, etc. they would focus more on adding content and fixing problems than stripping away features that, according to the above poll anyway, more than half the playing public enjoyed! Brilliantly ignorant move PD, keep that head in the sand!
 
People will like this because of the X1 duping and trading. I think you shouldn't be able to trade the X1, but every other car should be tradable.

I voted against. I just want to enjoy the game, can I ? I'm 32 and I'm feeling like a little kid with all of the restrictions. Let's all jump to NFS Shift 2.
 
How is GT5 analogous to a restaurant in the first place?

So dupers are killing GT5's profit margin? Not in the slightest.

Are dupers keeping people away from GT5? Not in the slightest.

Your analogy suggests that duping has some negative effect. What is this effect?

You will find that they won't tell you the negative effect, because there isn't one, outside of a couple egos with boo-boos.

The negative effect is that I have a life and fear for my ancient Playstation's, so it was much easier for me to do this than leave my PS3 running for days while I'm not even playing it. (What's the point of a game if I'm not even there playing it?)
 
It's stupid.

I hope all the condescending elitist crybaby ****ers are happy that they got their way. I'm still amazed that so many people cared so much. In the old days, anybody could buy a Gameshark and have 999,999,999,999,999 credits if they wanted to, and it had no effect how you, me or anyone else played their game. There's no difference between duping and sharking.

Oh, and FYI for all the complainers, it requires the exact same amount of skill to duplicate a car as it does to run 5 laps around Indianapolis; i.e. zero. Maybe if there was a more enjoyable way to earn money this wouldn't be such a big deal.

Another FYI, I'll qualify my statements by saying that I've duped two cars in my life: a Sauber C9 and an FGT in the color I wanted (I already had purchased one). Everything else I've earned. I could care less about having 50 X1's to trade for more cars. I want to be able to play GT5 to enjoy the cars I want to without having to drive around in a circle for 20 hours.
 
I personally don't care. Especially since I dupe cars that cost less than Cr.1,000,000 anyway. :P
 
Hopefully GT6 won't be as flawed. So that:

a) Duplicating will not be possible, possibly by means of online backups of saves that syncs with your ps3, with no option to back up your save manually like you can in GT5

b) Rewards for races later in the game become greater so they can refund the money paid for the car quickly*

c) The presence of a used car dealership will be combined with an extensive online marketplace, trading, selling, auctioning etc.**

d) The 20 million credit cap will be increased to a higher figure, it's just a number, increasing this figure to say 1,000,000,000 should be adequate to make sure if anybody reaches it, they will never need any more.***

*So I don't have to run the same event 5+ times simply to recoup the money I paid for the car I entered with - especially with racing cars (LMP, SuperGT, DTM etc.), as most of the teams who use these cars actually make a profit over a single season due to advertising revenue.

**So that rare cars actually have some value, and can still be obtained from other players online if they are not available in the UCD. Or remove the UCD altogether and have a GT3 style dealership (Every car listed as new in the dealerships).

***The most expensive car in GT4 was 4.5million credits right? I don't remember any cap on there... :rolleyes:

The current situation sucks, because of basic flaws in the game. This argument has gone on long enough and is pointless, because both sides are right and the game is broken.

/thread
 
How is GT5 analogous to a restaurant in the first place?

So dupers are killing GT5's profit margin? Not in the slightest.

Are dupers keeping people away from GT5? Not in the slightest.

Your analogy suggests that duping has some negative effect. What is this effect?


I've already said, I personally don't care as it doesn't effect me, but it's bad as it's just abusing the system, and PD didn't want it to be used this why. I'm just saying, I agree with the patch change :)
 
With GT4 I never felt like I had too many cars, or had too much money (I had all cars and basically infinite money) no one cared that I did it. I did it for myself, and I enjoyed the game so much longer. With that said, with GT4 used car dealers, it made the game FUN. I was always looking for sweet new cars and new deals, not passed it off because I know nothing good is in them. And the GT5 car count feels smaller. The standard cars are such a joke to the level of quality Premium cars are at.
 
Just take off copy protection, and make the gamesave indestructible ( ie. no corrupt data anymore) and the problem is solved! 💡
 
This update (1.07) does not bother me at all. I am almost 100% and I don't feel like I wasted my life doing it. I still have nice college grades and am involved in the community. I also still travel when I can. To be honest I thought about trading the $20,000,000 cars around. In the end I did not need to as I have earned pretty much all of them. I can see that some people want everything immediately and I can't bash them for that. I am happy with the game so far. So....

- Many people have already said this, yet PD needs if they can/want to;

* Special events more often-the ones that do payout a max of $1,000,000 (once a week and a couple more of them)
** Maybe a money/prize car lottery system.. aimed for dupers and not hoarders.. "hyper-active mans pick 5"
*** trade in system for the horns/paints/2nd Red Bull car (lvl. 35 gift) which is somewhat useless.
**** I don't think more prize cash payout is the answer (A/B-spec), but that is an option.
***** Allow rim changes on standard cars... a.k.a. distract the frustrated ones with more bling and something you should be doing anyways.

I have more thoughts but I would like this thread to be positive if possible.
 
Hopefully GT6 won't be as flawed. So that:

a) Duplicating will not be possible, possibly by means of online backups of saves that syncs with your ps3, with no option to back up your save manually like you can in GT5

b) Rewards for races later in the game become greater so they can refund the money paid for the car quickly*

c) The presence of a used car dealership will be combined with an extensive online marketplace, trading, selling, auctioning etc.**

d) The 20 million credit cap will be increased to a higher figure, it's just a number, increasing this figure to say 1,000,000,000 should be adequate to make sure if anybody reaches it, they will never need any more.***

*So I don't have to run the same event 5+ times simply to recoup the money I paid for the car I entered with - especially with racing cars (LMP, SuperGT, DTM etc.), as most of the teams who use these cars actually make a profit over a single season due to advertising revenue.

**So that rare cars actually have some value, and can still be obtained from other players online if they are not available in the UCD. Or remove the UCD altogether and have a GT3 style dealership (Every car listed as new in the dealerships).

***The most expensive car in GT4 was 4.5million credits right? I don't remember any cap on there... :rolleyes:

The current situation sucks, because of basic flaws in the game. This argument has gone on long enough and is pointless, because both sides are right and the game is broken.

/thread

That's what I have been thinking about for a while.
 
Your analogy suggests that duping has some negative effect. What is this effect?

Actually, I think the negative effect is more like being in a restaurant eating your main course, and a waiter comes over and asks if you want a drink. You really fancy some Champagne, but it's out of your price range. Suddenly, the bloke sitting at the table next to you opens a bag and offers you the same bottle of Champagne but for nothing. Before long, the whole Restaurant is drinking this Champagne and the restaurant hasn't made a single penny out of it. A week down the line, no one even cares about drinking the champagne no more, as everyones bored of it.

So the negative effect is, the champagne loses its value, and the restaurant goes out if business.
 
Go to your garage, when you view a car you're given the option to share it with friends. They can borrow it from your profile's page.
 
Actually, I think the negative effect is more like being in a restaurant eating your main course, and a waiter comes over and asks if you want a drink. You really fancy some Champagne, but it's out of your price range. Suddenly, the bloke sitting at the table next to you opens a bag and offers you the same bottle of Champagne but for nothing. Before long, the whole Restaurant is drinking this Champagne and the restaurant hasn't made a single penny out of it. A week down the line, no one even cares about drinking the champagne no more, as everyones bored of it.

So the negative effect is, the champagne loses its value, and the restaurant goes out if business.

Except that PD is selling Gran Turismo 5, not the cars in it individually. It's like if someone orders Chicken and Potatoes, you order Spaghetti, and they give you some of their potatoes or Chicken. Restaurant already made their profits on the two meals, why should they worry about what you share with a fellow paying customer?

The champagne analogy makes more sense when applied to Stealth/Chromline cars, for sure, hence why they aren't able to be traded ever. Those are the rare champagnes that some people paid extra for/went out of their way (I reserved my game from Gamestop at no extra charge and got some free cars. I'm the type who'd share my champagne because I appreciate how awesome it is and want others to as well. Alas, I am forbidden. Such is life.)
 
Actually, I think the negative effect is more like being in a restaurant eating your main course, and a waiter comes over and asks if you want a drink. You really fancy some Champagne, but it's out of your price range. Suddenly, the bloke sitting at the table next to you opens a bag and offers you the same bottle of Champagne but for nothing. Before long, the whole Restaurant is drinking this Champagne and the restaurant hasn't made a single penny out of it. A week down the line, no one even cares about drinking the champagne no more, as everyones bored of it.

So the negative effect is, the champagne loses its value, and the restaurant goes out if business.

Yes, I complete agree. In this case, the "restaurant" is the GTP Marketplace. Those who are offering rare cars for free will make those who want a proper trade seem meaningless. In fact, I think that Update 1.07 was only there to "save" the GTP'ers who want a legit trade.
 
What do you think about the fact that cars over 1,000,000 credits cannot be gifted?

EDIT #1: Guys, let's not try to get this thread closed. :)

EDIT #2: Please stay on topic.


I am buy no means a cheater or duper, but this restriction is absolutely ludicrous! PD please lift this restriction immediately!!!
 
lol, for the 24hrs than crybabies have spent in this forum crying, they had made a lot of money while racing in the game and buying/winning one of those expensive cars about they are bitching against PD
 
Except that PD is selling Gran Turismo 5, not the cars in it individually. It's like if someone orders Chicken and Potatoes, you order Spaghetti, and they give you some of their potatoes or Chicken. Restaurant already made their profits on the two meals, why should they worry about what you share with a fellow paying customer?

The champagne analogy makes more sense when applied to Stealth/Chromline cars, for sure, hence why they aren't able to be traded ever. Those are the rare champagnes that some people paid extra for/went out of their way (I reserved my game from Gamestop at no extra charge and got some free cars. I'm the type who'd share my champagne because I appreciate how awesome it is and want others to as well. Alas, I am forbidden. Such is life.)


And I agree with this analogy!
 
Back