Project CARS General Discussion Thread

  • Thread starter Terronium-12
  • 20,825 comments
  • 1,568,107 views
Not really. Capture being the key word, streaming another. Until someone gets the PS4 version in hand, runs it through a HDMi connection and then tells us what happens, the discussion is pointless.

Oh wait, Team VVV have done that and never mentioned ghosting. Whoops.

Actually I have mentioned it on multiple occasions, notable every time somebody blames my recording equipment and even on neogaf here http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=160620091&postcount=646

People have been so preoccupied with frame rate they've not really been listening.

As ever, YT videos give a good indication of what to expect, you've seen how it looks and plays, now there's enough information out there for consumers to make up their own mind whether they want to purchase the title, or not.
 
I've just been into game and the ghosting IS visible in game but really on,y noticeable when turning. On the straights it looks like motion blur, when turning both cars and track detail turn to mush!

I can't buy it like this and am now cancelling my digital ps4 order and grabbing the Xbox. Lesser fx but no mush!

I urge all of you to go see for yourself!
 
I've noticed it since the first(?) PS4 video was released to the public. Back then I wasn't sure if it was the game or artifacts from post-processing of the capture.
When it was in every single video, it became clear it's the game itself.

I watched the video again and it is crystal clear that the ghosting seen in stills instantly disappear when the video is set to motion again. The ghosting in stills will not be present when you pause the game on your TV or when using the photo mode.
 
This is the explanation that I'm going with. From what I've seen it is the truth.


Except Alan from VVV just posted he has noticed issues with the blur and linked to his post on NG.
I just played the game in GAME and can confirm its a mess when turning. On the straights it looks like motion blur, but when turning the screen becomes one big mush/smear.

The best way to demonstrate it is to go slow around a corner with cars in front of you (turn 1 of any race) and the screen becomes pixel soup! It's outrageous! How is this only now getting noticed.

There is another guy on his way to GAME in Edinburgh, so let's see what he says too. But Alan, Myself and no doubt a few others will confirm that the blur is an issue!

This might explain Ian bells remarks staring that he preferred the Xbox version!
 
I still don't get it. I've watched VVV 's videos lots of times and I never notice this ghostin. I watch these vidoes as I intend to play them racing. Eyes fixed on the road/cars ahead and I don't notice it at all.

I think a lot of you are getting caught up in things that's can only be spotted when really scrutinising videos to every bloody single frame And not looking at it as if you was racing.
 
I hope this ghosting is a fixable issue if it is in the base game. It seems a total waste to make a game run at 60fps 1080p if all it does is enhance a bad trait of the game. :crazy:
 
Actually I have mentioned it on multiple occasions, notable every time somebody blames my recording equipment and even on neogaf here http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=160620091&postcount=646

People have been so preoccupied with frame rate they've not really been listening.

As ever, YT videos give a good indication of what to expect, you've seen how it looks and plays, now there's enough information out there for consumers to make up their own mind whether they want to purchase the title, or not.

Is it possible to turn Motion Blur on/off on the PS4 version?
 
I still don't get it. I've watched VVV 's videos lots of times and I never notice this ghostin. I watch these vidoes as I intend to play them racing. Eyes fixed on the road/cars ahead and I don't notice it at all.

I think a lot of you are getting caught up in things that's can only be spotted when really scrutinising videos to every bloody single frame And not looking at it as if you was racing.


I literally just played the game in GAME and it's a blurry mess when turning and Alan of Team VVV just posted that the frame rate is not an issue but the blur IS!

Honestly, can you get into game today, if so, go and play it, on the straights it's fine, but turning is just a blurry mess.
 
I've just been into game and the ghosting IS visible in game but really on,y noticeable when turning. On the straights it looks like motion blur, when turning both cars and track detail turn to mush!

I can't buy it like this and am now cancelling my digital ps4 order and grabbing the Xbox. Lesser fx but no mush!

I urge all of you to go see for yourself!

You do realize that can be fixed via game update while hw. difference is here to stay.
 
Ok, suddenly this thread turned from ghosting problems to a motion blur problem discussion. I for myself would have wished to be able to switch off motion blur on consoles too. Never liked the effect and it is eating render time for breakfast.
 
The motion blur is seen throughout but it is not something that has hampered my enjoyment in any way.

It is highlighted more when you pause the videos, as you can see its not always as clear in motion.

Having said that, I'm all about frame rate and with the new gen consoles disappointing in their overall performance, compromise is going to become the norm.

On the whole there is a lot of over analysis, not enough focus on the game itself.
 
I've not read all the 500 pages of this thread, so I don't know if this has been asked but .... I've just googled 'motion blur PS4' to look into it and found peoples issues on other games seem to have been resolved by switching 'gaming mode' on on the tv being used .... does anybody know the settings being used on the tv's in the videos ?
 
I've not read all the 500 pages of this thread, so I don't know if this has been asked but .... I've just googled 'motion blur PS4' to look into it and found peoples issues on other games seem to have been resolved by switching 'gaming mode' on on the tv being used .... does anybody know the settings being used on the tv's in the videos ?
Capturing happens before any image processing is done by the TV. Non 'Game' modes on TV mostly introduce input lag, so the 'Game' mode or 'Direct' Mode disables image processing on the TVs to deliver frames as fast as possible.
 
Ok, suddenly this thread turned from ghosting problems to a motion blur problem discussion. I for myself would have wished to be able to switch off motion blur on consoles too. Never liked the effect and it is eating render time for breakfast.
Yes, it's starting to look like that is exactly what has happened. We know motion blur is in the game, that's very different from the double image seen when freezing the video capture.
I think Alan from Team VVV's post has just served to confuse the issue.
He has consistently said in his YT videos that PCars on PS4 is a gorgeous looking game, and went into good detail about replay mode including pausing the replay, slow motion forward and backward, zooming in and out and panning around the car paused in replay, and it was sharp as anything, the problem was not present. He would have definitely made an issue of it if it was present (ghosting/double image blurry mess especially when pausing).
 
Last edited:
I still don't get it. I've watched VVV 's videos lots of times and I never notice this ghostin. I watch these vidoes as I intend to play them racing. Eyes fixed on the road/cars ahead and I don't notice it at all.

I think a lot of you are getting caught up in things that's can only be spotted when really scrutinising videos to every bloody single frame And not looking at it as if you was racing.

You may be right. I also did not notice it during gameplay. But people need to try it out now beforing buying. They should release a demo :odd: If this issue is there and noticeable now in the game it is going to flop big time which is a shame. They had great chance as DC is the only proper car game and they could cash in with no official info on GT7. In Xbone Forza6 will probably release this year. But for PS4 they could done themselves a favor. Who know what else is wrong with the game ? It might just be another shift3 :banghead:
 
The motion blur is seen throughout but it is not something that has hampered my enjoyment in any way.

It is highlighted more when you pause the videos, as you can see its not always as clear in motion.

Having said that, I'm all about frame rate and with the new gen consoles disappointing in their overall performance, compromise is going to become the norm.

On the whole there is a lot of over analysis, not enough focus on the game itself.

Is it only the PS4 that has this blurry look? So far not seen it on any Xbox or PC vids.
 
Ok, suddenly this thread turned from ghosting problems to a motion blur problem discussion. I for myself would have wished to be able to switch off motion blur on consoles too. Never liked the effect and it is eating render time for breakfast.
It's supposed to be due to the way they have implemented AA on PS4 rather than it being motion blur...Being able to turn it off would most likely make it look like a jaggyfest.

What us PS4 owners need is for them to use the same AA on PS4 as they do Xbone even if it brings the picture down to 900p
 
The motion blur is seen throughout but it is not something that has hampered my enjoyment in any way.

Good to hear mate, thanks for that


On the whole there is a lot of over analysis, not enough focus on the game itself.

:gtpflag:

It's supposed to be due to the way they have implemented AA on PS4 rather than it being motion blur...Being able to turn it off would most likely make it look like a jaggyfest.

What us PS4 owners need is for them to use the same AA on PS4 as they do Xbone even if it brings the picture down to 900p

It's nothing to do with AA, it is the per object motion blur they have used on PS4.
 
The motion blur is seen throughout but it is not something that has hampered my enjoyment in any way.

It is highlighted more when you pause the videos, as you can see its not always as clear in motion.

Having said that, I'm all about frame rate and with the new gen consoles disappointing in their overall performance, compromise is going to become the norm.

On the whole there is a lot of over analysis, not enough focus on the game itself.

I agree Alan, however we are trying to buy the best burger for our money! Do we get a Big Mac or a Whopper!
Can you at least understand that people who have both consoles want to buy the best version.

I have just played project cars in GAME and I absolute love your Channel and videos, I'm also considering becoming a patron. However, I honestly can't recommend the ps4 version I played today over a pc on low/med.

I can see the mush in screen when turning (the ghosting causes a blurry mess on screen) are you going on the record and stating that you don't notice it? If so that's surprising and worrying at the same time.

I can assure you, that if it turned me off, it'll turn other users off too.

I will admit, I never knew about it until I read it here, but I had played on pc, and had only seen videos. After hearing about the issue I went to game, did a few tests and can categorically state that the blur/ghosting when turning is unacceptable and in my opinion I would not recommend this to anyone who cares about clarity. I would suggest pc or Xbox. If you DONT care about clarity, then yes the ps4 version is fine. But you need to get off the fence as it sounds like your scared to make a commitment one way or the other?

If you want a community funded site surly you need to have us trust you and know that we want yo know the truth and that means the good with the bad. I won't pay to have someone not help clarify my purchase?
 
Back