Cloud78
The force feedback with the DFP seems kind of weak...
MasterRusty
I've also been thinking that the feedback is a little on the tame side compared to the GT Force wheel...
DF vs DFP comparison:
I have been using the regular Driving Force (non-Pro) with GT4 (Chinese version) for about a month now. I have recently purchased the new Driving Force Pro (DFP) wheel and have logged about 30 hours on it already.
Most of the comments I read are similar to "Yes, get the DFP, you'll never go back to the DualShock 2!" I agree, BUT I find very few comments on how the new DFP compare to the regular DF, and specifically, is it worth the UPGRADE for people who already have the regular DF (non-pro).
Since I can still get a full refund on the DFP (I bought it at BestBuy), I have been doing extensive testing and benchmarking between the DF and the DFP. I have been swaping back-and-forth between the two and comparing them side-by-side. I used the same tracks, cars, settings, etc. for the comparisons. I have also used it under normal gameplay conditions. I fully understand how to calibrate, use and enable the DFP fully (e.g. 100% force), and also tried the different wheel settings within the GT4 options.
My Conclusion and Opinion:
The Force Feedback on the DFP is definitely weaker than on the regular DF (yes, it is set to 100%). On the same track and car, some rumble strips do not rumble with the DFP if I don't drive completely over it. With the regular DF, there is rumble over the same section.
The best test is to use a long straightaway with a fast supercar, going at ~380km/hr. With the DFP, the wheel bounced around a lot
less than the regular DF. Even the G-Force meter was a lot more stable with the DFP. With the regular DF, I had to struggle and concentrate to keep the car on the track (in a good way). I did a test... if I look away for even 5 seconds going at 380 km/hr with the regular DF, there is a good chance my car will be in the ditch. With the DFP, my car is very smooth and there is much less feedback. I can close my eyes for a lot longer and it'll still keep the car on the track. If felt TOO smooth. There was much less struggle to keep the car on the track with the DFP.
[UPDATE #1] The DFP is weaker only when in 900 Degree mode. If you force it to run GT4 in 200 Degree mode (press R3+Select+RightPaddle), the feedback on the DFP is stronger than the DF. I believe this has to do with the "resolution" between the two mode. At 900 mode, the scale is finer, and the feedback is spread over a much wider spectrum. Therefore the feedback feels relatively weaker.
On the plus side, the DFP felt a lot firmer and heavier. The DFP felt solid and less like a toy. The strength of the feedback may be weaker, but the QUALITY is better compared to the regular DF. Losing grip on a tire feels more natural. Too bad the feedback felt weak.
Other observations:
The foot pedals are better on the DFP. I especially like the brake pedal. It has much better VARIABLE resistance. The deeper you apply the brakes, the stiffer it feels. The gas pedal is also improved. It also has variable resistance. The deeper your apply the gas, the more resistance is felt.
adeseta596
The DFP makes every other aspect of the game more fun, but it ruins the rallying. The wheel needs to be 200*, imho. I haven't messed with changing it. At 900* you feel like you'll destroy the wheel by sawing it lock to lock.
The 900 degree is really nice for ROAD courses. I personally don't like it for rally courses. In Rally, you need to turn very quickly but the DFP is stiff and difficult to turn quickly. Also, even though I prefer to use the paddles for quick shifting, it is sometimes difficult because of the 900 degree movement. Your wheel could be upside-down and it could be difficult trying to locate the shift paddles quickly. In those situations (especially for Rally races where you need to turn
and shift aggressively), I have to use the stick shifter. This means only one hand on the wheel. This is not really the fault of the DFP, but I find it easier to use the regular DF for rally races.
The DFP's stick shifter is fun and excellent for that "simulation" feel. But when I need to shave seconds off for that illusive gold licence, I find it faster to shift with the paddles.
Summary:
My conclusion is YES, the DFP is an excellent wheel to get... IF you don't have a wheel at all. I would choose the DFP over the regular DF. The DFP is overall a better wheel than the regular DF. HOWEVER, if you ALREADY have the regular DF, I do not think the DFP is worth full price for just an
upgrade.
Having said that, these are just my humble opinion and my side-by-side experience with both wheels. Trying to help those deciding whether to UPGRADE from a DF to a DFP.
I have added some pictures below of my setup used for these tests: