You choose a video that has all assists on (probably filmed before this patch) to proove your point? looks like you want to be right at all costs.
This is getting boring now!
You quoted some one's post with a link to a PC version of the game(You're on the PS3 right?).Trying to prove that Shift is a perfect sim,at all costs like You accuse me of, which obviously isn't for anyone seeing straight.
I posted other Youtube video with GT1 cars-which were the class I was referring to to try to make my point across-do a search on Youtube with:
"Shift 2 GT1 championship" what video pops up first?
Right, the one I posted!
It seemed a fair comparison because:
a)Both are GT1 Tubes.(One of a real race the other from the game).
b)Both are from a race in Zolder.
c)Both are from exterior cams.
d)The exterior cam seemed the ideal one to show the irrealist behaviour of these cars in S2U.
So I didn't carefully chose a video to prove my point(as You ,and others have implied) I posted the first video on the search which seemed good for the comparison for the reasons stated above.
Now I don't use that view for driving(I think I wouldn't even be able to drive like that
), I use absolutely no driving assists(not even ABS), and You know it because I've stated it several times in these forums.Unless You don't believe me and think I'm lying.But when PSN is back on You can check that for Yourself(or anyone as a matter of fact
) unless S2U still has those ridiculous lobby settings where the host can't choose which assists are allowed, thing I sincerely hope has changed in this release of the series!
I couldn't check it for myself yet because I bought in the day PSN went down.
Or even best pick a train or plane...I'll invite You to watch me playing so You can see it for Yourself, maybe over a couple of beers You wouldn't stress as much as You do with our diverging opinions about a video game.
Either way You know me from these forums since Shift 1, You know the rules of the league we ran...I'M proud to be a member of a very restrict group of GTPeers which even in GT5 refuse to use ABS in the organized GT5 events(gathering people of almost all corners on Earth) we participate in.
Yesterday I was cooking my meal and it didnt turn out great guess what IT IS STILL FOOD ANYWAY...
Shouting much are we?
and so is a Sim, good or bad its a Sim
No, taking Your previous example good or bad is still a racing game...unless in Food You also include a Big Mac and a Lobster
Vol-au-vent in the same Food genre...if You do it...well I guess than I would start to understand You.
I got that.
Although, to be honest it seems to depend on the post and time of day...
But I can understand that if you play with a pad/ assist on and through your car around at hight speeds they will slide.
See above...don't keep bringing the pad thing here...You know that are players that still can drive properly with a pad right?-Take Dan Holland example in the GT5 WRS registry quallifying, and I know some very fast pad players...no matter which game they choose.
On the other hand I have several friends who are wheel users, so I've experienced several times playing games with wheels,although to be honest I only tried S2U one time with a DFGT...it's pretty much the same game only the control method is more accurate, immersing and fun. But it doesn't alter the game engine.
Yes I quoted Andy Tudor because you were the one wanting to know what was «underneath the hood» of the game...
False...quote me saying that!
I guess either You are confused(and didn't bother to check) with the conversation I had with boxox, before, where he used that term.Or You are deliberately distorting facts to Your like trying to prove Your point.
I play games for amusement...and take it for what they are...games!
I live perfectly well with the arcadish handling of S2U, I had the first one and played it to exhaustion and enjoyed it, the new one, as said in the ISR preview I posted and You chose to ignore, and quite obvious to anyone who has both deliveries of the series, is pretty much an improvement of the first delivery engine...so it is exactly what I expected:
A very fun arcade racer!
And You quoted Andy Tudor statements trying to prove Your subjective perception of S2U being a sim trying to bring an "expert" opinion to support Your position with some objectivity.
I just pointed out he is a SMS employee so his opinion could never be taken as unbiased in this discussion, don't You think?
if you think Andy Tudor is a Lyer thats your problem...
I don't think he is a liar I think he is a man...on SMS payroll
Which part of the syllogism are You struggling to get?
I know that-never expected it to be-You on the other hand...
but it was desgined to be a Sim and Fun...
Agreed in the last part.
Im begginng to think that your problem is more «there are no Sims on a console» Syndrome
I'm beginning to think You have a Syndrome about my hypothetical virtual Syndromes.
If I stated that you are amongst the minoraty it was not because I started a poll but because I read what other people right here and in other forums about the game and your one of the few that keeps calling this game arcade...
You stated that I am in the minority,
again, based in a total subjective perception of the people posting on a Shift 2 sub forum where there are hardly a couple of hundred-to be generous- regular posters...and where the people satisfied with the game(like me and You) keep posting about patch releases, favourite tracks,cars, etc.
And where most people unsatisfied with the game made one post calling it an utterly crap and moved on to other games and respective forums or sub-forums.
Even than if You were trying to be serious and having a honest discussion You would have noticed for instance that the rants(274) thread has more than twice the number of posts than the raves(126) thread...see a trend there?
Now, me, unlike You, I'm very certain of the way I perceive a game...I don't need to feel that I'm going with the tide to feel comfortable about it...even if I were-which, as I just proved, I'm not- the only one I would feel exactly the same.
The game producer states that they made a Sim
Again with the game producer talk B.S.
There are products which the producer claims You'll grow back hair or loose 30 kilos in a month...do You believe them?
, its being sold as a Sim...
Wrong it's being sold has a game...You just have to pay for it...than You can call it what You want they don't care!
its not a 100% hardcore Sim but it fits the category...
In Your opinion maybe, not in mine!
It's like what the tenth time I tell You this what part don't You get?!!!
And you say they failled miserably and it turned out Arcade...
Don't put words in others mouth( is getting a habit...maybe it's a Syndrome?
)
and against the AUP
I never said they failed miserably-your own words- I said, and even gave the hired drivers example, they've made a very good arcade racer which I'm enjoying pretty much, despite the obvious flaws.
They had success with the first delivery(was Shift 1 also a sim?) why wouldn't they repeat it with the slight improvements they were able to make in one and a half year of developing the same game engine?
Well I got news for you from the replys alone of people answering to you and trying to proove you wrong and from the ones not answering to me you can tell how the majority stands.
False again(are You related to our prime Minister?!
)!
That's what You choose to perceive-I'm getting pretty sure it would be a Syndrome in someone views- since my last post until now...where I read-i.e. the current post I'm quoting there was only one person addressing my post,questioning my choice of youtube video and implying it was a biased choice...I just explained in this post why I don't think it was...I didn't saw anyone addressing your post, but that's absolutely irrelevant this is not a gang fight it's a debate about
a video game!
Also more don't mean better, but I tell what if You're that sure why don't you start a poll?
S2U Arcade or SIM?
PS: if I disrespect the AUP Im sure a Moderator will put me in my place as it happened before.. not you.
If someone reported Yes...I was giving You a friendly hint.
Next time You claim I said something I didn't(which btw You just did 3 times in a single post
), I won't do the same!