It seems to me that you suffer from the «Need for Speed cant be a Sim» syndrome
It seems to me that You suffer from a syndrome...and it's not a "Need for Speed" one.
By looking at the telemetry alone (the most advanced in any console game) you can tell that the game is trying to simulate something,
Being
trying the
KEY WORD!
if it does a good job or not that is another question...
That's precisely the question...
but it definitly is in the Sim category...
So You keep saying...
it may not be a great sim but IMO is better than most other PS3 racers...
Now, You have to decide Yourself!
Your opinion seems very volatile and uncertain as the weather!
If I compare it to GT5 that is because that used to be the benchmark when it comes to the PS3 and I cant compare it to Forza because unfortunatly I never played it.
What? GT5, that crappy game?! A benchmark?!...NOOOOO!
Yes powerfull cars slide a bit, guess what they also power slide IRL...
Really?!
A Veyron or a CXX?!
Are You sure?
If we were talking about drifting motor sport disciplines I could even agree with You, and if You notice the drivers hired for the game(videos, drivers challenges,etc) come from those disciplines...it's probably a hint to what expect from the game.
The problem is that S2U also tries to replicate very specific FIA GT Series...did You ever watched a race?
I'll indulge You:
Does it even resemble this?
VVVVVV
and Ill just quote, if yor not too stubborn to admit your wrong check the videos from the quote and youll see that it is not Shift that is not acurate when it comes to power slide...
And I never knew one stubborn that could do it by himself...it takes two at least,You know?💡
And I even could agree that S2U simulates well the power slides...the problem is when they shouldn't be there.
Quoting Andy Tudor in a recent interview:
[...]
*P.R. merchandising speech B.S.*
[...]
Who?
Aaah, right this one:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_Tudor
Who does he work for?
What were You expecting?
I would say the same if I were in they payroll...why not choose an "independent" opinion:
I don't necessarily agree with all their reviews but I must recognize they try to do unbiased analysis of games...they don't just bash it...they are not GT5 Fan boys...but they are on the Sim racing reviews business for a while.
]Now you can keep on being stubborn all you like and keep calling the game Arcade...
Thank You so much...very generous and indulging from You.
Tell You what:
You can keep not being stubborn and calling it a Sim!
but you do realize you're a minority, and most of us think otherwise...
Hmm... I see You did a secret poll(careful with unsubstantiated statements and passing them as facts...I heard it is not very AUP friendly
)!
But if it makes You feel more comfortable I'll give You that...I think for my own head and do not need others compliance to be certain of how I feel about a video game!👍