I say we back off the religion debating. It started out as presidential talk, but drifted way off topic. Omnis said he may move it to a new thread, so I will wait for that, or maybe we should move over to some of the other already existing religion-based topics. I would think a Religion in Politics thread could be a neat discussion, but it won't stay there. But, I have found that religion devoted topics draw out the worst people on both sides of the issue and intelligent debate becomes hard without someone who is misinformed either way jumping in and getting close to making personal attacks. So, I don't know, but we should back off that one in here.
This is at least relative to politics.
[Bill Maher video]
Oddly, he describes Socialism as a a list of things government would do that it is not given permission to do via the Constitution. The scary part is that he and people who think like him, don't stop and ask if the government has that power, or why it was not granted that power.
All the things he listed should be state issues.
And that is the other thing. When people wish to adhere to the Constitution they do not necessarily mean it should never be allowed to happen anywhere. The education discussion on the federal level should be done when you mention its legality. On a state level is where the ideological debate should take place, assuming the state constitution of that state allows it.
Now, I know that it does seem as if the Constitutionalists wish to act as if the US Constitution counts for the local levels as well, but I feel the 10th Amendment explained that point.
10th Amendment
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
That seems clear to me that if it is not a listed power of the federal government it is a state power, unless noted. If it isn't already understood, this amendment makes it clear that this is a Constitution for federal government. States have their own Constitutions that cover the issues outside the ones listed on the federal level.
There are so many issues that fall into this category, yet they have entire departments devoted to them within the federal government. How much budget could be saved if we determined the existence of these departments by this rule?